SRGMP-Challenge/updates/comments.. - Page 93

Posted: 18 January 2006 at 7:47pm | IP Logged
by tansen ----------------------------------------

I hope the show saregamapa should not become plateform for professional jeoulessy of mentors, and the india-forums opinions the regional bashing.

Take saregamapa music as an source of musical entertainment .
------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------

I agree with Mr. tansen. It's ridiculous to see these great musician's fighting like this just to add some more juice to the program. I think the genuine quality of singing is more than enough for Sa Re Ga Ma..and Indian Idol contestents are no way near the contestants of Sa Re Ga Ma. I like the asthetics of the Indian Idol as compared to Sa Re Ga Ma but for me music and singing comes first and then asthetics .Lot of new budding musicians have these big guys as their role model and that's why Gajji pls. stop adding masala to the pure musical program.

Originally posted by: gatheee

lol now AS only wants western votes to be counted... wat does this guy think of himself? and he wanted this why did he wait till reults of other 3 regions were announced?
Guys does this look same like walkout of those3? they also walked out after Debo's votes were annaounced..
AS, now we know that u were brains behind that walk out too.. if u din want hometown votes counted u should have said so in begining not after watching Hemu in 3 rd place.. WE WANT INDIA'S CHOICE NOT JUST WESTERN CHOICE. WOULD AS PAY THOSE VOTERS THEIR MONEY BACK WHOS VOTES HE DOESNT WANNA COUNT?

Hemu u r best n dont worry u join Nihira n gang of real good singers.
TODAY, dEBO WAS BETTER SINGER THAN OTHER TWO BUT THATS MY CHOICE.

GATEE? -- DEBO IS OUT...

There is no point in blaming vinit/hema/himani or any other contestants. Only the Director and Mentors are responsible for whatever happened. Why didn't they announced result yesterday only, their interest lies in making Money through Ad/SMS etc. SA RE GA MA PA lost its charm due its controversies. I definitely agree that Quality is better in SA RE GA MA PA but indial Idol format is better (Less Controversies). NIHIRA IS BEST

its a black mark on the history of saregamapa as hemu is voted outand debojit got the highest votes.debojit do not deserve any place even at top ten.yes i agree that the three contestants did same thing as ID does.but why we r blaming AS for their walk out.in my opinion AS is the best mentor among those 3.HR is just like a joker who applies every tricks to hipe vineet.ID is very cunning person.when he left the show then wats the need to come back.he just played a trick to get votes for non deserving vineet.ID is also responsible for most of the controvercies of the show.AS is the best among them as he always ask for votes mentioning the singing qualities of his desiples.he also favoured the singers of other gharanas and also gave chance to hema,himani,rajeev and even nihira n ujjaini who belongs to other gharanas to sing in his movie.so no matter hemu is out but aadesh will always be remember in the show for his qualities, comments, support to all the contestants and as a best mentor.in my opinion vineet should win the challenge.if debu wil win then it would be second black mark on the history of saregamapa.

sorry,i mean non deserving debujeet

also the performance of hemchandra was the best perfomance of challenge on friday.this perfomance will always be remembered n also the injustice done by the people of india.

region based or not, now debojit will be winner, he has all sympathy votes, shocking that hemchandra goes out, by far he is the best male singer in this contest,

however my strong feeling is that , to change the format from next time, there should be judges and also public vote, should be given a weightage of 50-50,

otherwise all deserving guys and gals will lose the battle like this time

You know what guys? I can't believe I spent so much of my precious time on such a sick and unscientifically designed music program. I am sure unhappy that Hema lost. But now I am not even going to blame the public coz it was not the public who did this (ofcourse they could have done it too if they had a chance). it was the bad design with so much potholes and opportunity for rigging. Let us be cool and look at the truth. What if there was a genius programmer, computer, telecom etc. who could hack the lines and repeatedly vote? Does Gajji fellow have the infrastructure and design to counter any such mischief? How Debo gets such votes all of a sudden from rock bottom? and as someone rightly said from a place who doesn't speak Hindi and watch Hindi programmes much? Now I am ok with that too as long as you dont call someone as 'best singer' ..say popular choice. Ye theek rahega. or much better popular choice of East ..Popular choice of west and overall popular choice. Anyways I feel we guys in US had better things to do than to watch this useless programme and moreso waste time writing stuff on that. If you give the choice to public (where emotions run bigger than the talents ..rem how even poor people stand in heat to just see some celebrity/politicians's son or daughter or relative etc. just coz he is so??) what you expect? North Indians who though in general are good people, at heart can they give votes to some south Indian guy to the extent to make him win? Comeon guys let us face the truth. The other way is true. South Indians (again this is not a generalization ..but true to most extent) would have given votes to a north indian guy .. coz mysteriously they consider themselves inferior to them.

But the highlight is Tabu made my day. She had the guts to speak what she feels (I am not saying it necessarily is true) is right unlike people who speak sickening sweet words when they feel otherwise. I can understand one has to speak so at a funeral or a hospital etc. but not at a competition and surely not from people who have nothing to care or worry about. Did you all notice? Tabu is the first guest who said something against Vinit despite knowing that HR is obsessed with him. I liked her. Not that she was favoring Hyd guy blindly. There were 2 occasions when she didn't choose Hemu. man! she has guts! I hope all or atleast most of had ..and talk truth even if that was bitter ..at least from people living here. This most probably my last post friends. Nice being with you all for some time (again nice and sweet words 😊 heyyy heyyy as I said this situation supports such sweeet words ..doesn't it?? Have fun!

I am sorry guys I said that was my last post and am still writing. I dunno if this become an irresitible habit now 😭 If so, then Gajji not only spoiled the show but spoiled my habits too. I just forgot to add one more point to ridicule the sanctity of this voting system. I go for singing (by the way I don't sing that bad) and then have a god father who is a rich guy in my state or anywhere and then make him vote for me a million times and win the best voice of India. Hmmmm interesting. or is it that we are unnecessarily freeting on somrthing which is to be just watched and shrugged? Well, as people with conscience can we do it? I don't think so. Maybe Querty is right that everything is staged. I am disappointed when AS said (when asked at the begining of the show as to what he thinks would happen to Hemu) " I hope he loses" I didn't see a correlation between what he said later to justify it and his statement. None of those guys has a stature of a celebrity.

* ID is like a silly joker who cries if someone takes away his pacifier and stops crying when they thrust it in his mouth
* HR screams loudly in support of Vinit desperately hoping to hypnotize us to believe that Vinit is indeed a great singer. He shameslessly alters the data. Vinit was never consistent if you look at the initial rounds. It was Hema and only Hema who got green althrough. Bunch of jokers
* AS is now caught between supporting Hema or losing his friends support

CONGRATULATIONS HEMU! YOU ARE A GEM CHANDU! KEEP US THE HARD WORK AND SINCERITY AND HUMILTY THAT YOU HAVE. THAT SMILE AFTER LOSING ..WAS A WINNERS SMILE. WAITING FORWARD TO HEARING YOU FOR ABHISHEK AND MUKTA ARTS AND MUCH MORE. 👏