SRGMP-Challenge/updates/comments.. - Page 29

Well my second post here... first one was an introduction post.

I think that srgmp, should have a panel of judges, say 5 and public voting should also be there. If the pUblic voting is totally different from the judges choice then the judes should have the authority to override the public voting.

There will be issues but, this way we can make sure that the good talent stays. Well the final 12 are all good and they all are well exposed to the industry... I think its just a matter of who's luck stays with who?

As ID said... jo dikhta hai woh bikta hai.... I guess that is what happens with public voting...

hi... i'm new here... i jus wanna say that theres somethin dodgy bout sa re ga ma pa challenge 2005... like everytime i watch this program.. vinit is always gettin full marks from the judges.. even if he didnt sing that gd to deserve it... i'm not sayin vinit is a bad singer.. cos he aint a bad singer.. he is alrite.. he is nothin special to be praised by the judges more than other contestants. why did sharib leave.. can the public vote be that bad? is that a chance that this show is fixed? i seriously thought sharib was goin to win this... i thought he was the best... i hope this isnt the end of him n hope to c him more!

Originally posted by: Radhika87

hi... i'm new here... i jus wanna say that theres somethin dodgy bout sa re ga ma pa challenge 2005... like everytime i watch this program.. vinit is always gettin full marks from the judges.. even if he didnt sing that gd to deserve it... i'm not sayin vinit is a bad singer.. cos he aint a bad singer.. he is alrite.. he is nothin special to be praised by the judges more than other contestants. why did sharib leave.. can the public vote be that bad? is that a chance that this show is fixed? i seriously thought sharib was goin to win this... i thought he was the best... i hope this isnt the end of him n hope to c him more!

well said.

himesh openly favors vinit and neglects ujjaini and paresh. how mean of himesh.

after seeing sharib out of the show n nihira & hema had a tie..i m sure dat this show is fixed..how come sharib is out n rajiv & paresh are still in...thats just retarded!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I have been following SRGM/SRFMP for ages now. I have been following this Challange also very closely. Is there something wrong with SRGM team and Abhijit (the bald singer). Today when they showed JL and his gharana's history they did not even mention Abhijit. They talked about Saptak, Sharib and Bhoumik........I was surprised. And if you all have observed he was not called for the initial 'Brahamastra'.........I hope he has not joined Anu Malik camp (though that may be good for him)

Hi All,
Can somebody tell me the site where I can vote online for Sa Re Ga Ma Pa candidates....
Ish

Dear Radhika87

Vinit doesn't get full marks every time. He gets it when he deserves. And he is not allright. He is best amongst the mails. Sharib is out because his capabilities are limited.

Originally posted by: Ayeshahaksar

I don't understand what is your problem. Do you even have ny personal favourite or are you in the forum just to criticise all the singers beacuse as far as I am aware I have always seen you only criticising the singers.

Vineet is agood singer and the cap does look really cute on him. Way to go Vinit. Like you said earliar Sharib couldn't have asked for a better gift than getting a chance to sing with Lata Mangeshkar. All the best to you Sharib and I am sure I am going to see more from you soon.

Hi Kashish,
I feel really sorry for my posts been misinterpreted by you. You seem to be ill prepared to have anything said against you (sorry I didn't know Vineet is your favorite). It has not been against you or anybody specifically for that matter in the first place. In furtherance of my earlier comments, I would like to clarify that I have commented probably on 2-3 occasions only (you may refer to the left column). Your claim is exaggerated that I am here to criticise all the singers -- as I have just commented on one singer only. This points to your biased views. If they can be biased here they sure are biased in your voting (supposedly perfect) as well. To your utter dismay I still don't have any personal favorite in the show (if shan be spared). But it doesn't mean I don't like the show, its mentors, singers, their singing or anything else. It is the show of the day that govern my comments. What I see, on the basis of that I make my favorites and non-favorites on the spot itself. I could have shared my favorite with you dear Kashish, but I seriously doubt your mental balance as not to try your level best to dump him/her. Anyway, there is a way. You can keep your eyes closed during the show to believe more on the voice of your soul rather than the maya of eyes. Of course vineet is a good singer. When did I say he is not a good singer? I only said there are better singers than him on the show floor itself. Please don't look away from the stage to find worse than vineet. There you might find plenty better. So, keep focusing on your blind voting. Maybe next quazi is in the offing....
O, Yes, the cap really looks cute on him....and anywhere else for that matter. After all a cap is a cap is a cap and a cap. If it is good then it is not the cap's fault to look good anywhere...even on a duffer's alike student.
If I be the judge, I would have chosen surely vineet giving the kid age benefit. But, the real problem would have come afterwards, because there aren't much children's films nowadays. 😆. Oh, sorry, I should have been like 😒 as I am here to criticize. Right, Kashish?

Originally posted by: MAHEK2002

Hi Kashish

I am a newbie out here but I did have a look at all the discussions going on. I must say that whoever this (orthodox😕 ) is does seem to be a very negative character. Anyway just for your info even I am facing the same kind of issues on the net. I hope the problem on the site is rectified soon so that we can vote for our FAV contestants.😊

Hi Mahek,
I appreciate you for your insight that you have identified the character in comments. You know it is a high level of expertise and human quality that is attained with years of toil. And here are you, with this capability to recognise the character as negative. Better to recognize the negative even if you are not capable of recognizing the positive. It saves. The only flaw is, elders have said that what one sees outside is his/her own reflection. Please, don't see negative because I can't see anybody as negative including you. There is hope. Try. I know you can.
(a naughty thought please bring your ear near: By the way, you must have built a hell of a rapport with Kashish with a lit bit of buttering😉.) Take care and just enact your name -- what a beautiful name. sorry again! I was supposed to be a critic only🥱.

Hi Guyz,
Why are we after Vineet? There are contestants like Rajeev and Twinkle getting greens while Hema and Nihira have got yellow. Well, Vineet definitely has got great potential but the main thing that mars the show is how HR speaks about him all the time. Come on HR, give others a fair chance too and give us a break. It is high time for Gajji to wake up and intorduce some sense to the mode of elimination. Personally, I feel 50% weightage should be given to the popular votes and 50% to the decision given by a panel of judges (similar to Filmfare Awards). Readers of this forum please try to spread the word over the internet through other forums and otherwise so that we can save this great show from loosing the purpose of its existence. Also, please vote for the best talent and not for somebody from your hometown or state. May the best talent win at the end.