SRGMP-Challenge/updates/comments.. - Page 28

Originally posted by: asha rao

roy, I disagree with your views, Your advise to AS and ID shd have have been given to HR. let me give u some illustrations. take AS. when rakthima lost in the first round adheshji came on the stage and consoled her that not to loose the hope she will be given a chance in his film.secondly he encouraged himani by giving a gift [goggle] to her . thirdly he always encouraged rajeev [though he was not upto the mark some time ] but never discouraged him and finally when hemchandra was in tension adheshji came on the stage and lifted hema and said not to loose the confident and promised him that he will be given a chance in his next film [entire songs of the film for him].

now coming to ID he encouragd paresh and said that he sings well and nihira he always say she is best,and for twinkle and debojit ,niladri also he encouraged them that too on the stage and he never hesitate to criticise them if they r not upto the mark. he is very frank.

As far as JL is concerned , he came on stage and expressed his happiness on the stage for swananda and sharib abhijit and also he stood with them when they were eliminated and expressed his displeasure openly attacking public for their poor taste specially when sharib was eliminated..but he was very supportive to all his contestant of his gharana.

I never saw that spirit with HR . all along he has been praising only vinit and pleading to public to vote for favourite vinit and never plead for others.every time he come to stage before vinit starts singing and put cap on him and scarf as a token of his blessing to him. why is he not doing the same to paresh ujjaini or to other contestants who were in his gharana earlier. if at all he praise some time to others his comments like ,why did u wear the cap [ to paresh] and also commented that 'u will get half of the vote for your personality' as if they are not singing well. they too were appreciatd by the judge like jagjit singh, sameer, sureshwadker ,pandit chaurasia etc etc. HR is little different from other mentors who is not treating his gharana's participant uniformly and he is always biased. he never gives generously point to other gharana's contestant but other mentors are giving good point to his gharana.

I hear you, but HR spotted vineet from the very begining. He's very honest about Vineet that " one day this guy will be the star" etc etc.. infact he confessed many times that he's biased about Vineet. As far as Paresh is concerned ( according to me), he shouldn't be there in the first place. Public voting/messing brought him back, and infact HR again commented in once of the episodes that he thought " Paresh is a public star, now he sees that he can also sing too" 😊. Infact there is clear distinction between a "Public Start" and "Singer".

I think ID should start doing this, beleive in his gharana and start marketing for them. Again you are human and understand that he may/will have some biased opinion ( he did show some biased opinion about Paresh), so I don't see anything wrong with HR praising and asking public to vote for Vineet.

To be frank again, I think Vineet is capable of indeed wining the contest. He's been more consistent than the other singers. 😊

none of SRGP finalists are original..but they r good
and talking about Qazi?..keep watchin

Hello,
I am a regular viewer of all these music shows. SAREGAMAPA has a very high standard for music. We do not want to choose somebody who is people's choice. I don't think people are voting fairly. They are trying to vote for somebody from their region or sympathy votes.

Gajendraji, please stop this voting and bring some good judges who can pick a good singer based on training and singing.

Few participants are already fail to sing on a tune and yet people have vote them. This is just not fair to other participants who are doing far better than them.

Please keep up the standard of this show.

Mentors are clearly favoring some singers and at this point I don't think they should do that. All the singers at this level are very good and it could be anybody's game. Feel very sorry for Sharib. 😭

Shneila

I am a fan of SRGMP and my urge to discuss it with others brought me to this site. This is my first post.

I am really appalled at the people's voting choice. I doubt someone is manipiulating it as suggested by some posters here. I know, I might upset many of you with following comments but I will say anyway.
It simply shows mental bankcruptcy of us as a nation. We are too influenced our race,religion,state, languague , region and clan that we cannot make objective decision about what is good and bad for us and society as a whole. Sharib, Raktima and Sunanda were victim of not playing region/Language card well and they paid for it. Where as idiot like Rajeev, Ujjaini , Twinkle and Debojit are still there because they managed to play cards well. Jatin was right in his comment.

After all we are same people who repeatedly voted for monsters like Lalu,Mulayam, Modi,Jaylalitha and Uma again and again.
What we get , what we deserve.

this is my first post..i and my family are great followers of this show..i was really shocked to see Raktima, then swananda and then Sharib got out of the show. U all may be well aware of the praises Raktima got fm mentors when she sang the Roja song and Rang de Rang de and much before in HR songs round. She was excellent. Swananda got out only bcoz she could not perform well in the last 2 rounds of performance round. But atleast Sharib would hv been in the show while a person whose pitch goes off very often still remaining in the show. and though the show of Hem and Nihira getting same% of votes is yet to air in Dubai, i was shocked to read the update. and its a disaster that Rajeev got more votes than Hem and Nihira.

Pls can we all ask Gajendra singh to adopt to the system of judging the singers by the renowned and knowledgable judges????

i do agree that mentors hv stopped training the participants and it is quite obvious in their singing..

hello
i think u r rite madisamp...right in ur views but i think its now not possible to bring a changein the system of judgement...i think they introduced public voting cos if the judges vote then there may arise differences between them ...think this is made to stop controversies and ofcourse to know the taste and views of public...but one never knew that public had such a gr8talent ...talent that sends talented singers out of the show....no one must hav even guessed abt all this...but trying is not bad...its good to try..
and even people should hav the least sense regarding voices and atleast sur ..trained singers and untrained singers...if they consider even these basic facts ...the proper ones who deserve to be in the top five will be there in the top five....hope junta realises this and starts tapping their brains
pls pls pls vote for the talent but not for anything else....
till then adios

hey mahek and kashish!
Im also facing the same problem,only time i cn vote is wen sum1 has the link at the bottom of their comments,but i cn bvote only once lyk tht...n wen i go straight on the net i cnt vote AT ALL..

yeah...u all r rite...almost everyone is facing the same problem....no one is able to vote for their fav's
but this time inspite of this disabled online voting if they say that they r counting online votes in this week's episode...then this online voting is 4 namesake...lets see..
adios..till then

Originally posted by: Ayeshahaksar

Hi I am from Dubai and I am trying sincerely to vote for all the best singers but the website for NRI Voting just doesn't work. Is there any alternative site or address that we NRI can vote.

PLEASE DO LET US KNOW

LOVE

KASHISH

hey kashish nothing against your post but u try and vote for your favorite and not the best coz singing is an art and there r no scales to measure it, hence no superlative like best could be added here..film music is essentially pop music and means popular hence voting (public voting) is the only way out..or may be i'll try and remind you of mohamed vakil , bela shende , the winers of megafinals were chosen by judges...do u have any idea where they r?