Most justified elimination ? - Page 4

Originally posted by: Wazwan

When we talk abt singing - the priority should be sur, tal & Bhav. We cannot ignore sur at any way when it comes to music. And v cannot compare Yatharth with Yashodhan or Priyanka with Shreyasi. If Yatharth's prerference is emotion than Yashodhan concentrates on sur. Priyanka again has a rich base voice where Shreyasi is simply versatile. My best may be different from yours but every kid has his own espaciality in his or her genres here. I love all of them. And its just a beginning of the show - we hv to wait and watch for the Most Justified Elinination.😛

what abt yashodhan's dil jo na keh saka? It didn't have dard imo..... he did the expressions fine, as he always does....


Aghorpade:
yeah his ya rabba was incredible....

I dont agree with you here my dear - Mintyblue - every singer has his own limitations and he can do wonders if he regards it and use it carefully. Sawan beeto jaye by Yatharth was shrieky though Judges praised him a lot. High pitch and correct sur both are different things. I adore Yatharth, for all romantic numbers he sang, but where comes classical based singing (where you hv to be technically correct) I can think of Yashodhan only.

Debolina, I think was justified...but barely so. I think Shalini should definitely have left by now, but she's so over-hyped that it doesn't matter. Last week, it should have been Shalini or Antara. Yashodan....regardless of how he sung, he was better today than he was in the previous weeks. Anyway, I look at this as if Shalini weren't still in the competition, because she'll be that one that we just can't get rid of, so you have to look at the second worst in most cases. Farah wasn't her best last week, but I don't think she should have been eliminated.

Originally posted by: 3zfreebird

Yashodhan is the best, the most talented, takes his singing so serious, doesnt involve himself in any kind of dramas (thats the reason he got eliminated i guess) and the most genuine kid among all. He is the best and he is the Champ for me.

I just love the innocense in his face, the most cutest as well 😊

At what point have any of them been involved in any drama? And if I remember correctly, he was crying, which does constitute as drama. don't get me wrong, he is a good singer. if anything, he got eliminated for his lack of expression. although, today, i noticed him putting a conscious effort into singing with expressions...for once. his sur is pretty good though.

I wonder you rank Yashodhan this way - he is no doubt among top 3 boys - his elimination has shocked everyone - also pl. watch today's show and than justify his elimination.

Originally posted by: Wazwan

I wonder you rank Yashodhan this way - he is no doubt among top 3 boys - his elimination has shocked everyone - also pl. watch today's show and than justify his elimination.

Impossible. Yashodhan was nowhere near the worst this weekend.

Swarit was hopelessly besura on both days. Shalini was nearly as bad, and while once again she got away with tuneless numbers, you have only to listen to the originals to understand how besura she was anyway!

There can be no doubt. This show is an utter and complete travesty.

Originally posted by: chutneyx4404

At what point have any of them been involved in any drama? And if I remember correctly, he was crying, which does constitute as drama. don't get me wrong, he is a good singer. if anything, he got eliminated for his lack of expression. although, today, i noticed him putting a conscious effort into singing with expressions...for once. his sur is pretty good though.

Look at Shalini, she always sings with extra expressions which doesn't look nice to kid of her age, the faces that she makes is too annoying, Swarit in between the song raised his lil finger pretending that he wanted to go to the loo which of course was scripted and then he talks too much, Priyanka always talks about her coming from a conservative place bt she already is a stage performer. These are a few points for ur knowledge.

Yashodhan was crying becoz he got eliminated and that was natural what else do u expect from an 11 year old kid???? And what you call "lack of expression" is the seriousness on his face when he performs with concentration and the kind of songs he sings require a lot of concentration not dancing and style. He is always in sur and never tries to change the song for his comfort.