Most justified elimination ?

Page

Next Last

Poll

whose elimination was most justified

413185

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

hmm I'm fine with debolina going...

Quote

Frequent Posters

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

It's none... When Debolina was eliminated, she wasnt the worst that week, so on what basis did she end up with the lowest score?? Same case for Farah too... In Yashodhan's case, I have to listen to next week and then comment... It looks like the decision is made on the singing of Saturday alone or of both Friday and Saturday scores added together. They dont look at previous rounds at all, since the score is more dependent on the guest judge each week. In that aspect, I find it hard to believe that Khailash Kher gave the lowest score to Debolina last week!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

mintyblue

@mintyblue

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

All were better than Swarit, Shalini...

Antara has a very kiddish voice but at least she acts her age

Quote

413185

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: akanna
It's none... When Debolina was eliminated, she wasnt the worst that week, so on what basis did she end up with the lowest score?? Same case for Farah too... In Yashodhan's case, I have to listen to next week and then comment... It looks like the decision is made on the singing of Saturday alone or of both Friday and Saturday scores added together. They dont look at previous rounds at all, since the score is more dependent on the guest judge each week. In that aspect, I find it hard to believe that Khailash Kher gave the lowest score to Debolina last week!!

are u sure its on that performance alone or collectively?

Quote

413185

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: mintyblue
All were better than Swarit, Shalini...

Antara has a very kiddish voice but at least she acts her age

😆

yeah but shalini and swarit was more fluid than yash

Quote

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: gengarjetty2

are u sure its on that performance alone or collectively?

Last week, they said that the scores for girls are the added scores from Khailash and Abhijeet, and for boys, it is the added scores from Khailash and Alka... Similarly I assume this week it would have been the added scores of Pritam and Abhijeet for girls, and Pritam and Alka for boys. Maybe this week they would have scores from the Love Aaj Kal movie director too... But it was based on the singing of that particular week alone - this I am sure!! Hence I dont think Debolina's elimination was justified...

Probably next week Alka would have deliberately given the boys low scores after seeing her two girls have been eliminated because of Abhijeet's scores!! 😆

Quote

mintyblue

@mintyblue

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: gengarjetty2

😆

yeah but shalini and swarit was more fluid than yash

More fluid? as in?😕

Quote

akanna

@akanna

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: gengarjetty2

😆
yeah but shalini and swarit was more fluid than yash

Agree with mintyblue about Antara! She acts like an eight year old even with having her own band!! In fact I like her mom's attitude - "in our family no one can sing, so whatever way she sings, it sounds good to me"...

BTW OBJu, what do you mean by more "fluid"?? I agree that Yash lacked facial expressions, but some others seem to be lacking that as well!! We cannot comment much on it as they are all little kids...

Quote

413185

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: mintyblue

More fluid? as in?😕

hmmm maybe i used thwe wrong word.. i just feel hes a bit mechanical ... not free flowing- AAH! thats the word i wanted .. even the judges said it na?