Who would you like to see as a champ - Page 16

Originally posted by: akanna

Exactly!! 👏 👏 👏

OBJ, you have impressed me BIG time!! You are a matured teenager now!! Wow!! No joke, I am serious... Many times, you made silly comments like a teenager and you have turned the tables now! Very impressive!! 😃 👏 👏

Even to make an artist, especially a singer, it would be hard if they dont have the talent within... 😃

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

YES YES YES!!!!


FINALLY!
Too much classical KILLS the song.

Khatarnak, these melodies are based on the 7 notes.. it isn't necessary u need to base it on a raga..

rd burman's songs were so simple and melodious...

there is an article on mukhesh ... some classical guy asked an md why inspite of classical training he had to go by cycle while untrained mukesh had a mercedes.. the md gave him a tune.. the classical guy failed!
thats why he went by cycle 😃

also rafi hardly had any training,kishore used to merely observe singing classes of some relative of his, yet they souned better than manna dey..

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

silly matured teenager eh?😆 😉
Bet two sureelas u take the one with the better voice, expressions,style etc..
thats why i liked ash more than anwesha (tho anwesha had an excellent voice too)

Originally posted by: Khatarnak

I totally disagree with you guys - all the legends we talk about were all classical trained (even Rafi Saheb), and one should know how to utilize their talent (all the songs by greats Rafi ji, Khan Sahab and other legends have utilized their talents in ghazals and even in bollywood and that was the reason - why they were so much better then today's singers. I am not going to get into the debate of Kishore Kumar and Rafi Saheb, but a true ustaad would be able to tell you the difference (OBJ you should know it better, people like a lot of singers but that does not mean they are really good, you like these songs for a short period of time and then eventually they disappear.

Originally posted by: Summer3

WA I notice that sometimes you cannot help yourself.😆

Yashita has some good performances too. In skill I think it is Vaishali.

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

YES YES YES!!!!


FINALLY!
Too much classical KILLS the song.

Khatarnak, these melodies are based on the 7 notes.. it isn't necessary u need to base it on a raga..

rd burman's songs were so simple and melodious...

there is an article on mukhesh ... some classical guy asked an md why inspite of classical training he had to go by cycle while untrained mukesh had a mercedes.. the md gave him a tune.. the classical guy failed!
thats why he went by cycle 😃

also rafi hardly had any training,kishore used to merely observe singing classes of some relative of his, yet they souned better than manna dey..

Originally posted by: Khatarnak

OBJ - I wasn't expecting such a illogical reply - or may be you are just arguing for the sake of argument - there are so many besura singers in this industry (I am not not going to name any - as you know that better) - should I assume for you singing is limited to film industry.

Originally posted by: akanna

Hey, how did this thread disappear into oblivion all of a sudden? I am bringing this back to the front page! 😉 😃 BTW, Jojo, both OBJ and myself were talking in terms of singing in movies... 😃

Originally posted by: alujna-21

i want vaishali to win directly because i like her voice,