Royal Investigation Report On Todays (06.12.08) EP

Here is the Royal Investigation Report (Written Update) on Today's (06.12.08) Episode




Special Guest: Amir Khan

1. Soumen (Jai Ho Gharana)

Song: Chaand Sifarish

Singers: Kailash & Shaan

Judges Comments:

All Judges: Super Hit

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

To me it was not a very good performance by Soumen. He didn't do proper justice by singing this wonderful song. He could do much better but failed. I am still missing Toshi's (SVOI 1) rendition.

To Me: Hit

2. Pratibha (Lakshya Gharana)

Song: Radha Kaisey Na Jaley

Singer: Asha Bhosle

Judges Comments:

All Judges: Super Hit

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

Today was certainly not her day. The performance which we always expect from her it was definitely not. It was a soulless performance. Didn't touch me at all. It seems that she wanted to end the song as soon as possible which Shankar also admitted the same.

To Me: Hit (can't remember I ever gave her this mark or not)

3. Vaishali (Rock Gharana)

Song: Yaayire....Rangeelare

Singers: Asha Bhosle & Aditya Narayan

Judges Comments:

Amir: You sang very well. Beautiful

All Judges: History

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

Another wonderful performance by her on a row. It was a rocking performance.

To Me: Universal

4. Yashita (Dhoom Gharana)

Song: Yaaro Sunlo Jara

Singer: Udit Narayan & Chitra

Judges Comments:

Amir: Very Good.

All Judges: Super Hit ?!?!?!?!?!

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

No doubt the performance was wonderful. She sang extremely well. Didn't get the point why the judges gave her only Super Hit.

To Me: A deserving History

5. Zaheer (Rock Gharana)

Song: Oh Mitwa Oh Mitwa

Singer: Udit Narayan, Alka & .......

Judges Comments:

Amir: You sang very well.

All Judges: Super Hit

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

It was not an excellent performance but a very good indeed. The only reason judges gave him Super Hit because he lost Sur in the beginning.

To Me: Super Hit

6. Debojeet (Dhoom Gharana)

Song: Maa

Singer: Shankar Mahadevan

Judges Comments:

All Judges: History ?!?!?!?!?!?!

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

Some how I liked Voodoo King's, Dabba's this performance. He was very good but not an excellent one the way all the judges reacted. Another over & over hyping as usual.

To Me: Super Hit

7. Asma (Rock Gharana)

Song: Poocho Jara Poocho

Judges Comments:

Amir: Well Done

Aadesh: Super Hit

Shankar: Hit

Pritam: Hit

My Comments & Deserving Marks:

A very average performance by her. Completely agree with Pritam that, the energy was completely missing.

To Me: Hit

At the end, on Asma's special request Amir went to the stage and sang with her. Then all the judges requested him to play drums and performed Papa Kehte Hein.

Thanks.

Antar

I felt it was a day of mediocre singing from all the contestant, lacking soul in the music with drama starring Yashita mom as lead actress, Debo as special child, and Asma given second chance for survival.

For me weakest performance:
1. Asma : Weakest performance. She killed both the songs, Aati kya Khandala was better. Why was she given second chance ? and then debbo joined her. It reminded me of Salman special, just chill chill song.
20/200 (5- Pucho zara and 15 - Ati kya Khandala )

2. Yashita: Attitude does not mean she is singing good. Another murder of song. Yashita mom drama conitues. 25/100

3. Debo: It had soul, but lacked the pronunciation of words. Again special child drama. Even if he is special child, he has come to TOP 7 and he did more then other can do. 30/100

4. Pratibha: As said by Shankarji, she tried to finish the song hurriedly. I doubt if any other judge can finger point at contestant from their team. Hats off to Shankarji. Other would have asked for sympathy.
60/100

5. Zaheer, Vaishali and Soumen were better 65/100

ohh the show is coming on in 10 minutes lol!

but yeah...everyone is using the word royal these days...maybe too many kings effect!

xoxo

Originally posted by: v12345

I felt it was a day of mediocre singing from all the contestant, lacking soul in the music with drama starring Yashita mom as lead actress, Debo as special child, and Asma given second chance for survival.

For me weakest performance:
1. Asma : Weakest performance. She killed both the songs, Aati kya Khandala was better. Why was she given second chance ? and then debbo joined her. It reminded me of Salman special, just chill chill song.
20/200 (5- Pucho zara and 15 - Ati kya Khandala )

2. Yashita: Attitude does not mean she is singing good. Another murder of song. Yashita mom drama conitues. 25/100

3. Debo: It had soul, but lacked the pronunciation of words. Again special child drama. Even if he is special child, he has come to TOP 7 and he did more then other can do. 30/100

4. Pratibha: As said by Shankarji, she tried to finish the song hurriedly. I doubt if any other judge can finger point at contestant from their team. Hats off to Shankarji. Other would have asked for sympathy.
60/100

5. Zaheer, Vaishali and Soumen were better 65/100

A wonderful analysis except Yashita's case.

Hmm, it makes me sad that the contestants didn't sing well today, the song selection is so great, and they don't live up to the mark.

How was Aamir Khan? Charismatic as usual?


Thanks Antar for the Post-Mortem ... whoops Royal Investigation. 😆

Originally posted by: antar

A wonderful analysis except Yashita's case.

I felt Yashita was overconfident while delivering her song, if she had sung it without attitude, It would have been perfect song. Because of her extra effort suder was suderrrrrrr extra errrr was added at many places.
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MdFVVLeohvI[/YOUTUBE]

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

Hmm, it makes me sad that the contestants didn't sing well today, the song selection is so great, and they don't live up to the mark.

How was Aamir Khan? Charismatic as usual?


Thanks Antar for the Post-Mortem ... whoops Royal Investigation. 😆

Completely agree with you. The song selections were fantastic but the contestants failed to perform to the mark as like as the Salman's special. No doubt the Chocolate Khan was fantastic,Charismatic as usual.

King needs to find a royalty post for you/...you dont seem like a commoner

GPA of today performance: a flop show and many disappointed

Special Guest: Amir Khan

1. Soumen (Jai Ho Gharana) 😊 B+ 3.3 third topper. this song suited his voice. can do better

2. Pratibha (Lakshya Gharana) 👍🏼 B+ 3.3 fourth. not upto mark, no fault in singing, did not connect
to heart

3. Vaishali (Rock Gharana) 👍🏼 A- 3.7 today topper. better then other.

4. Yashita (Dhoom Gharana) B- 2. 7 fifth. was she overconfident or something wrong with
me?

5. Zaheer (Rock Gharana) 👍🏼 B+ 3.3 second topper.

6. Debojeet (Dhoom Gharana) 😕 B- 2.7 6th. hai na was not clear and missing at times,
pritam puran in defence. 😡 Gimme a break !

7. Asma (Rock Gharana) 😡 F F 0 0 she killed two beautiful songs. 😡

8. Aamir Khan 👏 A+ A+ 4 4 one for song and one for drum

Originally posted by: nausrat_fatali

GPA of today performance: a flop show and many disappointed

Special Guest: Amir Khan

1. Soumen (Jai Ho Gharana) 😊 B+ 3.3 third topper. this song suited his voice. can do better

2. Pratibha (Lakshya Gharana) 👍🏼 B+ 3.3 fourth. not upto mark, no fault in singing, did not connect
to heart

3. Vaishali (Rock Gharana) 👍🏼 A- 3.7 today topper. better then other.

4. Yashita (Dhoom Gharana) B- 2. 7 fifth. was she overconfident or something wrong with
me?

5. Zaheer (Rock Gharana) 👍🏼 B+ 3.3 second topper.

6. Debojeet (Dhoom Gharana) 😕 B- 2.7 6th. hai na was not clear and missing at times,
pritam puran in defence. 😡 Gimme a break !

7. Asma (Rock Gharana) 😡 F F 0 0 she killed two beautiful songs. 😡

8. Aamir Khan 👏 A+ A+ 4 4 one for song and one for drum

yup vaishali WAS the best.. soumen was great.. yashita is getting overconfident with her sob stories..

asma should get negative points tho.