Was that slap necessary? I was disappointed

Vayuputras thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Hi, I'm a silent reader in this forum. This is my second post.

Yes I was very very disappointed with Ananya's behaviour y'day.

First of all, how can a man come and 'say' he has been murdered? If he has been murdered isn't he dead? How can he send a mail from his id after death saying, "I have been murdered?" His ghost?

If Shreya was dumb to send such mail, isn't Ananya shrewd enough to reason it out?

Why didn't she give Kabir a chance to give his POV? In earlier promotion episode Ronnie made her understand that and she realized and made batti with him. Hasn't she learnt a lesson?

To err is human. To repeat the same error is inhuman. And not learning from the error is a sin.

Do they need Ronnie every time to make her understand Kabir? I pity Kabir then. Their life will always depend on Ronnie.

How can she just say, "I want a haan ya no." And go on to slap him?

Doesn't she know that Kabir risked his life to save her from human bomb?

Doesn't she know that Kabir saved her in Bhaagi case?

Doesn't she know that Kabir was concerned for her in arms dealer case?

Hasn't she made Kabir tell n' no of times ,"I love you."

Isn't she the one who told him, "main yeh haath chodne ke liye nahi pakda?" Wasn't that genuine? Looks like it isn't.

When her mom told her to choose between the 2, she told her "how can you take such a momentary decision? Aap ko pata hai such kya hai?" Isn't she committing the same mistake now?

After going through all this, her going back to square 1 is not accepted at all. Even if she feels that love for her father is greater than Kabir's love for her. No. I don't agree. How can she return the ring? Unacceptable. Atleast for me. I don't know about others.

Sorry Ananya. Sorry CV's. Wish you had taken a different route to solve this mystery. This MU, slapping, not giving an opportunity to the other person to express his POV is all very standard, normal, below ranking, soap ingredients. I expected something different from #Reporters. I'm sure you have been giving us a very different show which made me very happy. You made me get hooked on to a show for the first time in my life.

But in this route, I'm disappointed.

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

3.1k

Users

18

Likes

109

Frequent Posters

jojocheeku thumbnail
Groupbie Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Hi, I'm a silent reader in this forum. This is my second post.

Yes I was very very disappointed with Ananya's behaviour y'day.

First of all, how can a man come and 'say' he has been murdered? If he has been murdered isn't he dead? How can he send a mail from his id after death saying, "I have been murdered?" His ghost?

If Shreya was dumb to send such mail, isn't Ananya shrewd enough to reason it out?

Why didn't she give Kabir a chance to give his POV? In earlier promotion episode Ronnie made her understand that and she realized and made batti with him. Hasn't she learnt a lesson?

To err is human. To repeat the same error is inhuman. And not learning from the error is a sin.

Do they need Ronnie every time to make her understand Kabir? I pity Kabir then. Their life will always depend on Ronnie.

How can she just say, "I want a haan ya no." And go on to slap him?

Doesn't she know that Kabir risked his life to save her from human bomb?

Doesn't she know that Kabir saved her in Bhaagi case?

Doesn't she know that Kabir was concerned for her in arms dealer case?

Hasn't she made Kabir tell n' no of times ,"I love you."

Isn't she the one who told him, "main yeh haath chodne ke liye nahi pakda?" Wasn't that genuine? Looks like it isn't.

When her mom told her to choose between the 2, she told her "how can you take such a momentary decision? Aap ko pata hai such kya hai?" Isn't she committing the same mistake now?

After going through all this, her going back to square 1 is not accepted at all. Even if she feels that love for her father is greater than Kabir's love for her. No. I don't agree. How can she return the ring? Unacceptable. Atleast for me. I don't know about others.

Sorry Ananya. Sorry CV's. Wish you had taken a different route to solve this mystery. This MU, slapping, not giving an opportunity to the other person to express his POV is all very standard, normal, below ranking, soap ingredients. I expected something different from #Reporters. I'm sure you have been giving us a very different show which made me very happy. You made me get hooked on to a show for the first time in my life.

But in this route, I'm disappointed.

[/QUOTE
Completely agree with every word you have written.
Truly disappointed with the slap and this route of the storyline.
There is no justification for that slap,especially for someone who was ready to die with her.
Getting angry and confronting is fine, returning the ring very stupid, and slapping totally unacceptable.
For me now Ananya's's love for Kabir looks shallow . Whereas Kabir's ilove is actually unconditional.
Sad to see the story take this route.
Have been watching reporters with so much passion and interest, but after yesterday , it's back to square one.
The slap was justifiable only if Kabir was involved in the murder, which he is not and even Ananya's knows that. So slap was just for hiding the truth? Doesn't gel sorry.
crazy_rinks thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
slap is integral part of tele shows.

heroine slapping hero is a must in all the shows.

Ananya's character description and slap didn't go well in this show.

entire track of Ananya doubting Kabir and breaking engagement looks CVs have decided to divert their initial thoughts. few contradict characterization included in the end.

reporters turned out to be typical masala in the end.

sad that show lost its initial charm of reporting and turned out to be family drama

Danseuse thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

@Vayaputras : The slap defined the father-daughter relationship. It just happened, but it proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Ananya loved her father very much and missed him. To compare that with Kabir's love for Ananya is not correct. The slap was impulsive and unexpected, I was taken off guard too. 😃 But I applaud Ananya for doing it. It's possible that later, she may regret it and even apologise. 😊

The Creatives would be giving the viewers a convincing reason about Kabir's decision to lie to Ananya. Lets wait for that and then dissect!


-Rekha
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Danseuse


@Vayaputras : The slap defined the father-daughter relationship. It just happened, but it proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Ananya loved her father very much and missed him. To compare that with Kabir's love for Ananya is not correct. The slap was impulsive and unexpected, I was taken off guard too. 😃 But I applaud Ananya for doing it. It's possible that later, she may regret it and even apologise. 😊

The Creatives would be giving the viewers a convincing reason about Kabir's decision to lie to Ananya. Lets wait for that and then dissect!


-Rekha


I don't understand why ananya is not allowed to be angry? this is her father we are talking about, not the next door neighbour.
idonkno thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
I respect your opinion but then Ananya is not wrong on her part. See you gotta keep in in mind that Ananya's love for Kabir started as hero worship because he was the only one who supported her father...even though her love has come a long way and is no more a hero worship but her father still remains a scared connection in KaYa's relationship and Kabir still remains her hero somewhere (remember how she called him a 'perfect' person during their conversation in the car after the bomb was diffused??).. but that one detail changed the entire scenario for her.. trust, love and respect are the key ingredients of any relationship..she did not doubt his love but the trust and respect she had for him suffered a major setback with this one revelation...that slap signified her heartbreak as a daughter..it was indeed an impulsive reaction from her side but it was so because the reality turned out to be excruciating for her!
Edited by idonkno - 9 years ago
-sharada- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: pomegranate


I don't understand why ananya is not allowed to be angry? this is her father we are talking about, not the next door neighbour.


Sure. She is allowed to be angry. But, she is the one who forgot all about her father all this while right.. For all the tall claims she made about becoming a journalist for her father's sake, what has she done so far?

Basically, her anger is without any rhyme or reason.

Ananya is ready to believe an anonymous mail, but not the person in front of her? Hits him like no tomorrow and then breaks off her engagement? What kind of anger is that?

For all the time she dished out gyan about no nafrat, be practical and blah.. now what is she doing? Classic case of easy to preach but not practice?

Seriously, what are the CVs trying to show...
crazy_rinks thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -sharada-

You voiced my opinion too when you say this. For 100+ episodes they kept the story and characters close to reality. Now, all of a sudden they have made it similar to any other serial which is high on melodrama and low on substance. If they wanted to solve the SK mystery, they could have taken a separate route to show us that.

I don't agree with the thought process that there are hurdles in any relation, and this kind of MU is going to make Kabir and Ananya stronger etc. That is so ridiculous.

In real life, if there is trouble after engagement, you either sit and sort it out, or take help from friends and family to help you get your point across, but you don't break the engagement. That is a cowardly act, which doesn't sit well with either the characters or the story, as it has been shown to us so far.

I have given up hope on this track and have come to the sad conclusion that end of the day all serials are the same. It is unrealistic to expect them to be different or unique for too long.

Exactly my thought.

after 100th episode real essence is gone. CV taken the viewers for granted.

Ananya not even thinks like a reporter. her action was simply labelling Kabir as a killer.

by breaking engagement without giving a chance to speak up his side, she broke all her promises. she didn't keep blind faith on him, She promises to give him all the happiness was also broken. she let his hand from hers.

In one episode CVs killed the Ananya we seen in last 100 episodes.


pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: -sharada-


Sure. She is allowed to be angry. But, she is the one who forgot all about her father all this while right.. For all the tall claims she made about becoming a journalist for her father's sake, what has she done so far?

Basically, her anger is without any rhyme or reason.

Ananya is ready to believe an anonymous mail, but not the person in front of her? Hits him like no tomorrow and then breaks off her engagement? What kind of anger is that?

For all the time she dished out gyan about no nafrat, be practical and blah.. now what is she doing? Classic case of easy to preach but not practice?

Seriously, what are the CVs trying to show...


the writers once said they will try to be realistic as possible but some things will be fictionalized, so I'm guessing this is what they were talking about.

For ananya, the entire world can betray her but not her kabir and today he finally fell from that pedestal she put him on. she is angry because she trusted him with everything and now Because he did not tell her the full truth, she feels betrayed.

Ananya for the most part has a good head on her shoulders, but she is emotional when it comes to her father. it is one of her biggest weakness and now she is thinking from a perspective of a daughter. as a human, even I have said and did a lot of things out of anger, but did look back on my behaviour and regreted it once i cleared my head. not sure where this is going but I will hold back from labelling ananya and showing a little tolerance.



violette thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

jst put urself in Ananya's shoes.. jst a few minutes ago u r contemplating with ur mom with faintest of hope tht may b may b ur father is alive.. and u r expecting some positive news from ur BF and suddenly this bombshell strikes u and ur BF has audacity to not jst confirm it bt to confidently tell u on ur face tht yes he was murdered. And he was thr wen tht happened. And tht right in front of his eyes he saw him murdered.

Kabir knew her reaction and subconsciously he wanted to b damned by her for his lie, for what he couldn't do to save SK. Hence his such blatant audacity. He wanted to incur her wrath. He gave her a chance to vent out her pain, anguish, and hurt for his betrayal.
Ananya's reaction was an anger-filled reproach for what he did to her. It was natural reaction.
Agar sahi dimaag se soch hota to ab tak maaf bhi kar diya hota. Bt u have to agree she cudnt have been in right state of mind to think so logically or reasonably and give him a benefit of dbt, especially wen u trust someone with ur life and never expect him to go wrong. Its painful to see ur trust broken with such rude harsh shock.
any other time she wudnt have reacted so volatilely, bt the preceding events had led her mind to b very fragile. Tht is where Shreya scores the points. She weakens the mind and hits it when thy r at thr vulnerable best.
It wud definitely take some time for her to grapple with the truth behind his lie.
Ananya's character had always been so emotional and reactive. She never thinks before she speaks or does. She reacts spontaneously to such highly charged situations.
I think we shud judge both Ananya and Kabir's characters with an equal eye. Though the makers havent done tht justice in thr show.😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".