Was that slap necessary? I was disappointed - Page 4

Originally posted by: Vayuputras

I'm hooked on to this show only because its a different show. I hate leaps and melodrama. That's exactly why I still watch this show. Some of the episodes I must've watched 'n' no of times. I'm crazy abt this show. I would still watch it till the end. No doubt abt it. This is the only show I've been watching with keen interest. I'm not a soap watcher. I've not seen any of Rajeev's earlier serials which you all keep raving about. Nor Kritika's, except her dance shows.

If as you said, i found the heroine clinging to hero's T Shirt, crying, shouting "tum mere sath aise kaise kar sakte ho bla bla bla bla bla" and hero crying miserably, trying to convince heroine "main majboor tha, bla bla bla" i would've simply closed down on it. Thank god it didn't happen.

But still, I would've preferred if the creatives had taken a not-so-travelled path for this incident. They have been highly creative all these days. They had raised their own bar themselves. Suddenly I found it dipping. I couldn't digest when a dead man is sending an email saying, "I've been murdered" and the heroine believing it!

Anyways, as you rightly said, things should sort out hopefully.

Originally posted by: Danseuse

Ananya believed the first email. For a daughter whose father disappeared 8 years back and the body was not found, the family would always hav hope of his return. Its a very natural feeling. Its about being positive and believing in GOD. While she discussed with her family, her hopes of her father being alive was very high. Several scenes hav already been shown to the viewers about the closeness of the family to the father figure.

The second email shattered these hopes. What shocked her more was Kabir's name in it so she turned to him for confirmation of the incident. Where does the scene show that Ananya believed the second email came from her father? Once Kabir confirmed with a Yes, she realised her father was dead.

As simple as that. The entire sequence has been projected very well. 👏

Maanav has faltered big time. When Kabir finds out the hacker, he is dead for sure...😃

-Rekha

Originally posted by: pomegranate

to Vayuputras,

Hope is a dangerous thing. All this time Ananya hoped that her father may still be alive because there was so no body found. maybe it was too far fetched or too illogical, but ananya felt a spark of hope. she wasn't a reporter but a daughter who wanted to see her father alive after 8 years of agony, is that so unbelieveable?

The credibility of that email was insignificant when kabir confirmed he was there during the murder. in one blow, ananya's father was officially dead and that kabir was there while it happend. it was not the right time to analyze that letter and even if she did, what difference would it make? would that change the fact that she could no longer ignore? her father is dead and kabir was the witness.

hopefully she will dwell on everything after her mind clears.

Originally posted by: Vayuputras

Ananya is not a normal next door girl. She is very intelligent, smart, has an analytical mind and has cracked tough nuts with this shrewd mind. Agreed at that point of time it mattered that her father is dead and that blinded her completely. But when a person like Kabir who has showered his love on her was just a witness but not a murderer, this strong reaction is undermining all her intelligence. Even a normal person like me can immediately say that dead men cannot send mail. It wasn't expected of Ananya to overlook this. It looked as if she was only waiting to blame Kabir for some reason and she achieved it.

I'm sure she will dwell on everything after her mind clears. Again Ronnie might help her see the reality. 😛

Anyways, I'm not personally undermining anyone in the show nor here in the Forum. It was just a feeling and I shared it. I'm happy so many emotions have emerged here pro and con. Thats what i call a balanced discussion. Very good. I'm happy. Thanks for everyone who contributed. 😊

Originally posted by: asthana.shaily

Originally posted by: -sharada-

This will surely be taken care of, in the upcoming episodes. As for Ananya, at present, she is not in a condition to think of all these things. All of a sudden, one fine morning, she gets the biggest jolt of her life, in the form of an email from her father's email id after a gap of 8 years, whose death has affected her and her family a lot, and then she gets the second jolt much bigger than the earlier one that her father was murdered in front of Kabir, whom she idealised and adored for his honesty and truthfulness. At present, the thought of her father being murdered and moreover, being cheated by someone whom she not only loved dearly but also idealised are killing her. Moreover, Ananya always preferred being Ananya, the girl rather than Ananya, the journalist. Even in cases like Mahi, Ananya didnt act like a true journalist then, in such situation, how can Ananya, the journalist will take over? We can only complain about this, at the end, if it is not taken care of. At present, its too early to comment on that

Fair enough. She is the same Ananya who says she has good manners to had to invite Shreya to join them for dinner. Didn't want to be rude to her BFs ex. What kind of manners does she show when she slaps someone? Justifying her behavior because of anger or emotion doesn't change fact..that what she did is wrong..

I am not justifying her behaviour. I am just saying that Ananya is no DEMI GODDESS to act wisely and let me tell you dear that, its my personal experience that in real life, people hit each other not only out of impulse but because of habit. Dont believe me? Come to me, I will show you the endless scars on my body that my husband gifted because he used to always light off his cigarette by pressing it on my hands rather than ashtray. And mind you, that was his HABIT!!!

Originally posted by: asthana.shaily

No I won't call it filmy. I totally understand where you are coming from. My ex husband did not abuse me physically, but he did mentally. He went to court and said I had an affair with about 9 people, including my neighbor, office colleague and childhood family friend. Judge was quite favorable in terms of saying there is no credence in his allegations, coz at this rate, anytime a girl talks to a guy, it can be construed to be an affair. He also gave me custody of my son, till he is 18. That said, I did hear about unfair judges when my case was in court. That was the biggest worry till the verdict came out. I am sorry to hear about your experience.

Originally posted by: violette

The show has always been focussed more on Kabir. His character has been explored inside out and ppl naturally feel more sympathy for him. Ananya is jst a shadow of Kabir. We understood Kabir better bcoz of Ananya. Her character was simple and more justice cud've done to her character. She cud've been equally a central point of this story, bt focus shifted drastically to Kabir's story and his never ending raaz.. now even Ananya's central story SK has shifted its base to Kabir where as it shud've been a converging point for both Ananya and Kabir.😳

isiliye kabhi log Ananya ko gaali dete hai to kabhi Kabir ko... a writer shud put forth views of both protagonists to let us make an unbiased judgement..(unless its a deliberate attempt for amajor eye-opening twist in the end. More like famous O'Henry twists!😳) bt it hasn't happened.. lot of twists were left hanging open in the air, subjecting to multiple interpretations and speculations right from Kabir to Tarini to Ananya and even Richa!

Thnk god we all new beforehand from spoilers tht Shreya was a grey-shaded character, which turned out to b complete evil andpsychootherwise we might have had a Shreya fan club here on the forum!😆