Critics' Corner # 11 - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

139

Views

9.2k

Users

17

Likes

341

Frequent Posters

-mesmerised- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#61
Posting what i posted in Krishna's episode analysis thread... 😳
Another outstanding performance by KT/YM today! Fell in love with Shanak all over again because of their heartfelt performances! 👏
The Shanak scene; pain evident in both their eyes... Khanak as she reluctantly allows her husband to remove all traces of her suhaagan status, and Shaan trying in vain to be the stronger of the two by holding back his tears, unable to bear the sadness in her eyes. The replacement of the things that she is incomplete without... followed by that final hug as she breaks down completely and he offers her the only thing he can... solace in his arms. Loved it!
For me, today's Shanak scene was on par with some of their 'golden' moments from yesteryear... the depth, emotion, dialogues and music all added to the quality of the scene.
For some reason, i found myself comparing it to their confrontation scene post Shaan's accidental engagement to Natasha. Then they were going through a 'seperation' of sorts, but it was fuelled by misunderstanding, hurt, anger and a misplaced sense of betrayal.
Today, once again they were separating - although temporarily - the hurt still intact, but this time coupled with love, understanding and complete trust in each other... *sigh* ... they have indeed come a long way.
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#62
Good morning all😊

7th June epi-

Mangalsutra and sindoor have become so important in TV serials...so such scenes are expected... and I found it a bit filmy. But what elevated the scene was Yashu's acting... superb, the way she (i mean, Khana) breaks down and hugs Shaan. I had tears in my eyes... that's 2nd time in 3 days now,,,, RBO CVs, what is this? u want ur viewers to cry?... just kdding... that sob conveyed much much more than everything else in that scene!

My first thought when I saw Khanak cry like that was 'How r these 2 going to manage without each other? They just cannot'! Kudos to the actors for creating that impression among viewers, that ShaNak are inseparable...

Yashu's dialogue delivery, which was replayd when Shaan was putting the other chain on... brilliant! she gt the words and diction spot on! Well done Yashu👏

Shaan putting sindoor of his blood reminded me of a similar scene in QSQT!

Duck acted well. Jas Karan is always good. Am glad he has been retained.

KT is probably still recovering from the marathon performance he gave last wk. Must have drained him. It was all so emotional. But he got his groove back in the end scene, when Shaan goes to drop off Khanak at Gangubhai's.

Is it really hard in Bombay for a married couple to get a place to stay? Strange...

Looking forward to Khanak -Gangu bhai face off... Bhavna and Yashashree- awesome combo!😃

Good day all:)


dr.dsr thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#63
Good Morning, All!!
Just about everything has already been said...will add my 2 cents, too! 😊
Episode Analysis, dated 7th June 2011
Shaan's 'introductory' scene with Gangubai...a thumbs up for the serious tone underlying the comedy on display...Shaan, despite the mayhem, paying complete heed to Gangubai's address... soon to become his own!!
Brownie points, well-deserved here to the CVs for the consistency shown towards Shaan's 'serious' avatar, keeping his trademark budhthalness intact!! 😆
Loved the 'rose scene'...the significance of the plastic flowers going way beyond any of the real stuff that Shaan has ever gifted Khanak earlier!! 😊
A memory, so special...each flower underlying every attribute that the ShaNak equation is built upon...
Absolutely loved the way Shaan says "Ab tum jhooth bolna bhi seekh gayi ho na, Khanak!!"...beautifully understated, that!! 👍🏼
A thumbs up for the maturity displayed by Shaan in handling such a sensitive issue...loved the 'bharosa' moment before the moment unfolds!!
Khanak's disbelief and complete inabilty to come to 'terms with the situation'...nicely done, that!! 👍🏼
In the entire mangalsutra meets khoon aka sindoor sequence, the moments that stood out for me, really were...
The thoughtfulness shown by Shaan in getting the chain for Khanak...knowing very well, that it can never measure up in significance to the mangalsutra...yet, knowing his Khanak equally well...that for her, this gesture will always remain as significant, if not more...
LOVED the final 'breakdown' moment!!
Khanak was FABULOUS...Shaan too completed the moment beautifully with GRADUALLY engulfing Khanak into his fold...the initial 'lag' reflective of the pain plaguing his heart on the decision taken...and, the final CLASP...indicative of the bond...RENEWED AND STRONGER!!! 👏👏👏
What an amazing unspoken bond these two share...exemplary, really!! ⭐️
RBO moment of the day...
The last segment outside Gangubai's...
KT and Yashu pitched it just right!! 👏
The apologetic yet completely in love husband...reassuring his wife of his presence despite the absence...and the final 'check-list' with a reminder of the 'act' to follow...Khanak's brave front initially with the pain however, seeping in...with the final freeze shot...
BRILLIANTLY done that by both Shaan and Khanak!! ⭐️
A new 'beginning'...a new journey...
ShaNak have a new address...
Part Duck's and part Gangubai chi kholi...
Tora thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#64
Doc d you said it all
kt ym are blessed with the emotions
hopefully shaan's maturity is long time overdue I hope it stays
loving this serious phase of shanak too
hoping more scenes like this in future
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#65
June 8, 2011:

Nice episode. Another emotional one. Shaan leaves Khanak at Gangubai's house.

Yashu stood out! Beautiful expressions👏 The 2nd time she goes into Gangubai's house, the way she looks at Shaan, captured the Khanak from Dhulwadi's feelings- here is a girl, from a village, does not know anyone in Mumbai (except for her sasuraal-waale, now ghaayab)... and her husband has asked her to pretend to be unmarried so that she can stay in a cheaper place. And she trusts him enough to follow his decision... but i cudnt help thinking 'what is this you have done Shantanu? The girl trusts you completely and you ask her to do this?'

Such questions come to mind because of the excellent acting and direction. Congrats to the actors and the CVs for that.

I liked KT's acting when he was back at Duck's place. Especially the way Shaan says 'I mish you too'. Really nice touch, that one!

Yashu-Bhavna meeting- good. Liked it.👏 Bhavna's acting skills are known. She seems to have got into RBO mahaul quite well.

Pappi- funny. 😃

Some of the scenes they showed in flashback today, of the remarriage one, we didn't get to see them on last saturday na...good scenes. Because that question was bothering me, as to how Khanak agreed to move out of the house without a question. Any sensible woman would support her husband but would also ask 'How are we going to do this? where is the money? where will we stay?'... Am glad those points were addressed somewhat today, thru the flashback scenes.

Missing K-family😭

Khanak's salwar suits- 👍🏼

Duck- good as usual😊


shanakyasharan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#66
june 8th epi agh again a mindblsting one:)

i loved d MISH U2 moments a lot n d odhni scene...dil legayi mera...d pain love restlessness i their eyes was all evident..they dont need dialogues at all just their expressive eyes


v have a noodle scene coming up 2moro...reminds me of d shanak noodle scene in august..old days:)
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#67
Ah... Karish... dont remind me of the old noodle scene... I will start 😭... what a scene that was!
jparker thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: tvrasika

Ah... Karish... dont remind me of the old noodle scene... I will start 😭... what a scene that was!

Sigh.. Gaayu, me too am stuck in the olg Goldenn RBO times... even if the new track is as good.. miss those times...Cry
shanakyasharan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#69
gaayu jeesu...i know wat a noodle scene.i loved noodles more after tht shanak scene...d look he had wen she puts d noodles into his plate hes staring at her lovingly
man i know d scene by heart as yet:))))))
Tora thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#70
Gaayu I am loving this new track with a emotional bonding still thinking the same thing
I mean she is trusting him so much I know it's for her better ness but still they are newly married
hopefully next week we see Shan moving their too
and the separation scene kudos to the actors for their splendid job
talking trough their eyes very well done




Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".