Critics' Corner # 11 - Page 12

Created

Last reply

Replies

139

Views

9.2k

Users

17

Likes

341

Frequent Posters

tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
June 28, 2011:

Shaan sings in chorus. Bechara... cudnt help feeling bad for him a little bit.

Yashu had a lot of lines to say today and she did well. But i kind of switch off when someone gives long speech, LOL... so didn't attention to all that she was saying.

Looks like everyone in the GB house is trying to find a footing except Khanak.

Won't Khushi and Simran ask Khanak how she will pay for her rent?

Or is Khanak's rent is in exchange of her work in the kitchen?

What work does Simran do? How come she is at home during the day?

Adi's flirting with the secretary- usual scene. doubt there are girls like that even today...don't they watch films and TV?

Wish Adi wud get rid of that headband.

Shaan-Khanak scene was nice... realistic, the way a couple would talk.

Shaan-Simran scene- once again, to show a girl so naive, when living alone in Mumbai, hmmm...

It seems like a lot of people do not like Shaan-Simran scenes.

Remember similar outburst here during Khanak-Sunny (Suraj look-alike) scenes...

My feeling is, they are still trying to settle the new characters into the story. Because they hav introduced 4 people in about 2 wks, it will take time to give each of them a place in RBO.

There is a reason why the story shows Shaan and Khanak pretending to be unmarried. In reality, this would not happen. But here it has been set up so that the audience can see other characters fall for Shaan and Khanak. That (the cvs think) would give rise to comical and may be serious situations later on. That's the whole point of this track.

We just have to wait it out. We will get scenes of Simran dreaming of Shaan or Adi dreaming of Khanak. But the fact is, Shaan-Khanak will always be together and eventually everyone will come to know they are married. that will be the highlight of this track.

In Jan, We got scenes of Sunny kissing Khanak's hand and that didn't go well. So may be the CVs don't want to show any physical closeness between Khanak and Adi, but show such scenes between Simran and Shaan? I don't know for sure... am just guessing.

Otherwise. I cannot figure out why there is opposition for Shaan-Simran scenes, but not for Adi-Khanak.

Personally, I find Simran's character less realistic. I prefer Khushi's character. it seems more real. hav seen such aggressive, ambitious girls. but this Simran type, nope... not seen.

Not sure about Khanak's dress. The low neckline, the bright color...is that Khanak?

Even Simran's dress is in the Asha Parekh style. Is that in fashion now? Whatever happened to good old Salwar Kameez?

Precap- interesting.


.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
i think i might know the reason why i think that adi khanak are more acceptable tha shaan simran. this is strictly my POV.


adi khanak are subtle, while shaan simran scenes are too in your face kind. i mean no one likes to hear romantic background music, endure eye locks and physical contact between one from their fav jodi and a third person.

adi khanak scenes are a bit easy flowing. the day they become filmy like shaan simran's. people would stop liking them as well.

the precap is a good example. could have been a very filmi situation but seems like it would be handled lightly, at least i hope so.
Edited by zennnn - 14 years ago
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
@ zennn

Interesting... i see what you mean. Adi is a bit innocent too, but not silly like Simran.

May be bcos a majority of fans are girls, they don't like to see such a clueless girl like Simran, in this day and age? Adi is like a typical guy... Men fall easily for good-looking girls, LOL... but usually girls are careful na, at least to start with?

Again, I am making a guess.
dr.dsr thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
Episode Analysis 28th June 2011
Ok! This one's gonna be quick...my supreme tiredness not being the only reason, really!😉😆
Liked the all-involved Shaan...completely engrossed in his singing!👍🏼
Khanak and her 'realistic' ways...Yashu delivered exactly what was expected of her...but the whole Khanak 'pravachan yatra' got pretty exasperating after a point!
Khanak being the 'epicentre' of her new home too...interesting thought, that!👍🏼
The scene could have been handled much better, though...being non preachy for starters!!
A thumbs down for the terrace shenangians...
Khushi completely OTT...Adi kinda getting there...Pappi largely predictable!
Simran and her naivete!! Completely infuriating, IMO!!
Firstly, such nubile nymphets come across as too 'filmy'...Shaan and her 'sapnon ka rajkumaar' chants...only endorse the same!!
Thankfully, Shaan appears convincingly disinterested...nahin toh, the 'mellifluous' BG would have defo proven to be the much needed 'catalyst', if it hasnt already!😆
The only saving grace in today's epi...
The ShaNak scene!!
Beautifully conceived...Superbly executed!⭐️
The transition from "OMG" to "This is pure bliss"...Bang on!!👏
The purposeful, persevering, pensive Shaan...Pleasantness Personified!!⭐️
Khanak recognising her 'new found' Shaan, and endorsing the same simply with her eyes...Pleasantness Personified, yet again!!⭐️
The Ganpati bappa touch...the kheer gesture...
And, ShaNak simply lingering on...Pleasantness Personified to the T!!!⭐️
In conclusion, today's episode yet again proving...
The characters of the newbies is poorly sketched! Especially since they are pitted against the likes of KT-Yashu, they run the risk of simply fading into oblivion! Case in point...the terrace scene following the ShaNak scene...sure stood out like a sore thumb!
To add to the madness, Simran and her 'aimless' ways can get hugely annoying...her desperation to dress Shaan's wound...her moronic 'forgetful' antics...to name just a few!😡
CVs, request you to strengthen the characterisation of the new entrants...
Khushi could tone down her OTTness!
Simran and her lovestruck ways...Adi and his flirtatious ways!!
May both their bubbles burst soon!...May Simran-Adi nurse each others hearts soon!😃
Edited by dr.dsr - 14 years ago
shanakyasharan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
excellent dyo:))))))))))


loved d epi
right balance but still cant b much better...shanak were simply breadthtaking:)
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
July 1, 2011:

I liked Shaan's outburst scene. Vintage KT👏 I say 'vintage' 'cos we rarely get to see him this way aaj kal.

Didn't like Khanak's blue salwar with red dupatta. Gosh, what a color combo😲

The powerful scene kind of lost its wind bos of the easy way in which Khanak got manaofied by Shaan. Am assuming this means we will get one more such scene, and that time, Khanak wil lose it and give it back to Shaan. And may be, even take up a job.

Shaan did say many important things to Khanak but dont think she took them seriously...

When Khanak told Shaan to help Simran, only one word came into my head- 'vishesham'!!!😡 In Tamil it means something like 'bas ek yahin baaki reh gaya tha'!

Simran's character is the only one in this new gang that is not able to garner any interest or sympathy. The CVs have to give her some reason to exist. She cant just live to meet her sapnon ka munim ji or whatever... thats an objective in life for a girl to move from Kanpur to Mumbai? 😲

Poor Pappi and those bade bade books😲 😆 Shaan should help Pappi, not that dreamy girl...

Wish Adi's headband gets lost somewhere.😡

Adi-Khushi scene- i liked it. Khushi spoke some truth there... the way men (and society in general) differentiate between girls who are good to be arm-candies, as opposed to girls who are 'wife material'. Sad but true.

Will we see Khushi transform into a gharelu types? the actor is doing ok as tomboy. cud do better.

SK as GB- a delight👏 Her eyes- so expressive!😊

Khanak's red salwar suit- nice. The camera person needs to be told to raise the angle a little upar😡

The first one to find out abt ShaNak marriage would be either the one who gets hurt the most, which means Simran.

Or one who would use it against ShaNak. Cud it be Adi? Cud he turn negative? How can there be a story without a villain? Who is the next villain?

precap- whatever... they r bulding up Shaan-Simran story... its going to have a big fall.


shanakyasharan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
july 1st,2011

frst of all i wanna mention i saw sukanyajis epi now!
she was hilarious ki hadh man!
d way she says shaanpatti ishtyle thanku keep shafe dhistance.omggg she was superb superb superb.im totally fida over her:)

kt n yms chemistry wid sukayanji is bang on:)



it was a lovely epi n as u mentioned.Real Shanak love n story...this was it completely👍🏼


superbly captured by cvs:)
perfect balance...
i liked khushi teaching khanak a lot.simple bond:)

khanaks ...8joy hui, thanku, biziee*.superbly brought out by ym:)...shes just perfect n a natural:)


kt took d cake in d frst scene completely:)

awesome is d wrd fr him...these 2 make shanak... REALITY👏

Tora thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
July 1st 2011
epi all over was okay only loved the frustration part kt took the cake
second I loved simran because she is teaching khanak English
khanak adi scene khanak was mind-blowing with the expression loved it
gb she was amazing with her dialogues
kg pappi Khusi they were good
but the first shanak scene really loved it because it was so realistic between husband and wife wanted them to have more struggling because they both excels that scene
SPN_JD_Addicted thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
Loved the first scene.So realistically done.But bit disappointed with the way they resolved this so quickly!Khanak tho didn't even understand the importance of what he said and Shan had to just say sorry and that's it?Man,he got it easy or what!!

Adi and Khanak scenes are being done well but why so cheesy for Shan-Simran.All this may be build up for the maha epi and may be Simran or Adi knowing abt ShaNak(hopefully!!)but once again these CT's need to understand that the characters should revolve around ShaNak

Adi and Simran could be a pair!Still wondering what's Khushi doing and as well as Pappi!!

kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
Posted what I posted in the DT...
**********************
😆😆😆😆😆Just watched the epi...😆😆😆😆😆An okay epi really...not a 350 epi really...but then expecting to much always is bad...😆😆😆😆😆 where RBO is concerned...LOL
Okay first of all wishing Karan Godwani to Get Well Soon heard hes sick...poor dear...Love him as Adi...hes damn cute...
Ok now my Epi Analysi ...I kow tooo late but as I say its never too late and better late then Never...😆😆😆😆😆.sorry for the lame jokes but me in a homourous mood...😆😆😆😆
Loved Shaan romancing his wife towel...He knows her towel and thus was making do with it...not knowing that His Wife Towel was being used by Simran...the Mad Dreamer who has fallen for him...😆😆😆😆😆
If he hadn't said my wife towel or Khanak wouldn't have come and said what is my towel doing here or Simran must have used it...it would have been a bad scene as then we would be like does not Shaan the hubby know his wife's towel or her scent ..but well done scene that...
Simran her is the one who is so lost in her La La Land that she did not put 2 and 2 together and think oh I was using Khanak's towel..thus it can't be me but then...ome girls have no brians and she is the Prime example...
She is in for a bad fall and no one is to blame but Her Own Self...for building Mountains out of Ant Hills or Castles in the Air with out substance...
The whole Adi and Khanak scene superb really well executed..directed and acted...LOL..Got to love Adi tenaciousness to get Khanak to help him ignoring all the looks from her..and great to see Adi get Khanak's cahracter in the few days he has known her to the T...that she can't refuse to help anybody that Khanak is a kind hearted person who sees no bad in anyone really...
Well enacted and directed scene ..the subtlety with which Khanak Adi scenes are done , is the reason why they are so accepted by us audience...
Loved how he took her playing with her towel as a sign of her saying yes...LOL...cute misunderstanding that...lol..better then the Simran Shaan one...lol
What goes against Simran is the unrealisum...its too childish even to be funny ...
Room Talk...now this was very nice too...revealing to us the POV of all the characters and who thinks alike..
Papi was the cutest...Mummy indeed..as the boys teased him...
And the present for us for the 350 epi was what Shanak said about their life partner...so true that..and lvoely and beautifuly protrayed that what made them fall in love and why its more then that...thats Shanak for us...
Now for th most talked about Precape ...LOL..
It was the first thing I watched yesterday night...LOL
Poor Shaan he was trying to help her out as she was helping out his wife in Teaching English...thus decided to teach ehr Guitar ...trying to pay her in Kind for what she was doing for his wife...but then,.he does not know that the person Simran has fallen in lvoe with or is going gaga over is none other then Him...both hubby wife think its someone else..so thats all okay really...BUT what was bad about the scene again...no Subtlety in direction ...tooo in our faces...
Other wise a nce epi...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".