Which Sita? - Page 3

Poll

Which Sita?

Login To Vote

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

4.4k

Users

19

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

coolpurvi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#21
Debina is more beautiful than Deepika. she is tall. chemistry between debina n Gurmeet rocks. I found it a bit missing in the old Ramayan. She is beautifully portraying a devoted n loving wife. Her voice n way of speaking is really sweet (demonees, shurpi n Ravan uncle r exceptions)
I agree with Juhi Debina is best n Deepika was best
Debina looks really royal n gorgeous. her acting is so graceful. she nicely portrying brave n strong SitaMa
Edited by coolpurvi - 16 years ago
Mallika113 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#22
I voted for Debina. Both Deepika and Debina are beautiful!! I like Debina's portrayal of Sitaji better!! Debi started out slowly with her wonderful eye expressions during swayamwar but grew in to her role beautifully as her character got more dialogues. She is doing an outstanding job with the direction given by Sagars.
I can tell she has completely thrown herself in to the character of Sita. She seems to be sweet and down to earth in real life too from what I have seen from her interviews😊
coolpurvi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#23
I agree with Mallika. I love the way she hosted SBS on diwali n in her TV inteviews she looked so gorgeous n down to earth. Our GC n debi r so sweet n down to earth in their real life also. In scenes between Ram n Sita thier chemistry rocks. They look like true soulmates. She is agressive in some scenes between her n some domoness, shurp, n Ravan. But its natural
Durga1994 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Mkerai

I think Debina and Deepika are both good, but Deepika is better.

I agree😛. Debina is really pretty too, but Deepika was gorgeous! Absolutely stunning, and her acting was natural and excellent. Debina is good too, but her acting has to mature more.
Durga1994 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#25

If the Sagars had made a Mahabharat, I think Debina as Draupadi would have been awesome, because the agressiveness, anger, and strength she shows fits Draupadi's role more than Sita's (which was supposed to be more soft natured).

Think about it guys: Debina as Draupadi and Gurmeet as Arjuna. Wouldn't that be awesome???😛
Durga1994 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: rups.12bloom


i'm not blaming anybody for discouraging debinaji's character in ramayan !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!i'm just saying that the way Ms. aishwarya has used to describe debinaji's character in ramayan is absolutely wrong !!!!!!!
and this way seems to be discouragement !!!!!!! which IF rules do not allow !!!!!

Aiswarya may have become a little too angry, but what she said is still her opinon. She never called anyone names, or used any rude language. Also, in this forum, I've some people speak about Deepika that way. Yet, no one seems to care.😕 Now, if someone says one thing about Debina, people get angry, but everyone's allowed to talk about Deepika as they please? That seems hypocritical behavior.😕
muffins2waffles thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#27
Thank you Durga and Chandraketu for respecting my opinions, and I respect everyone elses as well...
To rups.12 bloom ( Ps. Um, do you like Miley Cyrus a lot? Random Question)
I was just saying that I do not think that the way I spoke is unnacceptable and discouraging. Your opinions would then be counted as discouragin towards Deepika, so you are doing the same thing. Anyway, what I was trying to say is that the characterization of Sita was much more pleasing to me than this one. It's not Debina's fault, it's the scripts fault in my opinion.
Durga1994 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: coolpurvi

Debina is more beautiful than Deepika. she is tall. chemistry between debina n Gurmeet rocks. I found it a bit missing in the old Ramayan. She is beautifully portraying a devoted n loving wife. Her voice n way of speaking is really sweet (demonees, shurpi n Ravan uncle r exceptions)

I agree with Juhi Debina is best n Deepika was best
Debina looks really royal n gorgeous. her acting is so graceful. she nicely portrying brave n strong SitaMa

If you don't like Deepika, you don't have to say she was best. We know your opinion. You like Debina better.
And you can't blame the old Ramayan for not showing enough "chemistry" between Ram and Sita, b/c they did not have enough money to stretch the serial more than 78 episodes. Do you know how much money goes into every single episode? It's a reeeaaallly tough job to make a mythological, b/c the costumes, clothing, and the set are not cheap, and the equipment and resources are not either. It's a really great thing that this new Ramayan can afford to do all this, b/c I know how much hard work goes into taking a mythological vs. a soap opera, but the old Ramayan was taken in 1987 or 1988! Come on guys, it's really really unfair to say that everything about this Ramayan is better b/c the older one didn't have as much "chemistry" or as good "sets", costumes, etcetera!😡 I appreciate the hard work the older Ramayan (with the extremely limited resources it had) put in, b/c unlike this Ramayan, the songs in the older one were original and thought of completely by them! 90% of the tunes in this Ramayan were copied from the older one, and lots of the lines were taken directly from them!
Basically, what I'm saying is that this Ramayan is over 200 episodes, so can show the love between Ram and Sita more, but the other one had only 78 episodes, so they concentrated on the main parts of the Ramayan. What could they do? Is it their fault?
Maybe if people stop criticizing the older Ramayan, this Ramayan will also get less criticism. After all, it's tit for tat.
desichica thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#29
I think both actresses did a wonderful job respectively...while Deepika showed the emotional, dependent, & strong character to the T of Sita mata, Debina did a wonderful job expressing the angry, emotional & strong character of Sita Mata!!!!
there were instances where deepika made me cry when she delivered her dialogues before calling upon Dharti mata😭 😭 😭 😭 ....& there was an instance i cried when Debina started to feel helpless & as she stated that she feels apavitra in one of the episodes....i'm not sure which one it was, but i think it might have been the one where Ravan teases Sita on how happy he is that she kept a vrat for him, when Sita Mata actually kept it for Ramji!!!!! I mean the way she was pouring her heart & eyes out to Trijata & saying that by listening to Ravan's disgusting words she feels apavitra & she starts crying.....i started crying with her 😭 😭
For an actor/actress to get emotions out of me I wud have to state they both were good in there own strengths...esp. since i'm very strong as far as my emotions are concerned....😆
Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
#30
All

Just a simple observation:

Stating that one prefers Debina to Dipika is not necessarily a criticism of Dipika, even though there may be reasons given.

Similarly, stating that one prefers Dipika to Debina isn't necessarily slamming the latter actress, much less undermining this show.

I know that most people here are groupies of either Sita or both, but nonetheless, no need to take the preference over your preference so personally.

In other words, no need to get so upset.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".