Originally posted by: starsinmyeyes
It's not even close...Buniyaad, Hum log, Siddhant, Sarabhai vs Sarabhai, ek mahal ho sapnon ka...miles ahead in terms of scripting...it's simple Amber..from where I see it..after so much trust issues and separation and problems..AsYa should have known better...Asad was most vulnerable when his mom got shot and when he was caught on the SR night with Tanveer...he still did not lose as much dignity then as he has lost now...for me Asad is irreparable..
Coming to Zoe...she was always the unconventional NRi...a loudmouth but with a brain..functional one...the built up to her dumbness was apologetic to say the least...and this is the same girl who saved Naj from the goons and save Mariam..all with same impulsiveness...she is one who would have stepped up...her father's death was an emotianally vulnerable news for her she still took with her head held high...choosing between Asad and her abbu's truth was another fork in the road...she had almost given him up...and trust me I did not point fingers at her love for Asad then..she did what a human would do when faced with such a dilemma..
QH was as close to real and I hate watching Indian telly now...but I loved QH for it's simplistic and believable portrayal of human emotions...and now I cannot relate with a wimp like Asad, a woman with no self respect like Zoya and a pathetic brother like Ayaan...and something I cannot relate to...I cannot feel any sympathy for it...there were bigger vulnerable moments that were handled with a quiet dignity...this was not the zenith of their problems...they haven't bloody seen the zenith yet