high trp can not be the measure of quality - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2.7k

Users

17

Likes

97

Frequent Posters

crazy4KASH_AR thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: gossipgirlxoxo

Though I like most of what Gul presents.. But not everyone will like everything...

Every individual is different..
If she portrays high class realism on Tv she will lose her viewers .
People watch Tv to escape reality...and be in a fictional land.
She has to cater to the masses otherwise the show will be off air...
So I ignore stuff I don't like



Very well said but still I can think QH is doing very well and Gul shud really not think about becoming number 1 at the stake of story and characters of QH coz in the end TRPs don't matter.
It's the story and characters which people will remember forever and not the number of years for which a show had run on TV.
kankabhor thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
It depends on one's taste.. Some are not liking does not mean its loosing charm , it means its showing something which is not your taste.. For me QH is doing great and I as hooked as I was in beginning..
crazy4KASH_AR thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Ankita.M

I don't personally understand what the meaning of losing charm is, and what going out of character means? Asad is a man who does everything for his loved ones, that is the first most important thing about him. Being an Akdu happened to him only because he was a loner, now he is not one, Zoya's presence and love has changed that, so him doing anything and everything she asks for is not going out of character. Qubool Hai is following a story it had planned from the start, you probably liked the what they showed initially and do not like what they show now, but that does not spell that the show is losing its charm.


The definition of good entertainment is different for many and at the end of the day numbers are what matter, for people who look too much into it quality and charm and essence and so on matter too much, but for those who watch it for entertainment, QH is showing what it is in its numbers.



And this is why I love u and your write-ups...
Very well said Ankita
But still I am a bit afraid for Asad.You are right in saying that Asad does everything for his family.
I'm not against Asad doing everything for Zoe.I'm loving the fact that Asad has changed sooo much.It's amazing to see him expressing himself finally.
All what I'm afraid of is future of Asad.For once I can digest Sallu dance but if Gul makes Asad do such things again and again in futre,I might be unable to relate to Asad's character.
I love Armaan more than Asad but when I watch a show I love the story equally.
I don't wish to see Asad turning into a completely romantic guy.I want him to romance Zoe,love her,fulfill all her desires and make her feel special but all this should suit his personality as well.
Noone can transform from angry young man to SRK completely.I love KSG the most when he romances onscreen but I would like Asad to romance Zoe in jahapanah style only.😉
I hope u get my point.
Take care!
Edited by crazy4KASH_AR - 12 years ago
gossipgirlxoxo thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: crazy4KASH_AR



Very well said but still I can think QH is doing very well and Gul shud really not think about becoming number 1 at the stake of story and characters of QH coz in the end TRPs don't matter.
It's the story and characters which people will remember forever and not the number of years for which a show had run on TV.


I think that she will tell the story the way she wanted to tell from the beginning...
All this melodrama is just ...means to an end...
Presumably Asad is still a virgin... Tanveer acted as a catalyst ... No permanent damage done...

karikarinainan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

What you are saying is absolutely true.

Some people pick things quickly and others take time. I am sure others in this forum will also repeat what you are saying but they will need some time to adjust to the new reality - high TRP, lack of content. Plus, there are still some scenes that are done well, though can't be said about the entire episode these days.

Unfortunate part is this is clearly a part of strategy to increase TRP. The phenomenon is not restricted to QH, in fact most of the serials of Zee TV is going thru this kind of transformation - over the top dramas, unnecessary twists and turns and what not. Zee (also is the case with colors and others except Star plus seems to be placed neatly) is under tremendous pressure / is determined to gain no 1 place. Look at the rate existing shows are closed and the new shows are started. I am sure somewhere 3-4 months back QH has also receive such a threat of either incr TRP (since begginning the show was liked well by people but its TRPs never cross 2.4-2.5) or closure, so QH has to resort to tactic to increase TRP. At the end of day, PH is in it for money.

In fact many of the track against which people have grudge are mainly due to strategy to increase TRP. Increasingly we have seen that issues are not shorted out based on logic but on emotional / drama/ faith based activities i.e. zoya saved by chaddar, characters becoming dumb, over hearing of drugging similar to SR. There are numerous instances where characters are not doing anything, problems are solved this way to give less time to logical activities and focus more on dramatic / emotional scenes. If dlishad would have been shot today, instead of zoya and asad teaming up to find the killer, it would have been found out by some chamatkar.

Yes, I have also felt that the romance scene are over the top now a days, it doesnt have the feel it used to have.

My only wish is that they should find a balance between quality and mass as soon as possible.



Edited by rockztheIF - 12 years ago
aish321 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: rockztheIF


What you are saying is absolutely true.

Some people pick things quickly and others take time. I am sure others in this forum will also repeat what you are saying but they will need some time to adjust to the new reality - high TRP, lack of content. Plus, there are still some scenes that are done well, though can't be said about the entire episode these days.

Unfortunate part is this is clearly a part of strategy to increase TRP. The phenomenon is not restricted to QH, in fact most of the serials of Zee TV is going thru this kind of transformation - over the top dramas, unnecessary twists and turns and what not. Zee (also is the case with colors and others except Star plus seems to be placed neatly) is under tremendous pressure / is determined to gain no 1 place. Look at the rate existing shows are closed and the new shows are started. I am sure somewhere 3-4 months back QH has also receive such a threat of either incr TRP (since begginning the show was liked well by people but its TRPs never cross 2.4-2.5) or closure, so QH has to resort to tactic to increase TRP. At the end of day, PH is in it for money.

In fact many of the track against which people have grudge are mainly due to strategy to increase TRP. Increasingly we have seen that issues are not shorted out based on logic but on emotional / drama/ faith based activities i.e. zoya saved by chaddar, characters becoming dumb, over hearing of drugging similar to SR. There are numerous instances where characters are not doing anything, problems are solved this way to give less time to logical activities and focus more on dramatic / emotional scenes. If dlishad would have been shot today, instead of zoya and asad teaming up to find the killer, it would have been found out by some chamatkar.

Yes, I have also felt that the romance scene are over the top now a days, it doesnt have the feel it used to have.

My only wish is that they should find a balance between quality and mass as soon as possible.





Well said, exactly what i had in mind, am not so good with words hence appreciate the clarity in this which reflects i believe most of our thoughts..😊
avi_k_ thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
Well, the truth can be ignored by online fans bt the truth is Qubool Hai is day by day gettimg more popularity even it is now reaching villages people loving. What we expect is something they cant show always as people stop or slowly get shy to watch it. Talking aabout sallu act, it was best protrayed by Asad. Not it was sudden it was like he has to as copying for zoya
livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
Umm Might b your pov, bt I am really liking da show now. Jst bcoz Asad dance in one of da episodes doesn't mean he has turned into complete romantic. And b.t.w he has fallen in love so dre shud b some character development in him. 😆
As of now Q.H continues to b entertaining. And no shows can survive without twists & turns & so we need it.
karikarinainan thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Here is a simple test - think about your favorite movie and then check whether it belongs to 100 cr club or not? If it is in 100 cr club, then you will belong to audience segment that will continue to like QH.
immigreat54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Qubool.Hain

comercially this show may be doing good. high trps ! but somewhere i feel the essence of qubool hain is missing !

now many may jump into my post saying you have got the remote. make better use of it accordin to your taste !
but here i am placing my opinion as a viewer who was once in love with this show and with asya.
i expected their love story to be realy epic... something different that no other love birds experienced. but comon gul khan ! why would you have to put the same elements from your previous show ?
and asad performing in the salman khan song... i dont want to comment anything on it ! even in her previous show when ASR stepped out of his charecter and did the salman khan dance there was an outburst from the fans ! it was indeed an embarassing sight for many fans ,ASR or asad doing such kind of dhinchak dance ! even from your past mistake you havent learnt 4lions !
now what i am trying to say is ... qubool hain is on the way to losing its charm. after tanveer revelation we thought things will be better. many of us are forcefully making ourselves understand that yes our show is back, our qubool hain is back ! but i dont see it getting back to its old glory anymore !
many may also defend that qh is on the right track... hence such huge trp !!! but i beg to differ... there r many shows on tv with saas bahu and kitchen drama u wont be able to enjoy for even a second ! yet they give trp more than 4 !
please place your view without any bashing , if u find the quality of qubool hain going downhill despite such high trp


Just wanna comment on one thing. The way Asad is behaving these days is because of the horrible incidents happened to him in the past. He is actually an emotional guy from inside who never showed that to others, but then Zoya happened to him. U need to understand that he resisted the love for so long but then finally, he failed and fell heads over heals for her. And after so many things happening, his inner child has come out when he only wishes to be happy and wants to make his beloved happy. That's why he's doing all the things entirely out of Asad's character. That's my just POV

Related Topics

Qubool Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Ayra_lovers

6 months ago

OS - You're not the one to blame...

Hi everyone! Hope you're doing great! I missed the fandom, I've been obsessed with QH once again after my last re-watch , and here is a new OS ,...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".