QH, IPKKND, GHSP - 4Lions use same formula?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

fabbz18

@fabbz18

Beginner

Posted: 12 years ago

#41

After reading this post Im a bit baffled so Im just gonna put a few things out there.

Firstly of course there's going to be similarities between show's that are being produced in the same production house - common its simple you learn and keep using things that work - like a tried and tested formula.

Secondly why even try to even compare ipkknd and qubool hai when qubool hai has something ipkknd never had - an actual legit storyline 😆 lol

and last but not least - girl go get your self some spec's how can you not think Surbhi's beautiful!!!!! - SERIOUSLY 😕 - go check her out again in the scene at the dargah that will make you eat your words lol

Edited by fabbz18 - 12 years ago

Quote

IntrovertedDame

@IntrovertedDame

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#42

The emotionally unavailable man/ passionate impulsive woman is a motif that you find umpteen number of times in literature and movies. It is the stuff of all M & B's for that matter.

If you come to the classics too, it's very much there. Remember "Pride and Prejudice", the brooding Mr. Darcy and the charming Elizabeth Bennett who make false assumptions about each other, only to realize that there were misconceptions and fall in love. So i would then say that IPK and Geet and plagiarized versions of Jane Austen's works.

For example, "Maine pyar kiya" can be regarded as a 20th century Indian reworking of Cinderella- rich man falls in love with a poor girl in spite of class differences and all that jazz. But what you have added in the mix is the conflict between the fathers which reminds you of "Romeo and Juliet".

And I think there are innumerable movies made on the same theme- two individuals fall in love in spite of coming from warring families, etc.,

Bottomline- In terms of motifs, themes, plot lines, basic human emotions and situations, you have so many similarities, so many archetypes. But the manner in which the story is treated is what makes a difference.

And QH certainly makes a mark in that!!!

Over and out:)

Edited by Amri174 - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Meaningful

@Meaningful

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#43

There might be some similarities as you mentioned, but both shows are poles apart. QH lead pair is brilliant ( i am not saying Barun - Sanaya are not good but they are no comparison to KSG - Surbhi in terms of acting, looks and all other things that makes an actor). And the setting of the story and rest of the cast are also fresh and worth watching, which was missing in the other show.

Just my POV, i could not watch the other show, where as i am hooked to QH.

Quote

LoveAsYa222

@LoveAsYa222

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#44

Ok I know u'll hate me for saying this but if u consider Surbhi not to be beautiful ...then by that standards Sanaya isn't either...I know thats a direct comparison but thats what u did too...

I agree that Arshi & SaRun's chemistry is great but for me AsYa and KaBhi have something even more amazing that maybe u failed to see...So... maybe u should watch both the shows without thinking that it's gul's show first and then compare them cause I know some IPK fans don't do that including me before I started watching this show...

Asad is different to Arnav and Maan because he's not a angry young man and is very polite to everyone except Zoya so I don't think u should consider him and Arnav or Maan to be very similiar...

I know all of these points I have mentioned above makes u think I disagree with u entirely but I don't cause in some way they are similiar but it would be best for everyone if we don't compare them...

Just to make it clear... I'm a fan of IPK and Qubool Hai and they're both amazing in their own way ❤️ GHSP probably was too but I haven't watched it so don't know 😆

Forgot to mention ...Surbhi is amazing!!!!!!! 😳

Edited by LoveAsYa222 - 12 years ago

Quote

Siri22

@Siri22

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#45

OK first off I think it's kinda rude to come to QH forum and not only say the leading lady is not beautiful and you did not even stop there but moreover compared her to another actress in terms of beauty. And I disagree with a lot of points in your post.

There's nothing new for me to add that others haven't already said but I'll say this again QH has a good storyline that IPK never had. IPK only relied on the chemistry of Sarun that's why it went down the drain after some time.

Quote

Esha

@eshaaax3.

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#46

It may be same formula, but heck its WORKING ! And i have to say it's working a lot better in QH than it has in the past shows from 4lions (my pov just saying :p)

I think KSG for this role was very good- the change we see has definitely made me a fan especially since his boyish doc phase wasn't so appealing (for me atleast lol) as is this weak hearted yet strong tempered man.

And Surbhi is BEAUTIFUL! She is a natural beauty- i love that about her. And she has nice eyes and a beautiful smile and gorgeous face structure! She's perfect as Zoya.

Honestly- this so far for me as to be 4lions best; i did follow the other shows and got bored after, and i thought id get bored with qh, but nope! It's practically the same formula just copied and pasted but there's something about QH that just sparks!!

:)

Quote

Zaina

@CrazyForAshish

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#47

KSG and Surbhi have a gud chemisty.. I m not here to compare KaBhi with any other couple.. But here U have compare KaBhi with SaRun so i want to tell U that just now AsYa have start to feel for each n their chemistry is growing very well.. So do nt compare with a Couple where there chemistry were well build n even show has come to an end..(u have watch them for past 2 years so they has 2 years time to become perfect couple for U) Here AaYa just strat there journey they need sometime.. A tlest After 1 year U can start ur comparisation...
And yeah do not tell me that surbii is not beautiful...
She is very beautiful.. In not easy to an actress to stand next to KSG if she is not beautiful...

Edited by zan101 - 12 years ago

Quote

Regina

@mizzundaztud

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#48

I agree on most... Strongly disagree about the leads' chemistry... I think its friggin hot... One of the bests I have come across... So much so that I can anticipate action-reaction between them by mere flick of an expression on either's face