QH, IPKKND, GHSP - 4Lions use same formula?

RandomSquared

@RandomSquared

Sparkler

30

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: ..Kirann..

Agreed about casting. QH has experienced, veteran actors. The actor playing Rashid is amazing. the way he portrays the pain of father, a lover, a husband is just amazing. Then we have actor playing, Ghafur, he's superb with his expressions. The actress playing Badi Bi is fantastic. Shalini playing Dilshaad is just beautiful and a brilliant actress. Girls playing NIkhat, Nuzhat, Humeira and Najma are all so beautiful, lovely and superb actresses. The lady playing Shireen is not bad either. I used to think she's not good but lately with her confrontation with badi Bi, she was superb. Rishab is not great of an actor but he does manage with his screen presence. Then we have Alka playing Razia. What a performer. Love watching her. Then we have our leads, Karan never fails to amaze me. He's a flawless actor. Who would believe this is the same guy who played Armaan in DMG? And then Surbhi, for a first time, she's flawless. She matches up to all these brilliant actors so perfectly. Seriously, Gul has definitely outdone herself this time in casting.

also this show gives all the characters a chance to shine bc each one basically has an individual story line and they are all tied together bc of their complex relationships. i think it was written very well. i also think its smart how they brought the gudiya factory raaz thing for a little bit and revealed a few things but then pushed it back again so they can reveal the 2nd half later.

4

Reply

Quote

Aleena

@Asya_KaJen

Inactive

21

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#22

ipkknd was crap and please don't come on to the forum and compare the shows QH is awesome and Surbhi is prettier than Sanaya. No offence buh i disagree with you in many ways. the chemistry between Asya is sizzling and Sarun bluhh.

May i be the first to say this, get lost ipkknd fans LOL

No offence

Edited by Sophisticatedxx - 12 years ago

8

Reply

Quote

Fatima

@Fatima_Q

Sparkler

33

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#23

Wow...what a thorough compilation of similarities.

Whatever the formula is that Gul is using...it must be working...because after IPKKND I'm hooked on QH 😆

2

Reply

Quote

shireen sukhan

@shinseen

Dazzler

22

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: KulfiBai
Okay, IPKKND was a love story. QH is a family drama. And I disagree with you on a lot of things because the characterizations are completely different in the two shows. QH has something that IPK failed to ever develop - a legit storyline.

Also, the source of conflict between the leads in IPK was really, really stupid, IMO. Sweet girl gets into a contract marriage with a man who mentally tortures her, thinks the worst of her and doesn't have enough intelligence to confront her about, instead ruins both their lives.

Also, Surbhi is flippin' gorgeous, I dunno what you're talking about.

Peace 😊

P.S. I am getting seriously pissed with all the comparison posts now.

you just put down my words,

Totally Agree with you ,

also surbhi is way beautiful than sanaya ,

only fair skin doesn't prove that you are beautiful,

also Surbhi is doing a perfect job as a debut show ,

as compared to Sanaya who i didn't think can act like as great as surbhi is doing in her first show.

thanks.

11

Reply

Quote

Hafizakhan

@Hafizakhan

Navigator

10

Posted: 12 years ago

#25

Ipkknd was a huge hit- so obviously the formula works. Why not re-invent it with different characters with a Muslim background?! I think it is a great concept, and having watched both shows, I love QH.

KSG is an amazing actor- his range of expressions is amazing. Unlike some forum members, I had never watched DMG, so this was my first intro to him. The range of facial expressions he has is truly a pleasure to watch. It doesn't hurt that he has a killer body and face.

I also completely disagree with your analysis of Surbhi. In the beginning some of her scenes were kind of abrasive and harsh. However I have definitely seen her grow as an actress. Surbhi's English diction seems ok to me?! In fact she has a Masters degree in English literature!

Her chemistry with KSG is sizzling! Perhaps if you had watched each episode over the course of the last 6 month, and analyzed and rewatched, as some of us had, this evolution in the characters and acting would have been more obvious to you.

11

Reply

Quote

Aleena

@Asya_KaJen

Inactive

21

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#26

Ipkknd was a huge hit- so obviously the formula works. Why not re-invent it with different characters with a Muslim background?! I think it is a great concept, and having watched both shows, I love QH.

KSG is an amazing actor- his range of expressions is amazing. Unlike some forum members, I had never watched DMG, so this was my first intro to him. The range of facial expressions he has is truly a pleasure to watch. It doesn't hurt that he has a killer body and face.

I also completely disagree with your analysis of Surbhi. In the beginning some of her scenes were kind of abrasive and harsh. However I have definitely seen her grow as an actress. Surbhi's English diction seems ok to me?! In fact she has a Masters degree in English literature!

Her chemistry with KSG is sizzling! Perhaps if you had watched each episode over the course of the last 6 month, and analyzed and rewatched, as some of us had, this evolution in the characters and acting would have been more obvious to you.

[/QUOTE

loving it ahahahahaahaha Love that and i totally agree

3

Reply

Quote

Kanika

@kankabhor

Sparkler

34

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#27

Why is this comparison again and again??

Ok here I go

There are few similarities but I disagree with many points. Surbhi is very beautiful and great actress. She is very very talented..And KSG is the best with his expressions. KaBhi has great chemistry.

QH storyline is very strong. Its not only about leads.. QH casts is superb and much better than any other 4Lions show.. Waquar Sheikh, Shalini Kapoor, Vidya Sinha, Tej Sapru are very good. At last how can we forget Alka Kushal. She is the best vamp not only among 4lions shows but among all other shows on television.. She is too good.

Edited by kankabhor - 12 years ago

11

Reply

Quote

Marysaa

@Marysaa

Dazzler

20

Posted: 12 years ago

#28

Originally posted by: Sophisticatedxx
ipkknd was crap and please don't come on to the forum and compare the shows QH is awesome and Surbhi is prettier than Sanaya. No offence buh i disagree with you in many ways. the chemistry between Asya is sizzling and Sarun bluhh.

May i be the first to say this, get lost ipkknd fans LOL
No offence

🤣 u ar crazy but u craked me up haha

ASYA rocks !!

8

Reply

Quote

Nida

@Gurmeet4Drashti

Rocker

27

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#29

Honestly, I absolutely L.O.V.E Gul and all her shows ... :)

I love the chemistry shared by all the leads ... ;)

Again I love Surbhi and she's damn pretty ... :-P

" Also the whole cast doesn't match up to the IPKKND one and the chemistry of the leads isn't as strong too. "

And I completely DISAGREE with this :|

Everyone is just FANTASTIC !!!

9

Reply

Quote

Aleena

@Asya_KaJen

Inactive

21

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: Marysaa

🤣 u ar crazy but u craked me up haha
ASYA rocks !!

hahaha jealousy flies like a mosquito what can we do ??? is it our fault now Qabool hai is an awesome drama and Asya rock!!! cant blame them for being cute. and have to blame Sanaya and Barun for their ugly chemistry. :):):)

3

Reply

Quote

QH, IPKKND, GHSP - 4Lions use same formula? - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics