A few controversial q's have been bothering me... - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

68

Views

5.9k

Users

29

Likes

190

Frequent Posters

Marybarton thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: Rin03

Oh! I have a very good question for which I have YET to find a suitable answer.


Why does Gul Khan and other tv serial producers consider 'Manhandling' to be romantic?

I have been so curious about this for a long time, so many tv serials have these man-handling scenes and its so romantic apparently!

I would probably kick the guy and walk away if he ever dared to man handle me.



Oh that's a loaded question 👏

Honestly, they don't know how else to show passion. I recommend they watch some British period drama to learn.
_vineeta_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: Marybarton



Aww did I hurt your little feelings? I watch because I can. Please come and stop me. If you cant take criticism don't read it.

Graduated with a specialized psychology program and read a lot about Mr. P-envy. But don't think the creative are psychoanalysts. That's giving way too much credit .

Indian Marriage 101 for you, you marry the guy and the family.

No you didnt hurt my feelings, you can watch or not, its your time and your choice..
I dont open all post on forum, but I opened your post, I go only two forums. QH and SaraswatiChandra. I dont it follow as I couldnt connect to any actor or story yet, but being Bhansali show want to wait and give some time..
I liked your post there and as you tried to see character in depth, and have given harsh replies to others who hate. You have to respect people here too..
What we see is all fictional half of it we cant relate to real, but some stories and character touches us to core so we try to rationalize them.
I agree girl is married to a guy and family, but even in reality we have seen a guy who after marriage becomes strong to stand for his wife. One vice versa too, very strong looking guys who are so superficial..
I believe everyone is born with some luck, maybe Nikhat who has such strong and loving bro, will never see the latter guy in Imraan..
I am trying to peace out here but would really want to see what you like, as you must to pick it from so many others to watch..
Marybarton thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: _vineeta_

No you didnt hurt my feelings, you can watch or not, its your time and your choice..
I dont open all post on forum, but I opened your post, I go only two forums. QH and SaraswatiChandra. I dont it follow as I couldnt connect to any actor or story yet, but being Bhansali show want to wait and give some time..
I liked your post there and as you tried to see character in depth, and have given harsh replies to others who hate. You have to respect people here too..
What we see is all fictional half of it we cant relate to real, but some stories and character touches us to core so we try to rationalize them.
I agree girl is married to a guy and family, but even in reality we have seen a guy who after marriage becomes strong to stand for his wife. One vice versa too, very strong looking guys who are so superficial..
I believe everyone is born with some luck, maybe Nikhat who has such strong and loving bro, will never see the latter guy in Imraan..
I am trying to peace out here but would really want to see what you like, as you must to pick it from so many others to watch..



No Vineeta, I have a reputation here as a defender of all so called "hate" posts. You can ask anyone from the IPK forum where I have made exactly 3000 posts. I have always stood up for the differing opinion. The only times I have been "harsh" is when people don't know where to draw the line and go for the easy way out by calling someone a basher or attacking them personally.

Otherwise, I will always argue with logic even if I disagree with the person. Don't know where you got this from. I am not the one who put down a TM by saying challenging them not to watch the show or leave because their opinion is not exactly the same as mine. The SC forum has hardly even had so called bashers. I even posted a post at the very beginning to stop using that word in the forum to keep the forum open to all points of views. Here's the link:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/saraswatichandra/3456862/proposal-reminder-bashing-bashers

It happened with IPK when anyone who posted an intelligent criticism was labeled a basher but eventually we drew the line and there were interesting discussions there.

As to the accusation that I was looking for depth there (not here). There is a simple explanation. Depth should be obvious, not found. SC is based on a classic piece of literature, hence depth. QH (and I don't want to pit them against each other) is based on a story written by drama writers - Some of whom were thought a little maturity by the IPK viewers for their PR and story flaws.

I have watched three of 4Lions shows and if I did not want them to do well then I would not have pointed out how they were messing up. QH has cast off all semblance of logic and is acting more like a the early 2000s K-soaps. It was better than that. They are good with symbolisms and good stories but they are totally selling out. The loyal viewer needs to hold them to the very bar they set with previous shows and even this show early on.

Edited by Marybarton - 12 years ago
CutielovesChocs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#54
Jeesus.

I came here at 8 in the morning, and this is what I see. DAMMIT woman, you made my day. 🤣

I actually went through all the pages and the replies I found were BRILLIANT! Kudos to you all, really. I couldn't think of better answers. 😆

Mary, kudos woman. Brilliantly written, and well, it stunned people. As for me, I'm gonna be a lawyer, so I LOVE questions of all kinds and logic that doesn't end up. But I don't watch QH regularly, so I don't know the exact details, but I've realised that there is only ONE 'raaz', and if that's revealed, everyone would be vella and everything would be hunky dory. So therefore, they have to stretch the 'raaz' thing as long as they can😉😆

Regarding Nikhat and her marriage. I've been asking myself the SAME question. Actually, I've been posting it here too. 😆 What sane family marries their daughter into a family like that!? Yes, Nikhat likes the boy. Based on WHAT exactly? A few smiles he sent her way?😆 Sheeesh.

Anyway, so much for not answering the questions. 😆

Kudos!
-Raina
Actomyo thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: CutielovesChocs

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Jeesus.</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">
I came here at 8 in the morning, and this is what I see. DAMMIT woman, you made my day.🤣</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">I actually went through all the pages and the replies I found were BRILLIANT! Kudos to you all, really. I couldn't think of better answers.😆</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Mary, kudos woman. Brilliantly written, and well, it stunned people. As for me, I'm gonna be a lawyer, so I LOVE questions of all kinds and logic that doesn't end up. But I don't watch QH regularly, so I don't know the exact details, but I've realised that there is only ONE 'raaz', and if that's revealed, everyone would be vella and everything would be hunky dory. So therefore, they have to stretch the 'raaz' thing as long as they can😉😆</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Regarding Nikhat and her marriage. I've been asking myself the SAME question. Actually, I've been posting it here too.😆What sane family marries their daughter into a family like that!? Yes, Nikhat likes the boy. Based on WHAT exactly? A few smiles he sent her way?😆Sheeesh.</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Anyway, so much for not answering the questions.😆</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Kudos!</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">-Raina</font>


Regarding Nikhath marriage, any parents wouldn't like to marry off their daughter to such a greedy and inhuman khandan! But if you look at the reality in most of Indian weddings, dowry has become a normal thing and what's worse if the girl is dusky in complexion, the greediness of groom's family grows more!
CutielovesChocs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#56
I realise that. There are a few folks in Rashid's family who DON'T want Nikat to be married in this household (Dadi, Ayaan, Rashid)

However, Razia has talked everyone into it (HOW she can do such a thing is beyond me- oh wait, the 'raaz') and ta-da! 😆


Marybarton thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: CutielovesChocs

Jeesus.


I came here at 8 in the morning, and this is what I see. DAMMIT woman, you made my day. 🤣

I actually went through all the pages and the replies I found were BRILLIANT! Kudos to you all, really. I couldn't think of better answers. 😆

Mary, kudos woman. Brilliantly written, and well, it stunned people. As for me, I'm gonna be a lawyer, so I LOVE questions of all kinds and logic that doesn't end up. But I don't watch QH regularly, so I don't know the exact details, but I've realised that there is only ONE 'raaz', and if that's revealed, everyone would be vella and everything would be hunky dory. So therefore, they have to stretch the 'raaz' thing as long as they can😉😆

Regarding Nikhat and her marriage. I've been asking myself the SAME question. Actually, I've been posting it here too. 😆 What sane family marries their daughter into a family like that!? Yes, Nikhat likes the boy. Based on WHAT exactly? A few smiles he sent her way?😆 Sheeesh.

Anyway, so much for not answering the questions. 😆

Kudos!
-Raina




Thank you Raina, you took it with the right spirit!
CutielovesChocs thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#58
Mary - I couldn't NOT take it in the right spirit, especially after reading the question about Ayaan's hair🤣

What I don't understand is how people sum up your post up as 'bashing'. You're simply asking about stuff that you think doesn't add up. 😃
545122 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#59
Tere baaki question ka toh pata nahi but ...the quyestion how will this how compete with other shows ??? .
.
.this is already going gr8 since it has been launched never left the top 10 slot and moreover when karan is there no need to be fear !!! He only on his terms and his power ran DMG for 3 years 2 months and 10 days !!! Anyways for me QH has story and ksg !! So way to go !!!!! ksg rocks
ArushiSagar thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: Marybarton

  1. Does Asad know only one song? We have since counted that he knows three or four. Major talent there.
  2. Why is everyone spending a week running after one cheap (breakable/damageable), yet resilient doll?
  3. Why is Zoya so ditzy these past few weeks or so? I thought she was this highly educated and grounded girl?
  4. Why hasn't there been any progress in the relationship between Asad and Zoya in the past 2 months? They are still in the formality phase, there is no familiarity, no intimacy (not romantic), no real friendship or even felt-avoidance.
  5. Why are they still marrying Nikkat off to this sleezy family?
  6. Why does Ayan and company think getting Rashid off the one police officer and station will solve the case? The case comes from above and Asad has the ear of the DSP, I thought?
  7. Why is Ayan so dumb? Why is that supposed to be "hot?"
  8. Why would Zoya or any woman beside Humaira ever choose that hairy thing over any other man, much less Asad?
  9. Why does Ayan stand with his shoulder up against his ears? Does he have a neck?
  10. How is this kind of weak storytelling going to compete with what else is on tv?
  11. How awful/stupid is that Billo Rani music and track?
  12. What is worse, the Billo Rani Billo Rani thing or the villain's all-knowing Shyam-like eyes? I don't literally mean the lady's eyes. I mean that she is the only all-knowing character. Everything she plots works out and she has some really DUMB ideas.
  13. Why is the antagonist more important than the protagonist in this PH's productions? Are the inspired by Othello?
  14. Why did they let go of the hitman or do they even remember than the actual one that committed the crime was the hitman?
  15. Is this the same PH that produced those stories in the past? Are their brains fried after QH had such a promising start?
  16. Why do they use the romantic couple to promote the show but only focus on the Rashid family when the show is actually on?
  17. Why does the actress who acts the part of Dadi stuck with one expression since she started - unfeeling, no expression? I am not talking about her current state. She ALWAYS acts poorly.
  18. Why is the mali storing leaves in open baskets? Aren't they going to blow away in the wind?
  19. When will the accuse Zoya, tears and then understanding trend lead to something new?
  20. Why am I going to be called a basher as soon as this message is posted?


Mary.

Mary, first off, I love your pic! Ah Mr. Thornton, you're always a treat for the eyes!!
Second, your post had me ROFL'ing. To answer your question in one fell swoop, this PH is notorious for good starts, but poor execution after the serial has taken off. If IPKKND, one of the previous shows produced by the same PH, is anything to go by, this is about to get a whole lot worse. Consistent characterization and compact story arc are not strong points of this PH. You're in for a bumpy ride dear...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".