A few controversial q's have been bothering me...

1. Does Asad know only one song? We have since counted that he knows three or four. Major talent there.
   
2. Why is everyone spending a week running after one cheap (breakable/damageable), yet resilient doll?
   
3. Why is Zoya so ditzy these past few weeks or so? I thought she was this highly educated and grounded girl?
4. Why hasn't there been any progress in the relationship between Asad and Zoya in the past 2 months? They are still in the formality phase, there is no familiarity, no intimacy (not romantic), no real friendship or even felt-avoidance.
5. Why are they still marrying Nikkat off to this sleezy family?
6. Why does Ayan and company think getting Rashid off the one police officer and station will solve the case? The case comes from above and Asad has the ear of the DSP, I thought?
7. Why is Ayan so dumb? Why is that supposed to be "hot?"
   
8. Why would Zoya or any woman beside Humaira ever choose that hairy thing over any other man, much less Asad?
9. Why does Ayan stand with his shoulder up against his ears? Does he have a neck?
10. How is this kind of weak storytelling going to compete with what else is on tv?
11. How awful/stupid is that Billo Rani music and track?
    
12. What is worse, the Billo Rani Billo Rani thing or the villain's all-knowing Shyam-like eyes? I don't literally mean the lady's eyes. I mean that she is the only all-knowing character. Everything she plots works out and she has some really DUMB ideas.
    
13. Why is the antagonist more important than the protagonist in this PH's productions? Are the inspired by Othello?
    
14. Why did they let go of the hitman or do they even remember than the actual one that committed the crime was the hitman?
15. Is this the same PH that produced those stories in the past? Are their brains fried after QH had such a promising start?
16. Why do they use the romantic couple to promote the show but only focus on the Rashid family when the show is actually on?
17. Why does the actress who acts the part of Dadi stuck with one expression since she started - unfeeling, no expression? I am not talking about her current state. She ALWAYS acts poorly.
    
18. Why is the mali storing leaves in open baskets? Aren't they going to blow away in the wind?
19. When will the accuse Zoya, tears and then understanding trend lead to something new?
20. Why am I going to be called a basher as soon as this message is posted?

Mary.

1. Does Asad know only one song? -- wait and see. He will sing at least few more by the end of this show.
   
2. Why is everyone spending a week running after one cheap (breakable/damageable), yet resilient doll? -- because they think that the doll will solve all the mysteries.
   
3. Why is Zoya so ditzy this past week or so? I thought she was this highly educated and grounded girl? -- Everything is fair in love and war. She obviously has lost her mind in the love for Asad or the feeling of it.
   
4. Why hasn't there been any progress is the relationship between Asad and Zoya in the past 2 months? They are still in the formality phase, there is no familiarity, no intimacy (not romantic), no real friendship or even felt-avoidance. -- You wouldn't be asking this question if you are used to Indian soaps. They fall in love, then what? It will take at least a year before male lead and female lead accept each other's love.
   
5. Why are they still marrying Nikkat off to this family? -- Because the Villain is hell bent on doing this rishta/alliance. I have no idea why, but during the process, Nikhat fell in love with the boy and now everyone will support this for her happiness.
   
6. Why does Ayan and company think getting Rashid off the one police officer and station will solve the case? The case comes from above and Asad has the ear of the DSP, I thought? -- Because this is not reality. And probably because PH thinks we are all idiots to believe such thing can happen. Even if that Firoz was suppose to destroy the evidence, how can he destroy the eye witness. Beats me.
   
7. Why is Ayan so dumb? -- Good question. Maybe he was never given a chance by others to use his brain. So, his brain is rusted.
   
8. Why would Zoya or any woman beside Humaira ever choose that hairy thing over any other man, much less Asad? -- Obviously people think lot of hair is sexy.
   
9. Why does Ayan stand with his shoulder off against his ears? Does he have a neck? -- His neck cannot take the weight of all the hair me thinks.
   
10. How is this kind of weak storytelling going to compete with what else is on tv? -- If not anything, this PH knows how to attract audience, so they will be okay, trust me.
    
11. How awful is that Billo Rani music? -- Have heard more horrible ones, so no comments.
    
12. What is worse, the Billo Rani Billo Rani thing or the villain's all-knowing Shyam-like eyes? -- Both in my opinion.
    
13. Why is the antagonist more important than the protagonist in this PH's productions? Are the inspired by Othello? -- It is very easy to understand protagonist, hard to understand antagonists so probably that's why. But any day, I would watch Razia over Ayaan. She is brilliant.
    
14. Why did they let go of the hitman or do they even remember than the actual one that committed the crime was the hitman? -- Something to do with selective amnesia that PH has. It happens in every story. Wouldn't be surprised if they brought him back as someone else down the road.
    
15. Is this the same PH that produced those stories in the past? Are their brains fried after QH had such a promising start? -- This is a successful PH. No doubt. They take all the efforts to go to the top and then work on spoiling it.
    
16. Why do they use the romantic couple to promote the show but only focus on the Rashid family when the show is actually on? -- How else would you attract teenage crowd?
    
17. Why does the actress who acts the part of Dadi stuck with one expression since she started - unfeeling, no expression? -- No comments. She was a pretty actress when young. I never thought of her as a brilliant actress. There are tons of other women who do the role of an elderly woman.
    
18. Why is the mali storing leaves in open baskets? Aren't they going to blow away in the wind? -- Good one. Have no answer.
    
19. When will the accuse Zoya, tears and then understanding trend lead to something new? -- Probably never.
    
20. Why am I going to be called a basher as soon as this message is posted? -- Definitely not by me.
    

Originally posted by: enchanted.

Agree with some of your questions, like why Nikkhat is still getting married off to that sleezeball? And when will something actually come from Asad and Zoya's misunderstandings? Plus, this stupid Billo Rani/Tanveer track should be killed off effective immediately, according to me too! Oh and the nobody-will-be-able-to-find-the-magical-doll game is getting boring ..well it always was.

However, I do not agree with all of your points. Asad has sung quite a few different songs since the show started. Plus its quite normal to have a 'family song'..and tbh it doesn't matter because I love it when the whole of Asad's family is together.

I get your annoyance with Ayaan, and yes he is dumb, but nobody said that was supposed to be hot, so I don't get why you questioned that 😕.

I disagree with a few more, especially the last one. Everyone in this forum has the capability and the ability to take criticism and critisize, so unless you actually bash (or coax them into calling you one), most people will not call you a basher.

Some really valid questions! 😊

Originally posted by: Marybarton

1. Does Asad know only one song? He sang 3 different songs so far! Zindagi ki yahi reet was repeated since it's his ammi's fav. song(if you have watched one of the old episodes, she asks him to sing it when she was feeling low), so to patch-up with her he sang it again!
   
2. Why is everyone spending a week running after one cheap (breakable/damageable), yet resilient doll? The cheap doll has a secret and it is the inevitable hero of QH😉
   
3. Why is Zoya so ditzy this past week or so? I thought she was this highly educated and grounded girl? Highly educated and grounded girls also have emotions and are flawed human beings like all.
   
4. Why hasn't there been any progress in the relationship between Asad and Zoya in the past 2 months? They are still in the formality phase, there is no familiarity, no intimacy (not romantic), no real friendship or even felt-avoidance. It has progressed to Asad making sweet, milky coffe to Zoya, progressed to Asad peacefully listening to Zoya, trusting Zoya untill he felt she betrayed his trust by stopping him to attend court by playing her antics!
   
5. Why are they still marrying Nikkat off to this sleezy family? Now this is indeed a question!
   
6. Why does Ayan and company think getting Rashid off the one police officer and station will solve the case? The case comes from above and Asad has the ear of the DSP, I thought? They are not thinking case is solved, it's just they want Rashid to be spared by Feroz's physical torture in the jail for the time being!
   
7. Why is Ayan so dumb? Why is that supposed to be "hot?" Nobody, atleast me didn't find him 'hot'! Looks like his 'dumb' phase is going to change soon!
   
8. Why would Zoya or any woman beside Humaira ever choose that hairy thing over any other man, much less Asad? Zoya has not yet chosen him, infact she has not chosen anyone yet!
   
9. Why does Ayan stand with his shoulder off against his ears? Does he have a neck? 😆 right now no answer, will look for the answer.
   
10. How is this kind of weak storytelling going to compete with what else is on tv? There are a lot of weaker and dumb stories that are shining on TRP charts, this story is far better!
    
11. How awful/stupid is that Billo Rani music and track? Music, yes! Track, not that awful and stupid, rather a torture for die-hard Asya romance fans!
    
12. What is worse, the Billo Rani Billo Rani thing or the villain's all-knowing Shyam-like eyes? Shyam-like eys? Come on, Raziya has most scary and sexy eyes!
    
13. Why is the antagonist more important than the protagonist in this PH's productions? Are the inspired by Othello? It's the same story of many PH, without antagonist story will not have masala unless it's a youth show!
    
14. Why did they let go of the hitman or do they even remember than the actual one that committed the crime was the hitman? Then whole Raziya raaz will be out and gudiya factory raaz can't be dragged for few more episodes, story will end!
    
15. Is this the same PH that produced those stories in the past? Are their brains fried after QH had such a promising start? Their past stories have taught them how to suatain the TRP chart, so QH is going more of family drama way!
    
16. Why do they use the romantic couple to promote the show but only focus on the Rashid family when the show is actually on? It's a family drama with romance as a part of it not romantic drama with family as the side track! It was made clear by the PH in the beginning! Promotions are always done by protagonists, there is nothing like romantic couple or unromantic couple!
    
17. Why does the actress who acts the part of Dadi stuck with one expression since she started - unfeeling, no expression? She is under coma.
    
18. Why is the mali storing leaves in open baskets? Aren't they going to blow away in the wind? 😆 so that the damn doll can be found by someone atleast!
    
19. When will the accuse Zoya, tears and then understanding trend lead to something new? Yet to be watched, it's just 4 episodes!
    
20. Why am I going to be called a basher as soon as this message is posted? Appreciate your confidence😉 I wouldn't call you a basher, you come across as a hard-core critic of this particular PH😊
    

Mary.

Originally posted by: Marybarton

Thank you for the response.

Asad, I believe sang exactly two songs the whole time. One, in the first episode and the second one twice. That makes 2 songs, not one. I stand corrected. 😆

Ayaan is supposed to be the one who gives competition to Asad over Zoya, which I find really hilarious. It hasn't happened yet of course but it will. Oh if only a happy personality and good intentions with bad ways made up for stupidity, Ayan would have a chance. Why couldn't they create a better character is my real question.

In my last post, I was called a basher left, right and center. So I preempted it for this one.

Originally posted by: Rin03

Very very good questions. I could add a few more to the list as well 😆

But Champa2012 and Bhavna has given quite good answers to all the questions :-)

Well my only answer is... Its Indian telly, 90% of it is filled with such bloopers, loopholes and bad writing. I guess its because of their daily 20 minutes format therefore they dont get much time to look into such minute details and end up making stupid and silly scenes thinking we the audience will buy it.

And this PH is rather famous for creating never ending MU's so I dont hold much hope for that accusation-realisation-accusation cycle to get over soon.

But compared to the other horrid shows topping the TRP charts, this is atleast better and more bareable. Atleast this show has some backstory and many different interesting tracka to fall back on.


Just hope they stop with the character butchering sometimes.