Dilshad...a mother or a wife? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

3.7k

Users

21

Likes

183

Frequent Posters

KunwaariDaayan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
People on here are further taunting on why we are not taking a stand for this slap!My question is...where are all the Asad slap justifiers now?Is Dilshad's slap not justified?Why?Cos she dnt have fit six pack abs and what nots to flash off?
Why is this forum so hell bent on endorsing violence?Someone please do enlighten me further...is it a kick,is it a thrill?Is it totally worth it?
VenusFlyTrap thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
The evil in me says 😈 Salay per ek thappar tu banta hai

But the pro-tolerance side of me says today was a violence mahaepisode !

& you dont choke a woman no matter how nasty she is- not if you are the good guy! & you don't slap your grown son (specially) in front of others in the room not a son who has dedicated his life to you.

Now if he's breaking furniture we should let that be- even I throw a vase or two when i cant vent my frustration and anger at anything else 😵
that's drama & Indian drama at that ☢️ there has to be some way the lead shows his manly *Biceps contracted Salman khan pose* anger 😡
delena90 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
I agree with every single word. For me, today, Dilshaad failed as a mother. I have said this many times in different threads...Asad may have been impulsive but Rashid committed each and every one of those crimes except the murder. Even for the murder he covered it up...which is a crime! He definitely deserves to go to jail. I just don't understand every one who thinks Rashid is the sun, the moon and perfect...YUCK!

He is not a sympathetic character and the writers can to try to shove it down my throat that he is but it's going to take a lot more than the writers TELLING me and propping him rather than showing. :/
risingsea101 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#14
Hey dear, beautiful post. i have a long reply for this, so please bear to read.😆

Either a mother or a wife, she was being mentally forced to choose a side, why should she choose anyways? It was either her son, or her husband. I get how she didn't notice all the pain Asad was through, but at the same time, he wasn't the only one who suffered.
I feel really bad for Asad though too, Dilshaad slapped him. He deserved it, but then again didn't deserve it, it was his "father" who was the main problem between this. Someone who is separating a mother from a child, over what...trust?
She still trusted him after 17 years, hey I guess it's because of how strong her love is for him, Asad wouldn't understand, he doesn't know how his mother feels. He feels his own pain and the hurt his "father" has put him through.
All I want to say is it isn't Dilshaad's fault neither is it Asad's.
RMamsa thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: risingsea101

Hey dear, beautiful post. i have a long reply for this, so please bear to read.😆


Either a mother or a wife, she was being mentally forced to choose a side, why should she choose anyways? It was either her son, or her husband. I get how she didn't notice all the pain Asad was through, but at the same time, he wasn't the only one who suffered.
I feel really bad for Asad though too, Dilshaad slapped him. He deserved it, but then again didn't deserve it, it was his "father" who was the main problem between this. Someone who is separating a mother from a child, over what...trust?
She still trusted him after 17 years, hey I guess it's because of how strong her love is for him, Asad wouldn't understand, he doesn't know how his mother feels. He feels his own pain and the hurt his "father" has put him through.
All I want to say is it isn't Dilshaad's fault neither is it Asad's.


I don't know- I can really relate to Asad (similar stories) and if my mother slapped me tomorrow because I turned my father in over a crime he contributed too (keeping in mind i don't know the full story) I'd find it really unfair that she slapped me. Specially because of my dedication to her. I feel Asad din't just turn him in out of personal anger but also to protect his mother from who he now see's as a murderer!
I really hope they don't show Asad forgiving Rashid so easily because it's not easy accepting a father who left you and your mother for another woman & gave all his time and dedication to the other family (let along the murder involvement)
delena90 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: RMamsa


I don't know- I can really relate to Asad (similar stories) and if my mother slapped me tomorrow because I turned my father in over a crime he contributed too (keeping in mind i don't know the full story) I'd find it really unfair that she slapped me. Specially because of my dedication to her. I feel Asad din't just turn him in out of personal anger but also to protect his mother from who he now see's as a murderer!
I really hope they don't show Asad forgiving Rashid so easily because it's not easy accepting a father who left you and your mother for another woman & gave all his time and dedication to the other family (let along the murder involvement)



Honestly, Rmansa I don't want Asad to ever forgive Rashid...at worst I want him to coldly tolerate his so called father. The man is a coward and a criminal! What sort of father doesn't cop to the truth when being asked clearly by his son who is in absolute emotional turmoil from what he has witnessed? Really is your own life worth more than your kids?
RMamsa thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#17


Honestly, Rmansa I don't want Asad to ever forgive Rashid...at worst I want him to coldly tolerate his so called father. The man is a coward and a criminal! What sort of father doesn't cop to the truth when being asked clearly by his son who is in absolute emotional turmoil from what he has witnessed? Really is your own life worth more than your kids?

Rashid is played out to be the perfectly self-centered man who comes out as a beechara in the eyes of his first wife just cuz she still loves him- the characters in this story are so well plotted and true to life... it's a pitty QH's script dsn't match its character's sketches
Edited by RMamsa - 12 years ago
Aalia_A thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Rupunzale

Dilshad is a great woman...she is the epitome of grace, kindness, sincerity, patience. She is the woman who is great enough to forgive Rashid for his sin and still care for him immensely. She is ready to go against the very son Asad who has devoted his very being for her and his family. She has undeniable faith in Rashid and it's admirable but I simply cannot support Dilshad in slapping Asad and blaming him for Rashid's arrest. Yes, Asad's decision was impulsive but being a mother Dishad should have made an attempt to understand the turmoil Rahid has put through the family...let alone has turned Asad into the mode of destruction..Asad clearly asked Rashd for an explanation but only to be said that he is forbidden to answer.


I am afraid to fulfill the duty of a wife ...she is failing as a mother. Dilshad needs to realize that she is the one who has to be strong for both Asad and Najma and not the other way around.

PS: All this slapping and choking is absolutely unacceptable ...it doesn't matter whether its Asad,Dilshad or Rashid choking Razia...it's just horrible and uncivilized. There as to be some other way to show anger and frustration.


Bang on, Pri! I realise love is blind and all that jazz, but if anything could ever give real takkar to that bells and violins aur taj mahal banane wala love, it is a mothers love for her child. Dissapointed in Dilshad today because Rashid did not deserve even the least bit of charity from anyone in his first family.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Rupunzale

Dilshad is a great woman...she is the epitome of grace, kindness, sincerity, patience. She is the woman who is great enough to forgive Rashid for his sin and still care for him immensely. She is ready to go against the very son Asad who has devoted his very being for her and his family. She has undeniable faith in Rashid and it's admirable but I simply cannot support Dilshad in slapping Asad and blaming him for Rashid's arrest. Yes, Asad's decision was impulsive but being a mother Dishad should have made an attempt to understand the turmoil Rahid has put through the family...let alone has turned Asad into the mode of destruction..Asad clearly asked Rashd for an explanation but only to be said that he is forbidden to answer.


I am afraid to fulfill the duty of a wife ...she is failing as a mother. Dilshad needs to realize that she is the one who has to be strong for both Asad and Najma and not the other way around.

PS: All this slapping and choking is absolutely unacceptable ...it doesn't matter whether its Asad,Dilshad or Rashid choking Razia...it's just horrible and uncivilized. There as to be some other way to show anger and frustration.


I could handle Rashid going after Razia because what Razia did was intentional; she purposely tried to kill his wife and has kept him a slave for years unable to see his family. This violence towards Razia is not on the same level as that between Asad and Zoya because Zoya was innocent and never had ill intent - she was a good person who did no wrong. Now, do I endorse this type of violence, not particularly but I can definitely see Rashid's pent up anger.

Dilshaad slapping Asad? No, I do not support or like and I will be writing a post on it when I get the chance.
risingsea101 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: RMamsa


I don't know- I can really relate to Asad (similar stories) and if my mother slapped me tomorrow because I turned my father in over a crime he contributed too (keeping in mind i don't know the full story) I'd find it really unfair that she slapped me. Specially because of my dedication to her. I feel Asad din't just turn him in out of personal anger but also to protect his mother from who he now see's as a murderer!
I really hope they don't show Asad forgiving Rashid so easily because it's not easy accepting a father who left you and your mother for another woman & gave all his time and dedication to the other family (let along the murder involvement)


I'm not taking sides here, and I'm definitely not taking Rashid's side. My heart goes out to Asad, as well as it does to Dilshaad. Both suffered a wound that is very deep. Dilshaad being tied to Rashid as his wife has some duties as she has being the mother of Asad. If Rashid is sent to jail, not just only Dilshaad, but Rashid's other family will be dragged into the drama, and they'll suffer as Dilshaad did, maybe Dilshaad didn't wan't that, or maybe Dilshaad still has her feelings for Rashid..
its just my opinion, if I offended you or hurt you in some way, I'm sorry

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".