Great Debate + Answers by Ms. Shah - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

157

Views

7.3k

Users

20

Frequent Posters

Kashimani thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#41
.....hmmmm, interesting debete.

Guys, I want to request everyone that don't take any statements offensive, be sportive and take it as a debate. Because, what you read may not be always what the writer means.

Let me tell you ppl my story - when I was doing MSc in India long back (in 1993), a movie came called 'roop ki rani, choron ka raja'. In hostel, everyone left that show, but I told my friends - yaar itna costly film he, kitni mehenat se banaya he producers ne, hume dekhni chahiye....and, you can imagine, after that my friends tease & laugh at me so much ....any bakwas film comes, my friends used to start - go Anu, the whole theatre is empty, you must go watch the film & appreciate 😳

...well, now I think I was so stupid/crazy. In fact, after I started to watch PRC (since Oct. 2006), I have started to criticize almost every drama comes on tv. Means PRC was superb. But as Chaitra said, I am not able to enjoy PRC anymore as I used to - it's really disappointing & all I can say is "don't know what's wrong with Sagars!!"

Well, M Shah, I like your spirit & patience. But, I don't think your explanation applies to general viewers, & makers have to make what makes sense to viewers, not what drama education teaches. While keeping close to the real story, they need to study viewer's feedbacks in order to keep up with a show's popularity.

PS: Sorry, if my point of view sounded rude to any of my dear PRCians.

crazy_kiran thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: ratilal22192

"united against M Shah" is the problem, its like saying that she is an outsider, she too is part of the forum, of course she is a part of the forum and we r not united against her but united against her thnking that we all lack intellectual capacity to judge a serail bad or good just because we dont go to some drama school and about the five days- you become active when you want to, there is an appropriate time for everything- which also includes being active! in India back in the old days kings would unite against other kings, or one king, or one group of people against another, and when the greeks came we were not unified, when the muslim invaders came we were not united, and when the british came we were not united and in all cases we were conquered . though this forum is not a country, but the situation is turning into something like that, - how so who is trying to conquer our forum just tell me and i will take care of him or her 😆
and since this is a "debate" , in debates its usually one against one, or one group against another. it should not be a million against one. If there is a limit to everything, and if M Shah passed her limit, wouldn't you think that some of us may also have passed the limit in uniting against one of our own? Yeah but u do have to reply if someone comes along and starts insulting u just because u dont agree to her. Y urself our saying its a debate and one against the other so we were reading her replies and replying our opinion on it..............but she is like either u agree with me or there is something wrong with ur intellectual capacity this is not debate

miraclemun thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#43
Dear miss kashimani thank you for your sound words of wisdom...i appreciate all of your comments and respect your ideas...

and miss kiran, please dont misinterpret what i am saying...i respect everyone's opinion and no one is right or wrong in this debate, as long as you believe you have solid evidence supporting your argument, which i believe i do, however you have a diff. view on things and its fine if you dont agree with me...and no i did not insult you or anyone, people did talk to me in a rude tone when they were angry...but i always wrote professionally and diplomatically to everyone even when i was pissed off...this is what you call professional courtesy...

and my dear, i do know how to debate quite well...i was part of the debate team in my school...i know how to argue from the affirmative and the negative and i always have a good rebuttal....

i just dont want to debate in my complex american english, thats all...

Best Regards,
M Shah

miraclemun thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#44
miss Kiran,

please dont decieve yourself and just believe me when i say that i do not think you are stupid...you misunderstood what i said, no insult was ever meant for you or your friends...and i even did compliment you guys for being very creative and noticing things...if i did think you were below me then i would never compliment you, however i did compliment you...

i never said i was smarter than you guys...i would never say that to anyone when i debate against them, its an unwritten rule...i just know more about drama, thats all and im trying to spread the knowledge...so listen if you want to and dont if you dont like my way of thinking...thats it

- M Shah
miraclemun thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#45
Miss Chaitra86, i believe it is...what were you saying about science and the arts? the IB program at my american school required me to take lots of science courses esp. physics...just ask away!

Love,
M Shah
ppiyu thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#46
sorry to interupt....... but
i m Confused 😕
What is the topic of debate now?
nishkala thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: miraclemun

miss Kiran,

please dont decieve yourself and just believe me when i say that i do not think you are stupid...you misunderstood what i said, no insult was ever meant for you or your friends...and i even did compliment you guys for being very creative and noticing things...if i did think you were below me then i would never compliment you, however i did compliment you... wow!what a gesture👏,u r complimenting us and that is indeed our achievement,miss Shah,Look who is complimenting us,Kiran😆,Have I ever given compliments to you,Nopes,so U should raise ur collars dear,Greatest Drama Prof.Miss Shah herself is complimenting you.You are in league with this great individual now.

i never said i was smarter than you guys...i would never say that to anyone when i debate against them, its an unwritten rule...i just know more about drama, thats all and im trying to spread the knowledge...so listen if you want to and dont if you dont like my way of thinking...thats it .
- M Shah

miraclemun thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#48
miss ppiyu,

you can debate about anything...if you have any question, misconception, or anything you would like to say, you can go ahead and speak on....i am open to all your ideas...i have no ideological biases...speak your mind...

love,
M Shah
miraclemun thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#49
My dear miss Nishkala,

Thank you for making me a great drama professor, this is very nice of you...i will give you the benefit of the doubt and just think that you are not being sarcastic here and even if you are it doesnt make a difference to me...i just know drama thats all, and im just sharing my knowledge and there is nothing great about that...this debate can continue if you and your friends want it to ... and as for me i love big and lively and challenging debates...so bring it on...if you have any other complaints...i will clear those up as well...

Respectfully,
M Shah
saswatisett thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: miraclemun

miss ppiyu,

you can debate about anything...if you have any question, misconception, or anything you would like to say, you can go ahead and speak on....i am open to all your ideas...i have no ideological biases...speak your mind...

love,
M Shah

Ok Miss Shah if u are so open to carry on this debate……..I have some questions here……..

  1. long back in some episodes we saw sanyo's mom, where is she now i.e. so many things are happening in kannouj and the Maharani is not present there???
  2. How come Prithvi & sanyo both come to that fountain where dehni & kannouj actually are far apart…….Sagars for making good drama can change the geographical location???
  3. When Prithvi came back with suraj & his mom his broken leg was completely cured & walking normally……..Is it so fast to mend a broken leg???

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".