prc and controversis!do read!dont miss - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.9k

Users

13

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

moreremix thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#11
*phew* finally read d whole post 😃
thanx a lot anu di 👏 ..lot of efforts 😊
dat ghori 😡 😡 😡
kiran_a thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#12
GOOD Anu I am always interested to read different History Matter Nowadays I am researching about Life of Prithviraj Raj Chauhan YOu know I love History I just want to go in different times with a time mashine but I know this dream can not come true therefore just researching and researching but I am very disapointed that I can not find any real story Everything is complicated and there are so many stories.

I think because of Sanyo he can not lost the battle because she was also rajput girl she was not coword. 😊 😊 I am sure she encouraged him to go to the battle.
256747 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#13
HISTORY IS VERYYY COMPLICATED...FOR THE SIMPLE REASON,THAT HISTORY BELONGS TO THE VICTORS'...TO THE CONQUERORS,NOTT TO THE CONQUERED....DUNNOOO wich is the real truth about Prithviraj Chauhan?!! It's better to believe what U wanna....BUTT....HE WAS 18 WHEN HE MARRIED SANYO...THENN...HOW IS THAT THEY ARE SAYING THAT HE MARRIED HER AFTER THE 1ST BATTLE OF TARAIN?? Cuz he had 7-8 years of Matrimony with HIS SANYO RANI 😳 😳 ... 😕
avtab thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#14
Thanks 4 the article. i read it on net, most probably it was the military history
rose0413 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#15
wow!! tht must have taken u hell lotta time! thxx for posting it up! i didnt know there for so many different accounts on Prithviraj Chauhan's life! but hey, it says up there that the Prithviraj Raso was written centuries later by Chand Bardai...and if Chand was Prithviraj's court poet, he must have been alive during Prithviraj's time..so how come he was STILL alive centuries later to write the Raso?? how many years did he live for..300 or what?? 😕
anuradhasharma thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: farahnaazz

oh my god so many stories really hatsoff for your dedication and lots of patience through which you typed such a long story thankyou so much anu it gave us so much knowledge of history 😊

hey farah!....i didnt write it...i copied it frm the link which i agve below of the whole story.😳..and paste it here....as it was tooo long ...and i know...no one wud be intrested in reading such a long story......dats why to make it intresting i added colors and highlighted dose stanzas which r very imp to read...!😉😳

actually wen i read dis article even sooo many questions arose in my mind....!

lots of prc versions!.....😳

anuradhasharma thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#17

green!

Originally posted by: anuradhasharma


According to Ferishta Prithviraj had an army of 300,000 cavalry (!), 3000 elephants (!), and innumerable infantry (what could be more innumerable after 300,000 horsemen? The entire population of the Kingdom of Ajmer?😆)

...🤔..i agree wid dis comment.....!!...

Later Rajput Kingdoms (when cavalry had become the most important formation in the army) of a similar large size had at the most 20,000 cavalry. By this comparison Prithviraj could not have had more than 10,000 horsemen.

Originally posted by: anuradhasharma



Chand Bardai states that after the first Battle of Tarain Prithviraj fell in love with, carried away, and married Sanyogita, daughter of Jaychand Rathor of Kannuaj. His love for her caused the defeat in the second battle, which is not borne out by the facts related above. According to contemporary literature, inscriptions, and coins the rulers of Kannauj were Gahadvals…the Rathors of Badaun were their tributaries. There is no record of a conflict between Ajmer and Kannauj for the simple reason that they did not have a common border.😲

really dis is shocking..!!.....is it true dat kannoj and ajmer do not hv common borders...den how sanyo reached pushker in mins ??🤔...sangars shud consider dese facts!

Originally posted by: anuradhasharma

When did Prithviraj have the time to correspond with a princess, admit his love to her, and make arrangements to carry her away from a place hundreds of miles in the east?🤔

OMG!...acc to dis comment prithvi and sanyo's story can be untrue??😭 ..or is dere some other fact which no body knows??😕


Originally posted by: anuradhasharma


The more contemporary, and accurate, account is the Prithviraj-vijay written by Jayank. This man was a Kashmiri who had settled down in Ajmer and was a poet in Prithviraj's court. 😲The names of the Chauhan Kingdom's ministers and generals are given here—interestingly one of these generals, named Udayraj, was from Bengal. The Prithviraj-vijay also describes the early communications between Ghori and the Chauhans, and the advice given to Prithviraj by the minister Kadambvas.

i thought dat chand was prithvi's coet poet...😕...now whozz jayank??😕

256747 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#18
I think Jayank was Chand's FAV son or some-thing...I had read some-where that he told Jayank to continue the work on "Prithviraj Raso" after he was gone....Soo..most probbalyy,he was the one who finished the work on it....Looks like,Chand did not live till 300 after all 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".