Is divorce and moving out worth it??

tinoo thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Recently there have been reports in the news about sussane and hrithik roshan splitting.
My friend feels that it is foolish for a woman to leave her husband, because the moment she does it then another woman will come into his life and will enjoy the riches of her husband.

My friend feels that examples should be like Krishna Kapoor and Jaya Bachchan who retained their "wife status" despite affairs of their husbands. Today they enjoy the spoils of their husband's wealth.

I gave the example of anandi and said that maybe she will get a new life with a husband who really values her... but my friend pooh-poohed it and said that anandi like fairy-tales dont happen in real life.

She also pointed out that Princess Diana when she divorced Prince Charles let go off a sizeable fortune, and a royal lifestyle.

I really didn't have words to explain what good things that women will get when they divorce -- besides their self-respect which is intangible and doesn't sound enough to offset a royal title or crores of rupees of fortune.

So guys please give me your views so that I can develop a vocabulary to give my friend a convincing answer. Thank you.


Created

Last reply

Replies

61

Views

9.5k

Users

19

Likes

245

Frequent Posters

libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Everything depends on person to person and their views on marriage
Some women don't divorce their husbands inspite of their affairs just ebcoz they are so used to lavish lives their husband's wealth has given them
Some women don't divorce their husbands more becoz of emotional reasons...maybe becoz of kids or family or even for herself...she thinks what will happen to her when she will be all alone...even though her husband may not be able to give any emotional strength to her she will still have the confidence to live in her society with her married status no matter how different the inside story looks.
I don't think Anandi's life is a fairytale...i mean it's true not every woman is lucky to have husband like Shiv but if we are talking about materialistic life then it does happen in real that women divorce their rich husband and get richer husband afterwards 😆 but it's totally irrelevant becoz riches never mattered to Anandi...she was just too lucky to have found a better husband in all aspects (nature and status)
seetha74 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
@Tinoo...very meaningful and thought provoking post ! 👏👏
Wealth and self respect...two different aspects...but intertwined in any married woman's life !!!

Divorce is the termination of a marital union... the cancelling of the legal duties and responsibilities of marriage-- and the dissolving of the bonds of matrimony between a married couple!!

Divorce can be a stressful experience affecting finances, living arrangements, household jobs, schedules and much more! Princess Diana's case is entirely different from that of any other Asian housewife !

If the family includes children, they may be deeply affected!! I think ...because of this reason Krishna Kapoor and Jaya Bacchan adjusted [??]--- compromised with their self respect !! For any mother children are more important than anything else !
Divorce is one of those life events that forces huge changes inanyone's life whether we like it or not. Moving on after divorce, no matter how strong a person you are, is challenging. You are alone in your own head every day with a range of emotions- anger... grief... humiliation... depression and fear. You are confused and overwhelmed at the same moment !Divorce is not only an emotionally trying experience, but it can be financially devastating one, as well.

A divorce itself will have significant financial impacts, as well as living alone or having to pay for child-care or support.

You will have significantly more time alone, which can be both an advantage and a disadvantage. If you have outgrown your relationship you might be more true to your current authentic self by deciding to go your own way and split. Feeling lonely is a common reaction after a divorce.

Now...I think...divorce is no more a social stigma...it is an accepted norm ...but at the same time ...it leaves a deep impact on the life styles of individuals...and opens up new challenges and new dimensions !!---as in the case of Anandi!!!


But every divorcee may not be as lucky as Anandi !
Edited by SEETHA.K - 12 years ago
brick_red thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Some people are ok with living a life of lies. They live happily in their bubble. But for some, being dishonest with self, is end of life. It will be like feeling dead inside. How do we equate wealth and status with feelings and emotions? They are two different things.
Head or heart ? Which is right?

Women decide to put up with a loveless marriage or go for divorce depending upon their personal circumstances, their values and what they want from life.
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Because Jaya chose to remain with Amitabh does not mean other women should also live with their cheating husband.

Jaya too may have decided to walk away at some time, and amitabh may have convinced her to stay. We dont know what happened. All men are not Amitabh and Raj Kapoor.

Why should Sussane care who comes into Hritik's life after she is gone? Money is the not the top priority for every woman especially if the woman has self-confidence. I am happy she chose her self-respect over her husband's money.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Suzanne Roshan's parental family is rich. She herself is a successful interior designer and runs high end decor stores. So even after leaving Hrithik, she does not have to suffer much financially. It's not like she saw crores only after marrying Hrithik.

It's person's choice what she wants and what kind of position she is in. If one's having one's own identity, earning well for onself and has nice support from parental family too then why stick to marriage only for husband's wealth?

It's about individual's priorities too. Everybody doesn't want just money and material comforts. If you feel stuck and stifled then you can't enjoy wealth. Better to move out then and compromise with factors like less material comforts than compromise with abusive or philandering ways of one's spouse.

Women have to weigh pros and cons of what they want.

Anandi's story is too dreamy. No in laws or village support a woman to this extent. In Indian society, divorced, widowed, sick and even ageing men prefer to marry single women than consider a divorced woman for marriage. Men like Shiv barely exist (which is why Shiv's so popular as a character). Families like Shekhars are also rare. Mostly families refuse such alliance outright or are all like Sanchi (bitchy, narrow minded).

It's true divorce is more of a stigma for women than men. Men get a new wife easier, than women getting a new husband. And men are more likely to get a single woman. Whereas divorced women are more likely to get divorced men, widowers or those with kids or even older ones with growing kids.

Society's still partriarchal.

I know a woman who's doing well for herself even after divorce. But also know a woman who was doing well, but gave in to depression and ended up losing everything. Her son's studies are also suffering due to her giving up her job and mental health issues.

Women must be strong and know what they are doing.
Missesha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
In either way I feel it is a woman's loss when her husband cheats on her behind her back.
If a woman divorces her hubby, there is lot she will lose apart from just wealth. Her family, her home, her dreams, her pleasures, her relations with her in laws, her entire world basically. She loses all these things that were always hers both emotionally and mentally, and something that she never wanted to part with.

If she doesn't divorce, still there are scars of broken relationships and betrayal in her mind. And she may not enjoy the wealth as much as did before. When a man cheats a woman, a woman ends up paying a price for the mistake she never did.

I don't know if divorce is a solution or compromising, but if a woman can make her man realise her value and her contribution in his life, then that would be her real win. If she can make a man repent / regret his decision of ignoring her and make him feel wrong then she would have achieved something.

Otherwise what a woman chooses to do is usually her decision.



Edited by Missesha - 12 years ago
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
i do not know if its worth it or not. each case is different. depends on if the relation is getting physically abusive etc etc... finances, husbands name these things are certainly NOT the reasons to put up with a loveless marriage, cheating husband etc etc.. well if the reasons are you want to make the marriage work at ANY cost then its a diff thing. but nor all women are well off or financially independent like ie. jaya or sussane are. some women have to put up because they are financially not independent and have no one to take care of their finances. And if such women have children then they have no choice.
in amitabh bacchan's case i think jaya decided to forgive him & he too decided to forget i think it was rekha for his family's sake.but in hrithik's case its not clear. we dont even know if there was a extramaritial affair or just compatibility or in law problems, or a case of giving work more prominence. but the sad thing is they have kids .. i just wish they had separated before the kids came.
well but the other thing (like in the case of many couple inc sussanne hrithik) is boy meets girl. love happens, marriage happens. both are financially independent. if you decide to seperate then its ok BUT THEN KIDS HAPPEN. well then you decide to seperate😲😲?????????. why.. extramaritial affair? inlaw probs? compatibilty problems? you fell in love ..YOU decided to marry...the imp thing is YOU decided to have kids. and you decide to deny the love of a mom & dad together to the kids. 😡😡. well i dont think that you have that right. you make the wrong choices n kids suffer.👎🏼 NO its the parents who have put up with the wrong decicion. .i hate couples who cheat after they have kids and decide to move on with another man/woman.

Maybe its not worth re: money etc but its worth if you decide to stay together for the kids.Most couples are on talking terms after divorces. If the kid is small ie:below two years then well they dont understand much & if they are more than 15 they are busy with other tings in life to get too much affected. but if they are 6-7 yrs old well its a bad time to separate. its a tender age where kids are attached to both parents. n cant understand things like divorce, parents fighting, affairs etc. its better to put up till the kids get a bit older & get busy with their friends etc. then separate. but if the dad is abusive, beating kidswife etc then do not stay together. the kids dont deserve such a father.

But if its not a physically abusive relation then couples can well stay in different rooms so that your kids have access to both the parents at a time. mark your boundaries in the house so that both parents cant invade in each others privacy n less fights happen & the kids are not affected. but stay together for the kids. imagine a kid of 6 to 7 yrs old & he has to adjust to not having his mom when he needs her. not having dad to play with in the evening and being put to sleep by his mom at the same time. Kids arent afffected because their mom dad dont stay together, they are affected because their mom-dad dont stay with them together. they dont want the love of mom-dad in installments separately. so well i believe if you can stand in front of each other-then stay together for the kids not as wife husband but as mom-dad. if you cant live in the same room move to diff rooms. if tht isnt possible then move to different houses but in the same building where kids can move in & out of both houses easily. is it tht difficult for couples to live as neighbours???if you have the money etc to make such arrangements????
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Shinya


Because Jaya chose to remain with Amitabh does not mean other women should also live with their cheating husband.

Jaya too may have decided to walk away at some time, and amitabh may have convinced her to stay. We dont know what happened. All men are not Amitabh and Raj Kapoor.

Why should Sussane care who comes into Hritik's life after she is gone? Money is the not the top priority for every woman especially if the woman has self-confidence. I am happy she chose her self-respect over her husband's money.

well we stil dont know for sure if hrithik's cheating was the reason for the breakup. what if it wasnt. it was only a case of growing apart, or a case of inlaw problems, or a case of giving more importance to work. and the just decided to seperate coz it was convinenent for them& satisfying to their ego( hrithik being a wanted bachelor & sussane being independent) . is itfair for the kids. re: in law probs is it fair tht you dont want to leave your parents but you can make your kids stay away from you. I think parents just live in some la la land n believe their kids are samajdaar n will adjust n wont have issuses. but in their pain n hurt of the divorce fail to see the kids being affected. these issues last a lifetime. its sad tht parent just decide to seperate coz they are NOT HAPPY TOGETHER- not because they are miserable together.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
@Missesha

I think it's hard and nearly impossible for a woman to make her man realise her worth if he's drifted away. And I find it regressive too. Men and in laws don't tolerate even small mistakes and flaws of a woman. But a woman should keep up with everything and rather work on making the man realise her worth? The Biwi No. 1 type of idea? Why?

And what can women do? Anandi kept serving Jagya's family, stopped her own parents from insulting Singhs and Jagya and herself got Bhairon to fund Jagya's studies and lifestyle, did not file any case against Jagya etc. But despite all her goodness and tolerance Jagya did not realise her worth. He never came back to her.

It was only after divorce that he began to realise Anandi's value and got more desperate when he saw she was going to remarry and there was no chance of getting her back anymore.

In reality women can only be tolerant and continue to be all nice and serving and hope for husband to realise his mistakes and get normal. One can't brainwash anyone to mend his ways soon.

Either men have to be status conscious to stick in a marriage (like Amitabh and Raj Kapoor) for their position in eyes of society or men's family has to deal with an iron hand with them (the same stars had pressure from their parents also to get back with their wives).

I don't think it's easy to behave exactly like how someone else wants you to or would like you to behave and tolerate even if he's cheating or sleeping around with someone else. It's said Mithun secretly even married Sridevi. I wonder how his wife Yogita tolerated all this!

Men's families too, I've seen, give up after some time. My relatives had given ultimatum to their son that divorce won't happen as no one in family ever did it. They tried their best to convince him to stay with his wife only. From debates to emotional blackmail - everything happened. But son was adamant. He started remaining more and more outside the house and more disconnected from family. Finally divorce did happen and his family couldn't do much. Rather they eventually supported him because they couldn't tolerate their son being so distant from them.
Men have it easier...after all...blood is thicker than water.

It's been 15 years now. The relatives barely mention the DIL they once used to support so much. Even if one or two people mention her, they shed a quiet tear for her and leave it at that blaming fate etc. Their son has remarried and they're all normal family. All those so called threats of breaking ties with him etc. faded.
No one knows whereabouts of former DIL anymore.

In-laws support to a woman is also only upto a limit I guess.

Women get a really raw deal compared to men...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".