|| Disscussion Of The Week (DOTW) #2||

Page

lakshmi

@Ephemera

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Welcome to the Maiden Discussion Thread Of this Forum

POINTS to REMEMBER
DO's
1] Discussion RELATED to the topic ONLY , Which is to say everything has to be related to the show and it's story line and Characters
2] If the whole topic is spent inside a week and there's no more to discuss, then Please PM the Thread managers requesting for a new topic
3] Citing a resource is a must IF the point made has to be supported with any canon/published articles
4]Respect should be given to all Point of Views No matter how hard it is to Digest. Healthy ... HEALTHY DEBATE is encouraged
5] MOST IMPORTANTLY ENJOY the round table discussion here

DONT's

NO SPAMMING

No Chatting whatsoever
No Bashing
No Onliners, single word/emoticon or emoticon filled posts
No discussion on personal Lives of the people involved with the show
No foul language will be tolerated

No RUMORS please, state a known fact. If it's a bit shaky or hazy cite the source along with your point

Thread managers
Main : ephiphany.
Back-up : lakshmi_3004

Edited by lakshmi_3004 - 11 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

lakshmi

@Ephemera

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Topic #1

Possession i,e.. Host-Vessel Dynamics

a) when the angels possess the humans with due consent..what happens to the soul of that vessel? as they mentioned Sam got a soul still conscious enough about his surrounding , while he Zeke is inside him . But there was no mention of Jimmy Novak or Anna Milton's consciousness

b) How did Sam's Soul got separated from his body in the first place for Death to bring back "shell" Sam as technically "Death" is nothing but Soul departing from body?

c) Sam had to drink Gallons of Demon blood to host Lucifer inside him. all through the show they have shown that Angels need permission from their vessel. So Lucifer is also treated as an angel albeit fallen one right? So do every angel need such fortification to hold them inside their human vessel ?? is that why in Season 9 early episodes they showed vessels deteriorating as in "can't withstand the amount of power"
If yes .. Then why didn't Sam drink DB again to hold zeke??
Clearly Jimmy never had to "have' anything to host Castiel except utter devotion

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

lakshmi

@Ephemera

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: herms_angel

I don't exactly remember at the moment which episode or season had this scene where Jimmy Novak, Castiel's vessel is about to die after having made attempts to save his daughter and wife from trouble. Castiel takes over his daughter and tells Jimmy that his daughter can to be a powerful vessel because of the same bloodline. But a dying Jimmy convinces Castiel to take him over instead. Castiel lets him know all that he has to before takes over him again. So, technically Jimmy novak is dead. And if my theory isn't correct, I am still pretty much going to assume he is dead and hence his soul is somewhere up there.

It's Season 4, 19 or 20th episode not sure😳
Yeah then again How can dead person give consent ??
and if it's a dying person wishing even then Its more like the Demon possession right??

Not sure about Anna as I don't recall any such details but I don't know why but I have this faint idea suggesting me that Anna had told Dean she possessed a dead person's body or something.

Quote

annihilation

@annihilation

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: lakshmi_3004
[

It's Season 4, 19 or 20th episode not sure😳
Yeah then again How can dead person give consent ??
and if it's a dying person wishing even then Its more like the Demon possession right??

No, I don't see how. I mean he give the consent before dying. Then how does it even equal demon possession?

Quote

lakshmi

@Ephemera

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: herms_angel

No, I don't see how. I mean he give the consent before dying. Then how does it even equal demon possession?

Well each of them are pressed for something liek Jimmy was pressed for his family's safety ... somehow they were coerced into giving consent so it's as good as a uninvited posession of Demon right??

Quote

lakshmi

@Ephemera

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

TOPIC #2

Father- Son Dynamics

We were Introduced to 3 generations of Winchesters.Each had their own problems .

Will John be called a negligent father when compared to Henry ??

Was John being selfish by neglecting father responsibilities??

Dean too became a father for few short moments and a father figure to Ben. How did he fare as a father ??

The only people who haven't experienced father hood in any way are Sam and Adam.so would you like to have that dimension added to their profile as well??

How much might the behavior of John Winchester might have shaped up the Sam and Dean's psyche

Quote

|| Disscussion Of The Week (DOTW) #2||

Related Topics

Explore Topics