Arjun DOTW 14th October

yes, and no. yes: it does help, to some extent and in some cases. But! When these people go back home, they come in the same environment, which means the same old friends and the chances that they go back to their old ways are really high. Unless you educate them, and also relocate them.no: here in NL we have rehab even for people who have sexually abused children/ watched childpo*nography. These people no matter where you give them a place to live, they tend to go back to their old ways. Also rapists here sometimes get rehab, and there are many cases reported that when a rapist is allowed to leave the rehab center for an afternoon with a nurse, he rapes her. So for these cases j would say no!

Firstly THANKS A LOTTT for bringign this topic for discussion...Well I was preparing for my Legal test and saw this...and my whole attention came here...hahaha ...

Well I'll start from the begenning...firstly these are my present views..as much as I know law presently through some books and shows etc.

Our legal system (I know of India but we all have bit knowledge its almost same in many nations so...) is undoubtedly the best and the most efficient department presently...
So coming to the procedures adopted...I'm totally in favour of it...
Like we all are aware yhat Arjun is a show ...and we all are aware that how our administration department is..I mean not the whole department but some or to say many...How corrupt they are...( None specific..) So if what ACP Arjun does in the show someonen else adopts the same procedure then we all instead of hearing verdits daily will be hearing encounters only...
One can imagine what a havoc it will create in the whole society when everyone I mean every officer willl start taking law in his own hands...They might kill anyone (Deciding who is guilty and who not ..)
and in return just just say that he was guilty ACCORDING TO THEM and the society ...Well not even a society DECLARE who is guilty and who not...Its only and only the JUDICIARY who is to decide who is guilty and who to be acquitted ...UNTILL THE VERDICT EVERY PERSON IS JUST ACCUSED AND INNOCENT till proven otherwise (except dowry cases..)
Ans these procedures itself show how much our judiciary and legal system is particular regarding its judgement and principle that no matter haw many guilty be acquitted but NOT EVEN 1 INNOCENT SHOULD BE PUNISHED...
After so many stages when its proven that the accused is guilty then giving him/her another chance in the name of rehabilitation according to me is totally wrong...When that person didnt give another thought before taking someone's life or doing wrong as prescribed by the law showing any sort of mercy towards that person is stupidity...BUT ITS THE DUTY OF THE JUDICIARY TO DECIDE AND NOT ANYONE IN PARTICULAR OF A SOCIETY ...( coz no matter what the no is wrong will be wrong..)

P.S :I hope I didnt go off the topic...actually I got excited so wrote what ever came in my mind...
PSS: Iam not talking of killers who are mentally disabled...coz dat forms another case...

I am not able to recall a case going regaring this I'll search and if I get or remember Ill update...
NOTE : These are my personal views as per my knowledge presenlly...and I am not defaming anyone in particular not even any department .
Thank You...!!
:)

Originally posted by: Sakuu

yes, and no. yes: it does help, to some extent and in some cases. But! When these people go back home, they come in the same environment, which means the same old friends and the chances that they go back to their old ways are really high. Unless you educate them, and also relocate them.no: here in NL we have rehab even for people who have sexually abused children/ watched childpo*nography. These people no matter where you give them a place to live, they tend to go back to their old ways. Also rapists here sometimes get rehab, and there are many cases reported that when a rapist is allowed to leave the rehab center for an afternoon with a nurse, he rapes her. So for these cases j would say no!

Originally posted by: SAKSHI..

Firstly THANKS A LOTTT for bringign this topic for discussion...Well I was preparing for my Legal test and saw this...and my whole attention came here...hahaha ...

Well I'll start from the begenning...firstly these are my present views..as much as I know law presently through some books and shows etc.

Our legal system (I know of India but we all have bit knowledge its almost same in many nations so...) is undoubtedly the best and the most efficient department presently...
So coming to the procedures adopted...I'm totally in favour of it...
Like we all are aware yhat Arjun is a show ...and we all are aware that how our administration department is..I mean not the whole department but some or to say many...How corrupt they are...( None specific..) So if what ACP Arjun does in the show someonen else adopts the same procedure then we all instead of hearing verdits daily will be hearing encounters only...
One can imagine what a havoc it will create in the whole society when everyone I mean every officer willl start taking law in his own hands...They might kill anyone (Deciding who is guilty and who not ..)
and in return just just say that he was guilty ACCORDING TO THEM and the society ...Well not even a society DECLARE who is guilty and who not...Its only and only the JUDICIARY who is to decide who is guilty and who to be acquitted ...UNTILL THE VERDICT EVERY PERSON IS JUST ACCUSED AND INNOCENT till proven otherwise (except dowry cases..)
Ans these procedures itself show how much our judiciary and legal system is particular regarding its judgement and principle that no matter haw many guilty be acquitted but NOT EVEN 1 INNOCENT SHOULD BE PUNISHED...
After so many stages when its proven that the accused is guilty then giving him/her another chance in the name of rehabilitation according to me is totally wrong...When that person didnt give another thought before taking someone's life or doing wrong as prescribed by the law showing any sort of mercy towards that person is stupidity...BUT ITS THE DUTY OF THE JUDICIARY TO DECIDE AND NOT ANYONE IN PARTICULAR OF A SOCIETY ...( coz no matter what the no is wrong will be wrong..)

P.S :I hope I didnt go off the topic...actually I got excited so wrote what ever came in my mind...
PSS: Iam not talking of killers who are mentally disabled...coz dat forms another case...

I am not able to recall a case going regaring this I'll search and if I get or remember Ill update...
NOTE : These are my personal views as per my knowledge presenlly...and I am not defaming anyone in particular not even any department .
Thank You...!!
:)

Thanks for participating dear...

Originally posted by: Jo_Pinchy

You have very well balanced your each point... yes i would agree as well that Rehab does not really work to all and therefore its a false promise.

Giving free counselling for life time, making them live in rehab does really help to know that Rehab methods do work. Instead I think its the government costs that go up.

So is retribution the only option?

hmmm no, a lot of the time people who go into jail come out worse na, depends, what is the crime.

Originally posted by: Jo_Pinchy

looks like no one is interested in discussing the topic... 🥱

hahaha wrong topic dear!

Pardon me, but just now saw this😳