27th August COncert. Who was the BEST? - Page 7

Originally posted by: ding dong

arpita really sucked

muu ki baat cheen li :-) 🤗

Originally posted by: Rumi

nisha

i would request you to listen to this concert once again.😃.i am living with melody for the last 22 years, i mean from my childhood.i also do the task of a judge in several music competitions here and there.i was only trying to use my experieance to analyse the performances of these people. of cource i admit that each of us has a diferent way of thinking , so our opinions may differ.😊

but the fact is that, i have always said that shamit is a far better singer( only singer , not performer as a whole) than Qazi usually. but that night, qazi was in sur. only he was not being able to give the subtle touch to the song as Kunal did and he was only singing it flatly like a child sings. but inspite of that it was not out of melody completely. but shamit was completely out of melody in his solo performances. i admit that he sang better with Arijit. but overall he could not perform well . he is a far better singer and he can perform far better. i said earlier that in my eyes, everyone is the same and i am imagining myself as a judge forgetting about whom i like more and whom i like less.

next time also i will judge them in this way, and i will once again forget who is shamit. who is Qazi etc.😊

Rumi you seem to be a very sweet and sincere person and i agree with your unbiased analysis altho i admit i am a qazi fan.Shammit had completely lost the sur in the second song, maybe because of the dancing and all, its not easy to dance and sing at the same time but the song he sang with arpita from the movie Aitraaz was awesome, also arijit was great. RR sang well but she needs to connect with audience more, she has such a beautiful smile and alot of charm. Arpita was good only in the aitrazz song and like the other person said her voice sounded like you are scratching your nails on chalkboard.Qazi inspite of his limitations and forgetting his lines did impress the audience and got them into a mode of excitement, he is a super performer for sure but needs to work on his sur.Actually for once today I thought RR looked slim but hey we all have different perceptions and points of view. Do you also sing Rumi? have you learnt classical? it was my one dream when i was growing up but my dad did'nt allow me.I do love singing though and took part in alot of competitions in school and college .

Originally posted by: Rumi

thanks sudha.

actually its a bit tough to forecast who will be in the fame jodi so early. let us define the candidates according to their abilities and try to find out their chances.

1. Rooprekha: very very talented singer but as a performer she is an average, she has to work on her performances. but she has a very good chance to come in the jodi. 80% chance.

2. Arpita: talented singer, but not as Rooprekha. she dances well , she has got a good feature too. but i think she is a bit mechanichal. she does not perform wholeheartedly. that's why her performance does not touch people's hearts. 70% chance

3. Shamit: very very talented singer by nature. but sometimes while singing in high peach his voice gets slightly choked, he seems to be tired. this happened at least two times. so he must be careful about this. his performance is also average. he has to work on it, only singing well will not serve the purpose. 70% chance.

4.Arijit: most talented singer among these five ratnas. he has got a superb voice. but he has to work on his performances and he has to choose right songs which will flourish his ability. he improved a lot in his performance in the concert. if he continues this standard then he has got 80% chance.

5. Qazi: average singer. but he is improving day by day. let's see how much he improves. but his plus point is his wonderful performance, which is called x- factor. x-factor is nothing, actually the secret is whatever he does, comes straight from his heart. and that's why it sounds wonderful.lately he is slightly upset that everybody is saying that he is winning only by his show-offs.and for thast he is chosing calmer songs and is not dancing wholeheartedly in the shows. but he should not pay heed to these comments. he should try to flourish whatever ability he has got. he should remember that show- off is also an ability and everybody cannot do that. he can do that and that's why he is Qazi , the heart throb of all people. for him , chosing the right song is most important. he should chose easy but beautiful songs which will touch the hearts of people and with that his wonderful performance will do the job. he has got 70% chance right now.

6. Sandeep: this boy has surprised me. why he was not chosen in the first round??? he is extremely talented singer. his only drawback is his voice lacks originality. he should not copy a singer totally. he should sing it in his own style. he has every possible subtle work in his voice. he will give a tough competition to the existing people. his plus point is that . not only he is a very good singer . he is a very good performer also. that means, arijit and Qazi at a time. how much chance he has got, cannot be said right now. i will have to watch him more for that.

7. Monica: good singer, but not a very brilliant performer. about her chances... ummm. i have to watch her more for that.

Remember that these chances may change according to performances. all i said, if they continue like this then this may happen. but as we have already seen that brilliant singers have also sang badly on a particular evening. afterall all of them are human beings and we know that they can make mistakes at anytime.😃

Rumi,

once again very well written and thats exactly the way I feel too, BRAVO👏 👏 Rumi.

Originally posted by: Rumi

thanks sudha.

actually its a bit tough to forecast who will be in the fame jodi so early. let us define the candidates according to their abilities and try to find out their chances.

1. Rooprekha: very very talented singer but as a performer she is an average, she has to work on her performances. but she has a very good chance to come in the jodi. 80% chance.

2. Arpita: talented singer, but not as Rooprekha. she dances well , she has got a good feature too. but i think she is a bit mechanichal. she does not perform wholeheartedly. that's why her performance does not touch people's hearts. 70% chance

3. Shamit: very very talented singer by nature. but sometimes while singing in high peach his voice gets slightly choked, he seems to be tired. this happened at least two times. so he must be careful about this. his performance is also average. he has to work on it, only singing well will not serve the purpose. 70% chance.

4.Arijit: most talented singer among these five ratnas. he has got a superb voice. but he has to work on his performances and he has to choose right songs which will flourish his ability. he improved a lot in his performance in the concert. if he continues this standard then he has got 80% chance.

5. Qazi: average singer. but he is improving day by day. let's see how much he improves. but his plus point is his wonderful performance, which is called x- factor. x-factor is nothing, actually the secret is whatever he does, comes straight from his heart. and that's why it sounds wonderful.lately he is slightly upset that everybody is saying that he is winning only by his show-offs.and for thast he is chosing calmer songs and is not dancing wholeheartedly in the shows. but he should not pay heed to these comments. he should try to flourish whatever ability he has got. he should remember that show- off is also an ability and everybody cannot do that. he can do that and that's why he is Qazi , the heart throb of all people. for him , chosing the right song is most important. he should chose easy but beautiful songs which will touch the hearts of people and with that his wonderful performance will do the job. he has got 70% chance right now.

6. Sandeep: this boy has surprised me. why he was not chosen in the first round??? he is extremely talented singer. his only drawback is his voice lacks originality. he should not copy a singer totally. he should sing it in his own style. he has every possible subtle work in his voice. he will give a tough competition to the existing people. his plus point is that . not only he is a very good singer . he is a very good performer also. that means, arijit and Qazi at a time. how much chance he has got, cannot be said right now. i will have to watch him more for that.

7. Monica: good singer, but not a very brilliant performer. about her chances... ummm. i have to watch her more for that.

Remember that these chances may change according to performances. all i said, if they continue like this then this may happen. but as we have already seen that brilliant singers have also sang badly on a particular evening. afterall all of them are human beings and we know that they can make mistakes at anytime.😃

I agree with each and every statement!😃👏

KUDOOS... Nice to have a great analyzer on this forum.
Hope Rumi will stay till the final Jodi is selected and keep posting the unbiased views. 😃

I am QAZI fan. Shamit is going out next week. 😆

Originally posted by: baiju

KUDOOS... Nice to have a great analyzer on this forum.
Hope Rumi will stay till the final Jodi is selected and keep posting the unbiased views. 😃

I am QAZI fan. Shamit is going out next week. 😆

Aaapp ke muu mien ghee aur shakur . :-) 👏👏

Qazi is having lead of 16 votes till now!

WOW QAZI really ROCKS!! 👏