27th August COncert. Who was the BEST? - Page 5

Originally posted by: Rumi

i am not anybody's fan. so i have no bindings for praising someone special.i would like to give an unbiased view.
1. Rooprekha: she was perfectly melodious this night. she was singing perfectly well, but her outfits were not good, i think. she was looking more fat in it. and she has to improve her dancing ability a bit.9/10
2. Arijit: he was also perfectly melodious. he was never away a bit from his melodies. he sang perfectly well. he co-ordinated with audience well. there is no harm in singing patriotic songs. till today, patriotic songs are those songs which can make people enthusiastic in all situations.9/10
3.Arpita: she was looking stunning. she sang well also. but that spark which is required for a concert was missing in her performance.she has to think about it.8/10
4.Qazi:he was also looking stunning. but the main problem is he had chosen a very difficult song at first. 'Janab e Ali' is a very difficult song sung by Kunal and it has very subtle works towards the end of every line. to sing those ones is not easy and for Qazi it is nearly impossible. naturally he failed. he is not suitable for these songs. it is suitable for Arijit, but not for him. he would have chosen a flat song and would sing better. but overall, Qazi saved himself with his x-factor like he does always.6/10
5.Shamit:shamit failed totally. if i were the judge i would ask him, aap ka sur kidhar gaya bhai??? he was far away from his melodies. he was only shouting and not singing. it seemed that he was very tired throughout the performance. i don't know why, but he can sing a way better than his performance in the concert. may be he was not fit that day. may be he was ill. but it was completely a messs.4/10
i know people here are fans of certain people. but i am only saying all these unbiasedly. i did not want to hurt anybody by this post.so if anybody feels hurt, i am sorry. forgive me.

VERY WELL JUDGED 👏👏

i only dissagree with qazi and shamit...qazi should get 4/10 and shamit should get 6/10...qazi forgot his dancin steps and he for got hios lines in da song no no...he sang no no ..lalalalalalla...he forgot wat to say...and i find tht very very pathetic....he needs to work on it more...cuase he was quite a dissapointment...last night..... 😕 😳

I agree about Shamit getting 4/10. In his second song he forgot everything about the SURs. He was just plainly speaking his lines instead of singing. His song was just like when a kid runs for 100 meters and start speaking, breathing heavily, again speaking few word in between his breath.

i have given Qazi 2 marks more as
1. Qazi was not completely out of melody. he was singing a song, which has subtle works in it , quite flatly. in this way he failed. but still he was roughly in his melody. yes, he forgot two words, but that is not so much important i think. because in competitions, more marks are alotted for melody. on the other hand, shamit was nowhere near the right melody.
2. in spite of everything, Qazi managed to attract people for his natural x-factor.he is habituated to do so, as he never sings that well, he just manages to sing well anyhow.on the other hand shamit was trying hard, but he was looking very tired and he has no x-factor like Qazi. he is a singer as a whole.this night, he could not sing well unlike his other performances ,and he himself understood that, so he was becoming more and more frustrated for that and looking tired and in this way nothing was left in his performance.
so Qazi got 6 and Shamit got 4. but never mind, shamit is a good singer and i believe that he will show his abulity next time.

Shamit left his sur and Qazi was in tune? Pity you guys couldn't listen better. I loved Shamit's perf., it was awesome in all respects.

Rumi, I agree with your views.

And I like your signature. 😊 😊 I hope you are not going to jump down. 😃

I think Shamit wasn't able to perform 2 songs at a time.. qazis solo wasn't wah i wud wan it to be :( .. arijit was good.. n rooprekha 2... arpita sings well buh shes a lil dead.. buh shed b good 4 playbak n juss playbak...

I love all the performance....

but I really loved Arijit, Rupu and Qazi's perfromance
and Shamit and Arijit was rocking 2gether. 😃

princess your avatar is very cute :-)

Shamit! Shamit rocked.

I was actually rather disappointed with Qazi's performance. I don't like the choice of song. But Shamit & Arijit together rocked.