dalerji is veryyyy eduvated in what he is judging.. he is a bit hars, but so is Palah, he os over emotional over his students..
Yes Daler is definately qualified to judge, but he is NOT the be-all and end-all, Although he seems to think that his opinion and his word should always be the final. He is definitely a great singer, but he is not the only good singer in the world. That having been said, yes, lots of the things he tells the students..need to be told. They do require improvement. Had he been completely unbiased and equally judged everyone, I may even forgive his lack of manners and ego.
The main argument here is that there is a way to say everything. Criticism should be given in a positive manner in order to help the contestant's to improve. He is obnoxious, condescending and derogatory. That is where he is wrong. You can be firm yet do so in a dignified manner and still get ur point across. It is amusing how he tries to get the final word in everything either by singing his stupid songs...or by arguing and being rude. That is not acceptable.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion, so is he. It's his job to judge and he should do so impartially, without any hang-ups and in a respectable manner. Throwing your weight around is not acceptable.
