Jodha Akbar 23: The heart prevails

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

The abiding image of today's episode was the very last one: Jalal and Bairam Khan in a tight embrace, silhouetted against the sky. It warmed my heart as nothing else in all these nearly 5 weeks of Jodha Akbar, for in one fell sweep, it blew away the miasma of siyasat, of power gained and power lost, of cynical games played with the lives of others. All of that will undoubtedly return, and in force, but for this one brief moment, the air was pure and fresh, and the heart prevailed.

The final encounter between Jalal and his Khan Baba, which was far more emotional than anything Bairam Khan would ever have permitted his pupil to indulge in - he does not allow even tears at the death of Jalal's father - did not only redeem the former Wazir-e-Aala. It also saved Jalal from doing something he would never have been able to get over for the rest of his life, destroying the man who, whatever his present failings, had provided him with a father figure for all of his growing years. It was his Khan Baba's final, priceless gift to his pupil.

The end scene also proved, beyond all doubt, that Jalal not only has a heart, but that he does not need a Jodha to teach him how to use it. I had written earlier that he has an admirable trait: he is grateful for any and all kindnesses done to him. This is remarkable and rare in a king, for kings have a highly developed sense of entitlement, and see the loyalty and devotion of their followers as no more than their due; gratitude is out of the question. Not so with Jalal, and this is an innate quality that has always been there.

This was more in evidence today than ever before in the debate over how to tackle Bairam Khan's rebellion. Jalal seems lost as his heart struggles with his head , while Mahaam Anga, her eyes as hard as agates, and Hamida Banu Begum, looking exactly like the Before part of a Saridon ad for headaches😉, fight for his soul. Sandwiched between them, their clashing arguments washing over him, Jalal agonizes, brow furrowed in helpless indecision.

I could not understand exactly what his Ammijaan wants him to do - go and fall on his Khan Baba's neck and beg his forgiveness? For a woman who has been an Empress, even if only briefly, she seems to have no notion of the imperatives of state power and the bounden duties of an emperor. Perhaps it comes from her not being of royal blood, but she sounds all the time like the 16th century version of a Salvation Army preacher😉.

Mahaam Anga is predictable, but she is far from sure of her hold on Jalal, for she is rattled when Ammijaan surges forth from the wings, plonks herself behind her son, and collars his left ear for her homilies. As Jalal, already haunted by old memories of his Khan Baba, wavers, Mahaam Anga's eyes mirror near despair.

It takes all the finely calculated eloquence of Ruqaiya - whose rousing address is, in its way, as cleverly tailored for its one man audience as Mark Antony's classic Friends, Romans, countrymen speech in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar was to the Roman crowd - to bring Jalal round to putting the needs of imperial power over the gratitude and affection of a lifetime. As he rides out of the city gates in full battle regalia, after a full-throated battle cry,Yalgaar! , it does seem that the head has won out at last, and he is, fully and without reservations, as ruthless as an emperor needs to be.

But beyond the gates stands Bairam Khan, arms akimbo like one awaiting crucifixion, and everything is turned upside down in an instant. The Ruqaiya-Mahaam Anga combo might have swayed Jalal for a while, but never forever. The real Jalal is the one who drops his sword in an instant, kneels next to his mentor and holds him close.

When he does so, and as he speaks of his Khan Baba of old, the accumulated bitterness of the last few weeks is washed away in a tide of emotion that heals them both. The inevitable parting will no longer be a corrosive one. And looking ahead, when Bairam Khan is killed by an old enemy on the way to Mecca, there will be no unbearable burden of guilt on Jalal's soul.

Mahaam Anga-Ruqaiya: I was waiting for Ruqaiya's promised chaal to get back at Mahaam Anga after the Zaheer fiasco, but the CVs apparently forgot about that. Now they have metamorphosised into a pair of most unlikely allies, against Hamida Banu Begum for the present, and even more so against Jodha when the time comes, for they will soon sense her threat potential.

For now, I enjoyed the candid cynicism with which Ruqaiya bares her real motive in coaxing Jalal to take Bairam Khan head on, and the instant pact between her and Mahaam Anga, which was strongly reminiscent of the one of 1941 between Hitler and Stalin. It will probably last just as long!

The new Ruqaiya: She is clearly much better looking than the old one. Her face is smooth in its lacquered perfection, and she has all the nazakat needed for the Malika-e-Hind. But her face, with the light eyes, looks like a cold mask, and she seems to be far more overtly arrogant and unfeeling than the old one was.

The old Ruqaiya was a creature both strong and insecure, arrogant and vulnerable.On Tuesday last, she was so convincing in her misery and her frailities, in the prison and then with Jalal in their bedchamber.There was also a nervous gentleness in the way she handled Jalal then. I somehow cannot see the stylish mask of a face that this new one has bringing out those nuances. The Ruqaiya during the hunt was already harder.

They are also making her out, suddenly, to be a political power, collecting the jaziya and lecturing Jalal on the duties and responsibilities of kingship. Gone is any evidence of the chronic insecurity about her hold on him that was most sharply in evidence on Tuesday, which was rooted in her childlessness. She now looks every inch the confident, favourite First Consort, flaunting the Malika-e-Hind title that was never used before. This Ruqaiya does not seem likely to seek reaffirmations from her lord and master about her being his most chaheti begum. The Malika-e-Hind would have no such doubts. What has happened all of a sudden?

It seems likely that the CVs, had, without really meaning to do so, created a fresh and fascinating Ruqaiya, intelligent, tantalizing, and Jalal's trusted partner in life, but yet with many vulnerabilities and secret griefs, unable to let him know what she feels for him for fear of losing the closeness to him that she cannot live without. What they apparently need, in their standard issue 'good girl- bad boy about to turn good' scenario, is a bad girl to set off the good girl's goodness. And the prime candidate for this is, who else, Ruqaiya.

I am thus more than half afraid, looking at the new Ruqaiya of the last two days, that they will soon leach out everything that made the character fascinating and vulnerable at the same time, and reduce her to a standard issue negative female from any TV soap. Like Bahar in Mughal-e-Azam, even after allowing for her being the seniormost queen. That would be a very great pity. Let us hope she escapes that sad fate!

Jodha-Ruqaiya: Well, the keenly awaited Jodha-Jalal encounter proved, not unexpectedly, to be a no show, as the two of them circled that tree so many times that it seemed impossible for him not to hear the sound of her payals, or even to step on the end of her trailing odhni! But still I enjoyed it, especially Jodha's quick-wittedness in scaring the deer away with smoke (she has apparently done a Girl Guides course in camping, including lighting a fire without a match!😉)

In this, the first of her successful encounters with Ruqaiya, an indirect one, she was helped greatly by Ruqaiya taking an inordinate amount of time for her shot. If she does this all the time, she would not be able to hit even a slow moving elephant!

What was intriguing here was the detachment with which Jalal views the whole proceeding, commenting, in an unconscious echo of Arjuna's maxim in the Mahabharata, that her focus must be total and she must, in some way, become one with the target. He also senses the smoke - there is something in the air, the winds are changing, he says - even before he sees the smouldering twigs. When he does see them, his eyes light up in genuine amusement and appreciation of the trick played on Ruqaiya.

In the second one encounter, about the jaziya, Jodha had all the best lines, though entirely predictable ones, and she rounded it off by the grand gesture of handing over a priceless necklace in payment of the tax for the whole lot of the pilgrims. Apparently the Malika-e-Hind is also a closet chartered accountant, seeing that she does a lightning calculation and sets off the value of the necklace against a whole year's jaziya (for how many pilgrims?😉

Jodha : They are getting some things about her just right. I liked two things about Jodha yesterday.

One was the calm dignity, firm but free of arrogance, with which she put that cheeky chunari seller in her place, capping that by draping the expensive chunari - fit only for the Mughal Shahenshah's begums - over her maid's head. It was a splendid put down, much better than chewing the woman out,and she added a solid retort about Mughal shehzadis and Rajputanis to sew everything up. Of course it was the 150 mohras that spoke the loudest, but she handled the whole impeccably.

She handles the jaziya encounter with Ruqaiya with the same clear-eyed, non-confrontational firmness, and emerged the winner. She will handle Mahaam Anga the same way when the time comes for that.

Second, I liked the open, childlike (not childish) way in which she laughed when Motibai ends up with mud all over her face and over that 150 mohra chunari. It was like a carefree little girl, and it was charming.

That Jodha treats her maid as her equal is admirable, but there has to be a limit to that. I did not like the way Motibai bargained for that chunari like a housewife in a fish bazaar, without waiting so see what Jodha felt about it at all. She should keep the rank and dignity of her mistress in mind. It looked bad, and it only highlighted the need for some staff discipline. The Mughal court is far more hierarchical and formal, and if Jodha treats the servants there in the same way as in Amer, and tries to befriend all and sundry, she will soon be in the suds. A queen must be kind, but a bit aloof and dignified as well; otherwise the staff will start being presumptuous.

The constant refrain in this serial is about how Jodha will change Jalal for the better. But it is equally important for her to change herself where it is necessary. As I wrote elsewhere, Jodha could, so far, afford to be as simple and straightforward as she is because she has never faced any serious dilemmas,any great danger, any great tragedies, in her life as Jalal has. She has never been as lonely as he is, so lonely that he does not even know that he is lonely. Lonely in that he has no one with whom he can connect with the certitude that the person is not out to use him one way or the other. He is the closest of all to Ruqaiya, and still, when she praises his appearance, he is sure she wants something from him.

Jodha can thus afford to see things in black white, to run to save a pigeon or a deer, and to lecture her family on the Rajput code of honour.

The first time she is going to be pulled both ways is about Sujamal, and the beginnings of this were evident at the Yamadwitiya ceremony. When he joins up with the enemy to redress what he sees as a great injustice done to him, Jodha will understand that there need not be one clear right and one clear wrong, and she will suffer with him. As Jalal suffers when Zaheer is blinded and later dies, when Takhtmal is murdered, and when so many other things go very badly wrong despite him.

Jodha will have to grow up, to learn that life is not so simple, that there are competing pressures that have to be balanced, and that for an emperor, his empire and its needs come before all else. That often the choice is not between the good and the bad, but between the lesser of two wrongs. That the imperatives of statecraft often cannot be subjected to personal concepts of right and wrong, or to those of human sympathy.

Unless she does this, she will never be able to get to the inner Jalal, and her influence over him, which is the keystone of this tale, will never reach the critical mass needed to change him.

Questions for the day: Jodha is shown celebrating what is apparently Deepavali in Amer. The Yamadwitiya is the day after Deepavali, and is popularly known in North India as Bhaidooj. She is carried in a palki all the way from Amer, with a longish halt in Bhanpur, to Mathura. How does she manage to reach Mathura for the Yamadwitiya?

And how does Sujamal, with whom she has no way of communicating , also turn up there on the dot?

Joke of the day: Suryabhan Singh, on hearing of the falling out between Jalal and Bairam Khan, proclaiming that Yeh Jalal ko aur bhi (?!?) kamzoor bana dega, and so it would be no big deal for him to defeat Jalal and fulfill his promise to Jodha about, what else, getting her Jalal's head. I almost fell off my chair laughing. Famous last words!!

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Edited by sashashyam - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

74

Views

13.7k

Users

27

Likes

195

Frequent Posters

-Eris- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Aww wonderful as usual Mam!!

The new Ruqaiya is already turning out to be the vamp I loved the old one and a part of me wanted more RJ scenes as she was portrayed grey beautifully. This one is making it easy to hate her so when the time comes we fall for jalal jodha easily..

Probably Jodha and the brothers go to the place every year and that s the reason Sujamal came..

Moti is becoming irritating .. the way she bargained as if they could not afford it .. never knew the royals bargained but when Jodha paid double the money she accepted it gracefully...

I felt really bad for Bahram Khan today and Jalal has a heart and it s the evil tri o which have stopped him from using it for their own motives..
Was waiting yesterday for ur post 😳( I mean am in India and it s the next day already 😆)

Edited by vibz88 - 12 years ago
apolloartemis thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Wonderful as always Aunty!
And yes, spot on with Ruq- already I can feel my sympathy leeching away. As you said, behind this new Ruq's porcelain (and very pretty) face lies little of the vulnerability and I would dare say, dignity of the old ruq. I already know who I shall be cheering for in the Ruq-Jodha encounters, whereas earlier, I might have hesitated a little before cheering Jodha on!
And you comments on Jodha are right- she will grow up as these difficulties come to pass. Already I can see her bond with Sujamaal fading as he sides with the Mughals against Amer. When Suryabhan dies/is injured badly (as shown in the promos) how sympathetic will she be? How much will her heart bleed for Sujamal as she is trussed up as a offering to a man she loathes with all her heart? We can already see a new, stronger Jodha emerging, and I look forward to her confrontations with the Mughal court.
Liked her scene with Ruq today. Jodha's quiet smile, her confidence, and her sassy answers- all while her brothers stood mute! Very nice to see!
BlackWitch thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
It is a really good thing I absolutely love reading . Otherwise reading this detailed analysis at 3:30 am would be next to impossible and I would miss out on some really good reads like yours, Mrs. Cowsik 😊

I love the way you get so in depth with the characters in the story. Finding nuances in the story and the character that I'm not very sure Ekta's creatives notice, going by the blunders they make at times. I'm glad about the happy coincidence that their stories, at first atleast, turn out to be really good stuff before going haywire towards the end (which is usually the middle of the series, but they milk the cow as much as possible).

Like you, I'm quite enchanted with Ruqaiya's character as well. I agree with the different portrayals shown by Smiley and Lavina that you have pointed out. I noticed just the same. Smiley (IMO) is an incompetent actor, but her portrayal of Ruqaiya was way more likeable than what Lavina's has been. Given more expressions on her face, I would have preferred her anyday. Lavina is by far the better actor, however, the shades of grey have only deepened with her and its been such a sudden change that it is noticeable to everyone who watches and likes her character! It is so obviously going towards an outright negative portrayal of Ruqaiya that truly I'm very disappointed. I want the character to be, as you said, vulnerable and yet strong. I'm sure Lavina can carry that off as well, as her acting skills are far superior than Smiley's. I have no idea if its the creatives who have asked her to be the vamp in the making. Sooo Ekta-ish.

Yes, the confrontation between BK and Jalal were truly endearing and heartwarming. But the question of the day should be - How did he suddenly capitulate when he was hollering about being a proud Baagi few episodes before? 😕 There was no remorse on his face or any realization. Just arrogance. Did Ekta cut off some scenes to make the wedding happen faster? Or was there some cue I missed which justified him standing there to be beheaded as he finally realizes his mistakes?

The AkDha scene really made me wanna smack my forehead. How can Jalal hear her payal when she is farther from him than when she is few steps away circling around the very same tree? With skills like those, one wonders how he hasn't been assassinated yet... They could atleast have shown Jalal seeing Jodha. What was the harm in that? Just another insight into her character. Maybe a mockery of a smile on his face regarding her valiant attempts would have been better viewing for the long suffering viewer.

Truly, I wondered the same thing. Did Sujamal know she was going to be there by the riverside? Does she go there every Bhaidooj? Maybe that's the reason she was waiting for him thinking he would definitely come. Also, how was it safe for the Rajputs to venture directly into Mughal territory with such few guards? And actually draw attention to oneself? 😕

Jodha was most elegant while dealing with Ruqaiya. She was such a little paragon of virtue, but surprisingly a dignified one. Or maybe Ruqaiya has become too vampish NOT to make the main lead's niceness stand out. TYPICAL.

Seriously, what is WRONG with Jalal's Mom? It's like she is a sheltered little girl who doesn't know the ways of the world! First she says its necessary for love to be there while having sex for a woman to conceive. And now she says Jalal should just let BK walk all over him cuz he is like his Walid. I mean, who GIVES that advice to a King? I won't give it to my little son! (if I had one!) She should have suggested something more meaningful, more becoming of the stature she has in the Mughal household, rather than acting like a sheltered school girl in the robes of a Queen. Btw, Saridon comment was BANG ON! 😆
smile.sara thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
0h my Dear Aunty Ji!!
I am thinking to write some thing on today epi ...but with kids didn't find time and most all I don't have fine words like you...
every thing you were saying, continuously roaming in my mind since I watched epi...
Specially Hamida bano Begumm..she was such an irritating today.. some one said today that Jalal listened to her mother instead of MA n RB But
no it was BK humility due to which Jalal forgave him.., if still remain arraogant really what his mother anted from not only his son but from true waris and shahnshah of saltanat. they showed Ruqayya motive selfish. I didn't find it selfish... for pitty sake this was the reality of power play and politics.
other point is about all of sudden promotion from baigum sahiba to malika e hind. the show plot is is become very diff that from start... now Mughal rules are cruel but not barbaric.
for e.g in start Mughal soldiers just saw tempel and chal pade loot machine here they were collecting tax,... and all amir raj rujkuar and rajkumari roaming freely in Mughal area doing shopping. no khauf k Mughal saina may be attack.
first when jodha bibi started arguing with Mughal fierce soldiers .. I was like is k bhaiyon ka ky kaam hae bhai .. n this bhagwan daas... bharmal ji should seriously consider to make his heir jodha istead of this pyara bhola bacha... not only big brothers was there but also future raja of her state...
Ruqayya begum ya her script writer surely don't know any thing where Hajj perform and who is eligible to take Hajj tax.. surely Hajj doesn't perform in india, how should they know who is going out from country is going for Hajj spec at tht time ... this tax is takn by the govt of saudia/Arab... not from hisdustan like Mathura is in hisdustan I am not justifying this tax and every 1 knows it ll be take back by Akabr later ofcourse in influence of jodha kiun k us ki apni tau koi soch hae hi nhi phir hoga RB ka dhan dhan... khair I was saying that even today like I have US passport and I can have my saudia visa at airport but not for Hajj... hajj visa is totally different whose payment all go in the pocket of Saudia govt,... at that I think it was ottoman empire who was the protector of haram shareef I don't know exactly... but poin is k there is no need, RB to say this fisadi sentence k "wo hamare mazhab k hae is lye unk choot hae". chichi
I know this is fictional show and also a disclaimer bhaii sahib is also here BUT any one really think k fictional liberty can give them liberty to portray a very respectful woman of her time evil ... we r not fool so we r surely not on roads but pls don't spoil original historical character so they will turn 100 perc evil and... hey r showing a fictional character surya bhan angel and real historical respectful character of a Mughal empress evill. pls CV n PH do what you want with fictional character but not with the real historical charcters..
Last but not last that Mahan speech of Jodha on Equality humaneness ... it was superb ...
I hope k yah equality of humanity ka lecture jodha kisi unchi zaat wale ko bharhaman ya khashtri ko bhi dae jab wo ksisi achoot/shudr ko zalil kar raha ho...

Edited by smile.sara - 12 years ago
charminggenie thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Well, a massive gigantic hug from me, this is beyond perfection, the way you have captured every emotion,act and the events is simply brilliant. Reading you is probably like watching a Picasso both work of admiration yet they engross you so much that one is left with deep sense of understanding and warmth . Forever in awe of you!

Jalal and Bharam Khan- By far the most beautiful scene ever captured in this show and dare i say, it will be really difficult to top this. An Emperor roaring his horse to Yalgar ho , as he braces to fight the rogue who till now was a father-figure to him. Jalal was marching toward the most difficult battle of his entire life. But what a sight to greet him, Bharam khan with his hands outstretched and head bowed, standing a foot outside the Mughalai Mahal was a testimony to the man. There was this ruthless General without his armor, coming to terms with his own reality. BK was always loyal to the throne, he considered himself the sacred soldier and this is why he was blinded by the powers bestowed on him . He considered himself the only savior of Mughal Empire, he just couldn't trust anyone else to run the kingdom. Somewhere in this , he lost his sight from Jalal , he couldnt identify the ruler he has become. He couldnt grasp how the boy, he has been grooming to be the Talisman of this empire has come of age. But now he has realized that by revolting againt Jalal he was challenging the throne, this I guess didn't sit well with his own morals and life's principle, hence the man with his head in a bow. With this simple action he re-gained his position in Jalal's life, the way Jalal dropped his sword and went on his knees and hugged his Khan Baba , one could sense a relieved son. He won't have to live with the guilt. he was out of the dilemma of being an Emperor or a son. His love, kindness and respect shows that Jalal was born to be an Akbar, maybe for our imaginations he needed a Jodha to discover that, but he always had an heart. Without a wiff of arrogance , he enveloped his Khan Baba, this shows the greatness of this ruler. BK can never accept or work again for Jalal , he is a man of integrity , so his Mecca journey is the only conclusion. His subsequent death won't be a hard blow to Jalal now, he has made him peace with his baba.
A king is born to win battles, this was his "Rajdharam", so Like Ahsoka, Maurya etc , Jalal had to resort to wars, battles, killing before he reached his Kalinga which I think was more of his acceptance to various religions and a fairly tolerant outlook to life. It was his rule which made Mughals from visitors to natives. A very intriguing personality this Jalal is, i cannot wait to see his other facets.

Jalal and the three wise women- What an unsavory position to be for any man. Maha Angha was edgy and too eager for Jalal to use his sword on BK, but Hamida Begum broke the scene with her Nirupama Roy monologue and reminding about BK's sacrifices, failing to sound like an Empress of India, how can she not perceive that BK is revolting against her son , a treason to the throne. She , like the history suggests, was very naive and too detached from the realities of political maneuvers. Jalal's voicing the importance of the three women in his life, made me wonder when did Ami jaan became this close to her son, quite a departure from their 1st meeting.

Ruqaiya Regum proved again, why she is equal to Jalal, she placated both the elder ladies, but tilted the axis in her favour. Her alliance with MA is going to shape up when Jodha steps in the harem. a word on the new RB, I liked the vulnerability and softness Smiley brought but I know this new girl is really talented , I think if they don' henpeck her as a future vamp , she would do good.


Jodha- I second whatever you wrote, there is nothing I can add to that, just that I am very amused that how in her own kingdom Jodha practiced purdah and travelled in palki, while here in Mughal neighborhood she is prancing without a care of the world announcing her Rajputa and verbally quarreling with Mallika-E-hind. I like the calmness and grace she has but I hope she doesnt turn into the typical Ekta's woman, savior with all the righteousness of the world.

I rest with the memories of the epic scene between Jalal and BK that for me overshadowed everything, Brilliantly enacted by both actors.

Two your queries - it's Ekta's world, here everything is possible as long s logic stays put.

Much love and thank you for your reply to my previous post, will it be embarrassing if i mention how many times I read it, meant a lot!





SonyaBlade thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Excellent analysis and excellent episode today. Bairam Khan and Jalal definitely had the best scene that we have seen. \

I do have to critic jalal's acting a bit though - during the BK scene his facial expressions sometimes make me want to laugh and I find took away emotionally a little bit from the scene, but because it was just a quick glimpse at Jalal, I was able to get over it soon enough. The facial expressions - I'm not sure what he can do to make them more natural, but that's just it...they seem to be forced as opposed to just coming naturally at times...a well - we can't have everything.

As to your question of the day - I have learned long ago, from the time my mom made me watch hindi drama's with her when I was 10 years old, that the laws of physics, time, principles of science and mathematics do not apply in the world of a Hindi Drama. Heros' can defy gravity, heroines can stall time and everyone has the power to time travel as they see fit.

lol...obviously I'm joking, but it is true in some cases... not only Hindi drama;'s but in hollywood films as well. I just saw the newest Star Trek and the storyline made no sense...Ahhh the creative liberties that are taken...but I digress...

that's all for now.
riyya6 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sashashyam

The abiding image of today's episode was the very last one: Jalal and Bairam Khan in a tight embrace, silhouetted against the sky. It warmed my heart as nothing else in all these nearly 5 weeks of Jodha Akbar, for in one fell sweep, it blew away the miasma of siyasat, of power gained and power lost, of cynical games played with the lives of others. All of that will undoubtedly return, and in force, but for this one brief moment, the air was pure and fresh, and the heart prevailed.

The final encounter between Jalal and his Khan Baba, which was far more emotional than anything Bairam Khan would ever have permitted his pupil to indulge in ' he does not allow even tears at the death of Jalal's father - did not only redeem the former Wazir-e-Aala. It also saved Jalal from doing something he would never have been able to get over for the rest of his life, destroying the man who, whatever his present failings, had provided him with a father figure for all of his growing years. It was his Khan Baba's final, priceless gift to his pupil.

The end scene also proved, beyond all doubt, that Jalal not only has a heart, but that he does not need a Jodha to teach him how to use it. I had written earlier that he has an admirable trait: he is grateful for any and all kindnesses done to him. This is remarkable and rare in a king, for kings have a highly developed sense of entitlement, and see the loyalty and devotion of their followers as no more than their due; gratitude is out of the question. Not so with Jalal, and this is an innate quality that has always been there.

i did love the BK -Jalal scene. But i find acting wise, was not that good... And how come all of sudden BK had change of heart is really hard to digest...But i liked the scene for one that even though BK has done many things for power n all, he trult love Jalal n vice versa. We could see the bonding there...
This was more in evidence today than ever before in the debate over how to tackle Bairam Khan's rebellion. Jalal seems lost as his heart struggles with his head , while Mahaam Anga, her eyes as hard as agates, and Hamida Banu Begum, looking exactly like the Before part of a Saridon ad for headaches, fight for his soul. Sandwiched between them, their clashing arguments washing over him, Jalal agonizes, brow furrowed in helpless indecision.

I could not understand exactly what his Ammijaan wants him to do ' go and fall on his Khan Baba's neck and beg his forgiveness? For a woman who has been an Empress, even if only briefly, she seems to have no notion of the imperatives of state power and the bounden duties of an emperor. Perhaps it comes from her not being of royal blood, but she sounds all the time like the 16th century version of a Salvation Army preacher.

Mahaam Anga is predictable, but she is far from sure of her hold on Jalal, for she is rattled when Ammijaan surges forth from the wings, plonks herself behind her son, and collars his left ear for her homilies. As Jalal, already haunted by old memories of his Khan Baba, wavers, Mahaam Anga's eyes mirror near despair.

I seriously dun understand the lady playing his real mum Ammi jaan... hes expression n all not convincing enough...
It takes all the finely calculated eloquence of Ruqaiya ' whose rousing address is, in its way, as cleverly tailored for its one man audience as Mark Antony's classic Friends, Romans, countrymen speech in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar was to the Roman crowd ' to bring Jalal round to putting the needs of imperial power over the gratitude and affection of a lifetime. As he rides out of the city gates in full battle regalia, after a full-throated battle cry ,Yalgaar! , it does seem that the head has won out at last, and he is, fully and without reservations, as ruthless as an emperor needs to be.
N why did ruqaiya supported Maham Anga this time, i fail to understand... anyone

But beyond the gates stands Bairam Khan, arms akimbo like one awaiting crucifixion, and everything is turned upside down in an instant. The Ruqaiya-Mahaam Anga combo might have swayed Jalal for a while, but never forever. The real Jalal is the one who drops his sword in an instant, kneels next to his mentor and holds him close.

When he does so, and as he speaks of his Khan Baba of old, the accumulated bitterness of the last few weeks is washed away in a tide of emotion that heals them both. The inevitable parting will no longer be a corrosive one. And looking ahead, when Bairam Khan is killed by an old enemy on the way to Mecca, there will be no unbearable burden of guilt on Jalal's soul. : yes, jalal soul will be on guilt

Mahaam Anga-Ruqaiya: I was waiting for Ruqaiya's promised chaal to get back at Mahaam Anga after the Zaheer fiasco, but the CVs apparently forgot about that. Now they have metamorphosised into a pair of most unlikely allies, against Hamida Banu Begum for the present, and even more so against Jodha when the time comes, for they will soon sense her threat potential. : looks like it

For now, I enjoyed the candid cynicism with which Ruqaiya bares her real motive in coaxing Jalal to take Bairam Khan head on, and the instant pact between her and Mahaam Anga, which was strongly reminiscent of the one of 1941 between Hitler and Stalin. It will probably last just as long!

The new Ruqaiya: She is clearly much better looking than the old one. Her face is smooth in its lacquered perfection, and she had all the nazakat needed for the Malika-e-Hind. But her face. with the light eyes, looks like a cold mask, and she seems to be far more overtly arrogant and unfeeling than the old one was. : i like the new ruqaiya

The old Ruqaiya was a creature both strong and insecure, arrogant and vulnerable.On Tuesday last, she was so convincing in her misery and her frailities, in the prison and then with Jalal in their bedchamber.There was also a nervous gentleness in the way she handled Jalal then. I somehow cannot see the stylish mask of a face that this new one has bringing out those nuances. The Ruqaiya during the hunt was already harder. : in the beginning i did not like the old ruqaiya, n as time goes by i began to like here, n there u go actress got replaced...the old one gives you mixed feelings by looking at her, new one totally VAMP type... Viewers are Mentally Prepared (VAMP) type...

They are also making her out, suddenly, to be a political power, collecting the jaziya and lecturing Jalal on the duties and responsibilities of kingship. Gone is any evidence of the chronic insecurity about her hold on him that was most sharply in evidence on Tuesday, which was rooted in her childlessness. She now looks every inch the confident, favourite First Consort, flaunting the Malika-e-Hind title that was never used before. This Ruqaiya does not seem likely to seek reaffirmations from her lord and master about her being his most chaheti begum. The Malika-e-Hind would have no such doubts. What has happened all of a sudden? : Agree, the sudden 360 degree change is kind of

It seems likely that the CVs, had, without really meaning to do so, created a fresh and fascinating Ruqaiya, intelligent, tantalizing, and Jalal's trusted partner in life, but yet with many vulnerabilities and secret griefs, unable to let him know what she feels for him for fear of losing the closeness to him that she cannot live without. What they apparently need, in their standard issue 'good girl- bad boy about to turn good' scenario, is a bad girl to set off the good girl's goodness. And the prime candidate for this is, who else, Ruqaiya.

I am thus more than half afraid, looking at the new Ruqaiya of the last two days, that they will soon leach out everything that made the character fascinating and vulnerable at the same time, and reduce her to a standard issue negative female from any TV soap. Like Bahar in Mughal-e-Azam, even after allowing for her being the seniormost queen. That would be a very great pity. Let us hope she escapes that sad fate! : i really hope they dun take this route as welll

Jodha-Ruqaiya: Well, the keenly awaited Jodha-Jalal encounter proved, not unexpectedly, to be a no show, as the two of them circled that tree so many times that it seemed impossible for him not to hear the sound of her payals, or even to step on the end of her trailing odhni! But still I enjoyed it, especially Jodha's quick-wittedness in scaring the deer away with smoke (she has apparently done a Girl Guides course in camping, including lighting a fire without a match!😆)

In this, the first of her successful encounters with Ruqaiya, an indirect one, she was helped greatly by Ruqaiya taking an inordinate amount of time for her shot. If she does this all the time, she would not be able to hit even a slow moving elephant! 🤣

What was intriguing here was the detachment with which Jalal views the whole proceeding, commenting, in an unconscious echo of Arjuna's maxim in the Mahabharata, that her focus must be total and she must, in some way, become one with the target. He also senses the smoke - there is something in the air, the winds are changing, he says - even before he sees the smouldering twigs. When he does see them, his eyes light up in genuine amusement and appreciation of the trick played on Ruqaiya. : aunthy why did he stood there standing, wont he be curious to know who was it... should he not chase her after seeing her...

In the second one encounter, about the jaziya, Jodha had all the best lines, though entirely predictable ones, and she rounded it off by the grand gesture of handing over a priceless necklace in payment of the tax for the whole lot of the pilgrims. Apparently the Malika-e-Hind is also a closet chartered accountant, seeing that she does a lightning calculation and sets off the value of the necklace against a whole year's jaziya (for how many pilgrims?) 😆

Jodha : They are getting some things about her just right. I liked two things about Jodha yesterday.

One was the calm dignity, firm but free of arrogance, with which she put that cheeky chunari seller in her place, capping that by draping the expensive chunari - fit only for the Mughal Shahenshah's begums - over her maid's head. It was a splendid put down, much better than chewing the woman out,and she added a solid retort about Mughal shehzadis and Rajputanis to sew everything up. Of course it was the 150 mohras that spoke the loudest, but she handled the whole impeccably.

She handles the jaziya encounter with Ruqaiya with the same clear-eyed, non-confrontational firmness, and emerged the winner. She will handle Mahaam Anga the same way when the time comes for that.

Second, I liked the open, childlike (not childish) way in which she laughed when Motibai ends up with mud all over her face and over that 150 mohra chunari. It was like a carefree little girl, and it was charming.

That Jodha treats her maid as her equal is admirable, but there has to be a limit to that. I did not like the way Motibai bargained for that chunari like a housewife in a fish bazaar, without waiting so see what Jodha felt about it at all. She should keep the rank and dignity of her mistress in mind. It looked bad, and it only highlighted the need for some staff discipline. The Mughal court is far more hierarchical and formal, and if Jodha treats the servants there in the same way as in Amer, and tries to befriend all and sundry, she will soon be in the suds. A queen must be kind, but a bit aloof and dignified as well; otherwise the staff will start being presumptuous.

The constant refrain in this serial is about how Jodha will change Jalal for the better. But it is equally important for her to change herself where it is necessary. As I wrote elsewhere, Jodha could, so far, afford to be as simple and straightforward as she is because she has never faced any serious dilemmas,any great danger, any great tragedies, in her life as Jalal has. She has never been as lonely as he is, so lonely that he does not even know that he is lonely. Lonely in that he has no one with whom he can connect with the certitude that the person is not out to use him one way or the other. He is the xlosest of all to Ruqaiya, and still, when she praises his appearance, he is sure she wants something from him.

Jodha can thus afford to see things in black white, to run to save a pigeon or a deer, and to lecture her family on the Rajput code of honour.

The first time she is going to be pulled both ways is about Sujamal, and the beginnings of this were evident at the Yamadwitiya ceremony. When he joins up with the enemy to redress what he sees as a great injustice done to him, Jodha will understand that there need not be one clear right and one clear wrong, and she will suffer with him. As Jalal suffers when Zaheer is blinded and later dies, when Takhtmal is murdered, and when so many other things go very badly wrong despite him.

Jodha will have to grow up, to learn that life is not so simple, that there are competing pressures that have to be balanced, and that for an emperor, his empire and its needs come before all else. That often the choice is not between the good and the bad, but between the lesser of two wrongs. That the imperatives of statecraft often cannot be subjected to personal concepts of right and wrong, or to those of human sympathy.

Unless she does this, she will never be able to get to the inner Jalal, and her influence over him, which is the keystone of this tale, will never reach the critical mass needed to change him.

aunthy in my view its not Jodha to change Jalal but Jalal to change Jodha 😆... Plz dun throw anything to me, but the actress playing Jodha needs to improve... When shes with the actress playing ruqaiya, ruqaiya stands out and not Jodha... Jodha was suppose to be a princess who is brave and also beautiful but so far we could not see all those... at times i feel shes not that beautiful on screen... Camera angles... One dun feel that this girl will get Jalal running after her or falling hard for her for her beauty / bravery ( bravery does not mean one saying dialogues i want Jalal's Head everytime)...I agree that jodha never face any serious drama/ danger n is looking at things at face value... I dun know abt sujamal thing, but i think her marriage with Jalal will make her realise and view things differently... Im not sure how this marriage is gonna take place, is it with Jalal asking openly, or Jodha is tricked into the marriage by her own family , her father that trades her for the throne knowing that Jalal wants her. Before Jodha could see or enter the inner part of Jalal, she herself needs to change n reform herself...
N aunthy i agree with Jodha being to close with the maid... there should be a limit... You can be nice n caring towards ur maids, but they need to give u the respect ... The part wer she talks n bargain, i was like what the...😆... again here i would like to highlight jodha does not stand out as a princess... she looks like a normal person not like a princess... ... the main element she needs to be n look like a princess... then even any other short comings can be overlook but here we dun even get that... there is a vast diff between a normal girl vs princess... that needs to be shown on screen...
I dun blame paridi here, this is her 1st show as a lead n 1st istorical show i wonder whether shes given appropriate training n worskhop that could assist her in her acting... She needs to improve... what is the dir doing here... The body language n all is not like a princess... Wake up, this is a historical show n not a normal daily shop... look at how Aiswariya Rai carried herself in the movie... Im not comparing but the director needs to look into all this... Forget abt other rajput, i agree they are the same but at least we need to lead actress to be n act like a princess...
I believe there is something in paridi that Ekta had choosen her as the LEAD, im still waiting to see it... PLZ prove me wrong... PLZ 😆
Questions for the day: Jodha is shown celebrating what is apparently Deepavali in Amer. The Yamadwitiya is the day after Deepavali, and is popularly known in North India as Bhaidooj. She is carried in a palki all the way from Amer, with a longish halt in Bhanpur, to Mathura. How does she manage to reach Mathura for the Yamadwitiya? : 😆... there are too many question but no answer aunthy 😆

And how does Sujamal, with whom she has no way of communicating , also turn up there on the dot? : 😆 via sms aunthy 😆 SMS : Bhaisa im here, please come ...🤣

Joke of the day: Suryabhan Singh, on hearing of the falling out between Jalal and Bairam Khan, proclaiming that Yeh Jalal to aur bhi (?!?) kamzoor bana dega, and so it would be no big deal for him to defeat Jalal and fulfill his promise to Jodha about, what else, getting her Jalal's head. I almost fell off my chair laughing. Famous last words!! : 🤣... theres a discussion in some other place wer a fren ask what is Suryaban n Jodha equation something like that... i replied " Jalal Head Ka Rishta" ... Kindly take note that in her convo with suryaban, Jalal head is a must dialogue 🤣...

Shyamala B.Cowsik

10q aunthy... 👏
Edited by riyya6 - 12 years ago
smile.sara thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: riyya6

10q aunthy... 👏

your analysis good too. aunty was very deep and yours was very light ... I was really laughing all the time while reading you,
ameilia thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Shyamala Aunty once again you have done a brilliant job.You are very articulate with your feeling about this serial.
I must say that this Ruquaiya has already made me hate her.She is definitely Ekta's new Vamp.I loved Smiley because she portrayed a woman who was confident yet had insecurities. Rajat and Smiley shared a wonderful screenspace. Lavina's portrayal just looked brutal and evil.I mean is this the same character that shed tears because she loved Jalal but he didnt love her back?The character traits seemed to change from downright hoity-toity to plain heartless.I mean Ruqaiya has grey shades just wished they had tried to explore some of them before going all 'I am going to kill that woman who dared to interfere in my hunting.'If she flares up just for a petty thing like that then how come she shares Jalal with other women and never seemed complained since they are so close?Writers need to be careful and the directors need to know how to direct Lavina to toned down a bit.This sudden change with the character doesnt fit in well.🤔
As you said Jalal already has a heart but i do think that Jodha is the one who is going to unearth this lost treasure.Jalal shows loyalty to his people unlike Sujamal. Everyone around Jalal has their own motives for keeping him in control.Jalal shows his gratitude to the people who was there to him.He is faithful as a Emperor but as a husband well i didnt live in the 16th century so i cant say i am ok with polygamy.Looks like Bk's track is going to end.I have a question though BK was shown in the promos with Jalal when he attacked Amer so wont he be going?Maybe this is what they want to show anyone who betrays Jalal doesnt live even though they might be his closest of what he has for a family.
As for Jodha i do think she needs to be careful on who she trusts.Her blinded trust for others especially those who sees this and use this at their advantage can really mess up her life.For Jodha to understand Jalal she needs to live with him,breathe the same air as him,be in the same environment as him and interact with the people that surrounds him.Only then will she be able to take a sneak peak of what its like to be an Emperor.But with wealth comes greed and with power comes people thirsting to hold position and authority.When someone is in a situation like that they cant trust anyone as even the family can be after his empire.Jodha in order to change and be an influence to Jalal needs to change herself too.She needs to know the world is not all beautiful with chasing bunnies and kissing birds.She needs to know about the cruel parts too.The parts that she barely gets an insight of and it riles her up.For a change someone needs to change.For Jodha to change Jalal and herself she needs to adapt and learn her to survive.
Edited by ameilia - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

6 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78B updated on 08/07/2024

Jodha Akbar FF : --- Who loves Him Most (M) --- Link to my other threads Thread 1 Thread 2 - Thread 3 :::::Thread 4::::...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: Swissgerman

9 years ago

Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 48 Updated 20/7/2025

... Shahzada Of Her Dreams ... ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::Index::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: Chapter-1.....The beginning Chapter-2:...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: ParijatDeewani

1 months ago

Jodha Akbar Vm Thread

Hey y'all! I've created this thread so that you'll can easily access all the Akdha Vms in one place. Please feel free to add to the list. 1....

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

5 months ago

Jodha Akkineni & Jalal Ahmed of Pale Blue Dot : A Story in Verse 💙

Before you read, This is strictly for die-hard and loyal fans of Pale Blue Dot ...our fellow PBDians ... I've been working on this since...

Expand ▼
Jodha Akbar Thumbnail

Posted by: nushhkiee

6 months ago

Jodha recreated - A beautiful nostalgia 😍

Hello People.....Our Pari just posted her recreated Jodha look for a paid partnership promotion ... absolutely loved it ... she still captures...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".