Asad was looking for what answer?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

bheegi

@bheegi

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#21

Vineeta

Actually I loved that scene. This is only the second time in his life when he approached his father- the first time was after Dilshaad was shot and then today. Different circumstances but both heart wrenching scenarios. First one, he was about to lose his ammi and today, he lost the love of his life.

Both situations where someone had sucked the life out of his beating heart.

We all know Asad hates his father but why did he still go to him in both these situations? Because somewhere deep down, he needs his father. Like every son, he needs his father to comfort him in the gravest situations of his life. Of course, he would never say it explicitly but that's what every child's subconscious wants- a parent who can comfort them when their life is about to be sucked from them.

Rashid's silence was his answer. 17 years of guilt have made this man lifeless and spineless, a man who is alive but not living. Asad didn't need an answer. He could see his future standing right in front of him. That's why he didn't want any sympathy from his father.

Rashid will hopefully recognize this cry for help from his son. Will he call Zoya or Dilshaad and figure out what's happened? Will he try to redeem his years of guilt by advising his son to make the right decision? Will he tell him that Tanveer could be framing him? He should. If there is one thing he can do for his estranged son, then this is the moment.

As Kirann said, this is a new beginning to their relationship. Now that both are standing on the same moral platform, they both would be able to relate to each other and with time, understand each other.

Vineeta, I hate direct scenes. For me one of the charms of QH is the subtle messages, reading in between the lines and interpreting what the actors are trying to emote.

Shows and movies that spell out every thing for you are way too boring...i love show and not tell :)

Quote

Tanzia Scott

@latanzia

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#22

I totally got where you are comming from, i wanted more from the scene, i wanted Rashid to knock some sense into Asad or at least make him aware that Zoya had some suspicion about his best friend, something to give this scene more impact. It was a waste of time to have him standing there crying like an idiot.

I wanted to see him act like a father to Asad for once.Be a man

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

904910

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#23

asads character is like neeropa roy from old movies, bechare ko cvs ne bilkul neeropa roy bana diya hai.

tanveer and razia r lead characters it seems...

need some happness guys u will get trps for sure

Quote

sheilasandhu

@sheilasandhu

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#24

Originally posted by: kankabhor
I think Kiran said everything what I wanted to say..The only thing I wanted to comment that you said by choosing Tnaveer Asad is making one more Ayaan but remember by abandoning Tanveer and child he will create one more Asad which is worse..

Sorry but i beg to differ .As first and foremost she is not pregnant with Asad's child and secondly if a nasty human being is born thru Tanveer it will be due to the fact that both the baby's parents are from gutter background with so much of evil running thru their veins.

Quote

Monica

@mochhug

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#25

Thank you! Me too! I thought his silence did speak volumes. But at the same time, it was the first time his son was reaching out to him, granted in a rather insulting way, but still. It was the first time Asad saw him as him as his father and admitted IN FRONT OF RASHID that yes I am your son. But I really wanted Rashid to say something. I understand that he was under an obligation and blackmail, but he could've said something. He could've advised his son to fight for his love. To learn from his mistakes, or something.

I really wanted that. Not bashing the scene, just think it would've added that much more depth to it, as well as a small step forward in their troubled relationship.

Edited: And I agree is his silence spoke alot to say that this is what kind of person I've become. I at least after this Rashid tries to help his son, or find out what exactly happened that he's even more broken than before, then I won't even bother worrying about him not saying anything. I agree the beauty of Qubool Hai is the subtle messages. But at the same time, sometimes it's nice to know things that you're not sure of or something that may seem like it's going in another direction.

But again, I DID LOVE THE SCENE. Just felt it could've been that much better.

Edited by mochhug - 12 years ago

Quote

Kanika

@kankabhor

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#26

Originally posted by: sheilasandhu

Sorry but i beg to differ .As first and foremost she is not pregnant with Asad's child and secondly if a nasty human being is born thru Tanveer it will be due to the fact that both the baby's parents are from gutter background with so much of evil running thru their veins.

Here we are talking about Asad's decision is right or wrong..And Asad did not know whose child it is.. According to TM by accepting marriage with Tanveer Asad is creating Ayaan but according to Asad , if he abandon he will create one more Asad and he does not want that so he is choosing child over Zoya.. So Asad's decision of giving up love is right..See from Asad's POV not viewers where we know the truth.

I am sorry to say, but blood does not determine person's nature, values its upbringing, surrounding which does it.. If you adopt a new born baby from orphan age, and give him good upbringing. the child will turn into good person..

Quote

Kanika

@kankabhor

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#27

Originally posted by: _vineeta_
No I didn't want him to ask anything but just say what's in his heart, curse him how low he feel being his son. Because Rashid's reaction was apt for that, blame..

He felt as if someone hit him badly. But he asked then Rashid should have consoled him or said what he went though..

I sincerely cant believe a father can be like that. Father can take blame quietly but don't have any answer for son begging for one, I don't believe unless they want to keep Rashid a wimp character forever😕. The way I see Rashid, he is weak but not completely wimp and he cant be, woman like Dilshaad love him still..

Rashid was about to console Asad but Asad denied it.. And RAshid did not have any answer to Asad's questions.. He himself is broken seeing son like this where he was 17 years before..Moreover, Asad did not actually want to hear Rashid's side, did not want her sympathy he just went to him to tell, see I am like you.. Its hurting me so much but din't it hurt you.. It was more like a child went to his dad to complain.. And its present situation where Asad is broken, how can Rashid bring past and try to justify himself at this situation.. Today, Asad just needed a shoulder to cry , nothing else.. If son is in pain, agony then how can a man go back to 17 years and justify himself.. This was not correct time to do it.. In future when Asad will be calm Rashid can explain but not now when he is broken..

Quote

_vineeta_

@_vineeta_

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#28

Hi Sangeeta, thanks for posting you thoughts...

Like I said I hope there is new begining, but so many times we have been dissappointed waiting for something coming later, I am losing hope. And precap doesnt look very promising from that angle, he is worried about his mom more than his son so it will be again "Let bygones be bygones".

I really hope Rashid said dont live my life, he had two options like Asad has today and he lived one and both knows the result, why Asad want to live same? and why Rashid couldnt say pick another.

That scene started off damn well, when he came and broke with "aaj mujhse ek bahut bada paap hua hai.." in middle, it should have been curse but no asking questions and then ending would have been apt with what indeed happened "you never had anything for me ever "

Waqar such excellent actor failed me, couldnt understand he was helpless, sad or worried. He just looked wimp to me is thats what they wanted to show😕, and they cannot gutter his character like that while trying to raise Gaffur..

For me most beautiful part was last scene, some growth in character and story. Gaffur heartfelt plead(he is alive somewhere as dad), Zoya and Humaira bounded by blood, their hearts connecting dots..

And yes i am not looking for all explicit scenes either, but when giving all so explicitly where Tanveer is concerned, why not give some where others are concerned. Want to see them expressing their feelings, as I crave to see beautiful actors acting their part. Shalini, Waqar and Gaffur(forgot his name) have been sidelined badly even Karan and Subhi's talent is used in just crying and harmless threats in repetitive scenes..

Edited by _vineeta_ - 12 years ago

Quote

Andrea

@DreA

Stunner

Posted: 12 years ago

#29

Im sorry...Is Rashid NOT supposed to worry about his mother who is MISSING? He's supposed to forget about his mom because his son is going through problems too? Cant he worry about them both???

Oye...

Quote

_vineeta_

@_vineeta_

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: Drea_QH1fan
Im sorry...Is Rashid NOT supposed to worry about his mother who is MISSING? He's supposed to forget about his mom because his son is going through problems too? Cant he worry about them both???

Oye...

yeah thats why couldnt understand, what was use of the yesterday scene when he will be unaffected later and wont do anything. He didnt act at that time, Asad asked him question he didnt utter a word, why Asad just didnt cursed him even more and pented out all his pain

Quote

1 2 3

Asad was looking for what answer? - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics