What makes a show a hit? - Page 2

I was wondering how much of AsYa pain is self inflicted. None of them even confessed their love to each other, and all through the nikaah was nakli for them... We know it wasn't but Zoya assumed (correctly so, but still) Asad loves her, and now is all heart broken, and Asad knew he loved her, never expressed or gave their love a chance to blossom and now is going crazy in pain and guilt... I pity both of them... Asad was better of before this ten day hangama... Atleast he had a wall around his heart... 😭

Originally posted by: kankabhor

I really dont think Zoyaan now fits anywhere.. Asad and Zoya are hopelessly in love with each other.. They are lifeless without each other, can Zoya ever be normal with Ayaan where she wil have to face Asad everyday? Any stupid person can sense their love... Asad making sacrifice is also not making any sense.. Zoya wont be Zoya, Asad wont be Asad if Zoyaan happens , how can Ayaan or anyone ignore their behavior.. What they have shown today, after that they just can not be normal without each other.

Logically I don't think ZoYaan can happen now but what I meant was if they were going for convoluted storylines they should have done it right away. Now if they try this shit it just makes the characters, the story and the writers look very stupid.

Originally posted by: ..Kirann..

I agree with everyone here. I am fine with everything in the show except Tanveer. She boils my blood and I feel like breaking my screen every time she comes on. Amrapalli isn't helping with her bad acting! I'm actually loving the separation track and the way it's executed. I just cannot take Tanveer. i want her out SO BAD! I'm just hoping her pregnancy drama gets dealt with by the end of next week and then after Ajmer track she gets revealed and kicked out! She's extremely annoying to watch. I have no other problem with the show!

I agree. This character Tanveer has dumbed down the leads and the storyline lacks logic just to accommodate her stay in the show.
Amrapalis overconfident attitude and repeatitive overacting is not helping either.
Please end this track ASAP. Except that boring character everything else is fine

Superbly and sensibly put Laila...agree with u totally...and as u rightly said there is not much that can be done, even in terms of dialogue, to portray romance on Indian TV...this separation had to happen...they managed to hook the audiences with the romance for half a year is commendable...but this was really inevitable...amidst so much negativity, good to see a post that looks at it from the business point of view...😊

Yeah I kinda expected the separation, that's no surprise. It's still kind of sad that's all ): Anyway not all Indian serials thrive on this kind of stuff, many successful shows have the main leads happily married. But I guess that's not what was planned for this show, so oh well!

Originally posted by: delena90

Frankly Laila, I am not upset about the separation at all. AsYa are the OTP so they will get together tomorrow or even two years from now and frankly that doesn't bother me. What does bother me is the fact that the writers are treating their viewers like idiots. I understand there is a large section of the audience that does watch this show solely for AsYa but I don't. I watch it for a story told with some semblance of logic. And contrary to what Gul and Mrinal believe Tanveer has no logic as character and AG cannot act.

Tanveer has no back story. As an viewer I can't understand or even sympathize with her motive. The fact that she is harming her childhood friends for something Razia and co spewed at her baffles me. She wants to avenge herself but uses the very woman who insulted her to do it. The character has lost focus of what she wants to achieve. When Nisha was playing her you got the feeling that she truly cared about her kid but that story seems to have fallen through pretty quick. So, now you basically have a woman committing psychopathic acts with no explanation and frankly while it may make good tv for an audience that has no brains it annoys me.

Tanveer was always going to play the sex and kid card but when the writers knew that Tanveer was pivotal to their plot the least they could have done is tell/show us her motive.

I hope you do take this to Mrinal because she needs to hear it - As a writer she has failed to give a valid characterization to Tanveer and instead of the character being someone the audience loves to hate...we or at least I just hate her. Massive, writing gaffe.

Edit:

I loved yesterday's episode though...definite improvement. It was an absolute pleasure to not have to see Amrapali ham it up on screen. I have a half a mind to send some money to that woman and beg her to take some acting classes.

Originally posted by: goingreen

Yeah I kinda expected the separation, that's no surprise. It's still kind of sad that's all ): Anyway not all Indian serials thrive on this kind of stuff, many successful shows have the main leads happily married. But I guess that's not what was planned for this show, so oh well!

Originally posted by: Laila2009

I know there are a few shows that do but they do focus on the storylines involving the other characters - the love story is not the crux of the storyline and the other characters are well rounded and more developed - that's not the case with QH.

Originally posted by: Laila2009

I have already discussed this with her in March and as you can see, she doesn't take much heed with what I say. I even brought this up in March on this forum as to why I did not suspect her to be Billo Rani but as you remember, NO-ONE cared. So you can see, why should the writers?

Nisha was perfect in the role but the writers wanted some who was "meaner" to look at...and they are stuck with the typical stereotypical bad person. Nisha was good - she came of sweet but she was going to be mean. I thought she was better.

I agree nisha was better. It would have been more believable.