Torn Between the Call of Her Heart and Her Mind

nafisa_kazi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
by Nafisa Kazi :
M-EIEJ, Episode aired on 18/05/2013 : A Scrutinized Overview

A desperate Dipali to get back at Madhu casting the bait before the most likely ones who might take it, Padmini and Trishna...Though Padmini is guarded an cautious, its Trishna who takes the bait and lets the cat out the bag...This gives Dipali and opportunity to fill them with a sense of foreboding with her wily and instigating words...After this it becomes clear what induces Padmini to seek Sultan's help...

A desperate Madhu oscillating between the call of her heart and her mind...how she seems disturbed and preoccupied by this bipolarity of emotions that she is going through...RK's sincerity and his desperate need to redeem himself is adding on to her guilt...Guilt of what she is contemplating to do to him...

A desperate RK unable to hold on a secret from Madhu shows her the pleasant surprise he has for her : "That's how you know you love someone, I guess, when you can't experience anything without wishing the other person were there to see it, too." (kaui Hart Hemmings)...This very gesture of RK indicates that this time round he is sincere about redeeming himself and make and do everything as per Madhu's wishes...so this time round he doesn't give her an imaginative picture of their "dream home" but something concrete and real...something for which even his laborious effort is also involved...

here's a perfect retro to go in with this situation : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UOMjKWrfI0U "ye tera ghar ye mera ghar, kisi ko dekhna ho gar, to pehle aake maang le teri nazar meri nazar..."

An Madhu overwhelmed with the abundance display of affection from RK and his wanting to keep his scars unhealed as a reminder of all that he did to Madhu in the past, can't bear to see him in pain and demands an explanation to all his redeeming acts...this one is an indication enough that it's not in Madhu to avenge herself now that she has been assured about RK's sincerity and redemption...

---- Must say every episode of Madhubala though reveals one thing, yet raises another doubt in mind...so once again we are left with playing the guessing game...

---- Another appreciative feature of MB team is that they stick to their track irrespective of the pressure from various factions of fans, namely the opposing fanatic fans of RK and Sultan...

---- An adept ensemble of cast : SM perfect as Dipali; AP as the dicey Trishna; PP as the ever suffering Padmini (portraying this character with conviction is certainly not easy as one has first to be convinced about it)...VD has become synonymous with RK and of course the amazing one liners...DD, only she and she can do justice to the role of Madhubala, can't conceptualize anyone else but her...

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.5k

Users

7

Likes

37

Frequent Posters

Golmal thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
You post are Nice nice and nice as usual Nafisa... I still doubt on RK
-brokensoul- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
RK might be genuine now. But I am sure he will still be insecure.

Lovely post as always.😊
fairy_stardust thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Great post. MB team really does a good job with managing all these tracks and keeping all characters in full lime light.
ennishet thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Nice post!

RK's actions have put a doubt in Madhu's mind, she is torn between her desires - whether to accept what she is witnessing as true and give up on revenge, or to remain firm on her chosen path and finish her mission. I agree RK's eyes spoke the truth even when he was taking revenge, so Madhu is right in not trusting him so easily. Once burned, twice shy!

Yesterday's episode kind of conveyed RK isn't faking or fooling Madhu ... the same cannot be said about Madhu. Don't know what she will eventually end up doing ... the precap suggested she forgives, still don't trust it or the CV's for that matter.

Your last line, only DD can do justice to Madhubala - agree, but I would say the same about VD, only he can do justice to the role of RK with such ease. SM was awesome as she usually is, I wish she was offered some other role, would have enjoyed it much to see her in a positive role ... ummm as RK's friend perhaps. Wishful thinking.
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: ennishet

Nice post!

RK's actions have put a doubt in Madhu's mind, she is torn between her desires - whether to accept what she is witnessing as true and give up on revenge, or to remain firm on her chosen path and finish her mission. I agree RK's eyes spoke the truth even when he was taking revenge, so Madhu is right in not trusting him so easily. Once burned, twice shy!

Yesterday's episode kind of conveyed RK isn't faking or fooling Madhu ... the same cannot be said about Madhu. Don't know what she will eventually end up doing ... the precap suggested she forgives, still don't trust it or the CV's for that matter.

Your last line, only DD can do justice to Madhubala - agree, but I would say the same about VD, only he can do justice to the role of RK with such ease. SM was awesome as she usually is, I wish she was offered some other role, would have enjoyed it much to see her in a positive role ... ummm as RK's friend perhaps. Wishful thinking.


agree Nupur..therez a chance of Madhu faking it as well...bec. she sounded desperate to take revenge from RK..itni jaldi mind change nahi ho sakta πŸ˜† if she does, i must say, mindblowing acting πŸ‘
nafisa_kazi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
friends,
thank you so much for commenting on my views and sharing your pov too...
ennishet thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: _charu_


agree Nupur..therez a chance of Madhu faking it as well...bec. she sounded desperate to take revenge from RK..itni jaldi mind change nahi ho sakta πŸ˜† if she does, i must say, mindblowing acting πŸ‘



Agree Charu. If she is acting, then she's doing a fab job, well suited for her entry into movies.

Just read what I wrote above -
I agree RK's eyes spoke the truth even when he was taking revenge, so Madhu is right in not trusting him so easily.

Somehow I think earlier too when RK was on his revenge path, maybe, he was still honest. I mean what he was saying must have been true even then about his feelings, his interactions with Madhu but he never recognized it as love or caring for Madhu. Possible?

So Madhu was right in saying his eyes spoke the truth even then ... but RK was honest then too ... only thing is he never knew he was falling for her or had started caring for her ... in the end his ego and his revenge kind of wiped off everything, his real feelings too. I hope I made some sense with all this ...

Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: ennishet

[
Agree Charu. If she is acting, then she's doing a fab job, well suited for her entry into movies.

Just read what I wrote above -
I agree RK's eyes spoke the truth even when he was taking revenge, so Madhu is right in not trusting him so easily.

Somehow I think earlier too when RK was on his revenge path, maybe, he was still honest. I mean what he was saying must have been true even then about his feelings, his interactions with Madhu but he never recognized it as love or caring for Madhu. Possible?

So Madhu was right in saying his eyes spoke the truth even then ... but RK was honest then too ... only thing is he never knew he was falling for her or had started caring for her ... in the end his ego and his revenge kind of wiped off everything, his real feelings too. I hope I made some sense with all this ...


yes, it's fine if we look at it from RK's POV..but I'm too confused about Madhu...if she felt anything for RK, she wouldn't have decided to take revenge from him..i dun know the CV's failed here or we failed to understand their story , but it's senseless...🀒 they never told us what RK and Madhu truly feel for each other and if they did, may be we never believed them πŸ˜†
ennishet thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: _charu_


yes, it's fine if we look at it from RK's POV..but I'm too confused about Madhu...if she felt anything for RK, she wouldn't have decided to take revenge from him..i dun know the CV's failed here or we failed to understand their story , but it's senseless...🀒 they never told us what RK and Madhu truly feel for each other and if they did, may be we never believed them πŸ˜†



Simply put, you don't hurt the ones you love.

Yesterday, she couldn't stand RK's injured hand .. and on the other hand she plans to inflict much worse pain ... to be honest, Madhu unnerved me yesterday. I wasn't much troubled with RK's antics, but Madhu was still evasive ... I don't trust her a bit, won't trust her even if this ends in Rishbala wedding. Still will get some idea in Monday's episode.


As to Madhu's revenge ... I think the amount of hurt, insults and the revenge by RK clouded her thinking ... maybe her hurt and anger got an upper hold and since RK wasn't letting go of her, she thought this was the only way to make him realize what he did.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".