Impartial, True-Dance lovers-Read

annie_belle thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
hi
i watch nach baliye because dance is my passion.i am not partial towards any jodi (i am nobody's fan, as most people would call it).i have fav performances in the show but no fav jodi.whichever jodi performs well on a particular day becomes my fav jodi for that day and i believe they should be marked according to that day's performance.
i request people who truely appreciate good performances, without any bias towards their fav jodis to participate in this thread.i would be glad even if i find one person who thinks like me here.
i was kind of disappointed after the semi-finals.though i agree hussain is a good dancer, but i thoroughly disagree with the judges for treating tina like the apple of their eyes.according to the performances on that day, k-sera-sera was badly choreographed and equally badly performed.i saw them losing sync a no. of times but the judges even at this level of competition made no remark at that...to surprise me more, they awarded them a perfect score.i was wondering if they were commenting on the same performance that we saw!
in the next round bharat humko jaan se pyara song was way too amatureish.tina had no expressions at all.i thought that was complete injustice to the song.we had performed the same song in a concert in the US.it seemed they were already sure about the scores they would get so they didnt spend more than a couple of hours practising on that song.the judges, pretending to look patriotic awarded them a perfect score again.
on that day, the other 2 jodis had performed better and deserved better scores.
its a pity that people like saroj khan,malaika and kunal kohli are judging here.they are way too commercialized to be fair.
i dont expect people to spend money voting for the jodis they dont like( even if they are better that day) but atleast, i expect them to be honest and not bias on this forum when they comment on performances.
i was very sad to read people saying that hussain and tina's performance in the semi-final jerked their tears...also, that hussain and tina should win the final.tell me how can u say today that they should win the final when they havent even performed for the final yet? such bias people are all set to praise the candle-like tina even if she cant shake a leg in a performance.this has happened earlier to some other jodis too on this forum but i am not bringing those out as those jodis are voted out already.
be fair to "DANCE" atleast on this thread.
i am terribly sorry for tanaz and baktiyar who,inspite of performing better, had to pay the price that day of such bias judgement.i am feeling sorry for yash gouri coz such statements 'like hussain tina will win the final' must be lowering their moral.


Edited by annie_belle - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

62

Views

4.4k

Users

30

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

3283 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
Finally a neutral statement to look at. 👏 👏 👏 .....I think I totally agree with you. I am not that much into dancing, but even I noticed a lot of mistakes and lack of coordination in HuTi's performance. I think it was pretty unfair
rose82 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
i agree...i had liked yash gauri's performance in the 2nd round...and im sure tht if HuTi wud have done the same dance,they wud have got 30 ' for their different concept n coordination' but YG...well..u have to live with it...u r'nt so perfect as HuTi even tho u try however hard u can.
FreeBird03 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
i totally agree...

Hussain-Tina did not deserve that 30/30 😕

n i am also no one's fan...so its a neutral response!
angelsgurl thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
huti are ma favourite pair and i love wuh dey bring up every round.. its different.. and da patriotic thing waz different.. and its tru tht.. tht song din need a lot of steps.. dey juz showed a story to it.. but yes both der performances were nuh da bestest they have given.. even k sera der waz no sync and der steps differed.. and being an energetic song.. der steps fell toooo dull..
:.Roshni.: thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
i agree wid u guys totally
luv ya
roshni
xxxx
parneesha211 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
gr8 to c a totally neutral view of the show...i am also no jodi's fan but i am a fan of good dance...and even i noticed the mistakes in HuTi's performances...the 1st performance had nothing awesome abt it..they had quite easy steps..they have performed better in the past on much difficult steps but both of their performances were not that gr8..they deserved around 28 but not 30...they got all the marks for the concept for 2nd song as they were not even in sync in that song....i felt TB were good in yaadein song and they deserved around 27 for their efforts but YG were awesome and truly deserved full marks for their second performance...especially their movements on words chehre pe chehra were brilliant...judges are tending to b baised in their judgement..

sorry if i have written such a long post but its such a relief so c someone else sharing my neutral opinion so cldnt help my self
cool_pooja thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
I agree... N im glad to see a neutral response n not suprise not to see much tina-hussain fans replying.... But i disgree wid u a bit... I loved their ke sera sera performance because the coordination and the attitude was amazing!! But i was very sad that YG didnt get full for their bhoot performance even through it was much much better den HT's patrotic performance... plz dont think im saying dis because im not an indian... Dis is not true...
tv_addict_uk thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
i am not TB's fan

can the impartial people answer this :

why r TB blamed for being repitive and monotonous when HT are not? arent they repeating their cover-up acts (to cover up that tina cant dance) with their drill displays?
i have not seen them dancing for a long time.i found tina's zinda hu main, the rope performance, the k sarah, and patriotic song mere skits.if these skits were done by hrithik pr prabhudeva i could understand that they r trying to be different coz they usually dance...but here HT r resorting to this strategy only to avoid dancing on a DANCE COMPETITION ! 😉

@angelsgurl:
sure the patriotic song could be done without steps...but here the IMO says they lacked expressions (correct me if i m wrong).expressions sure are an essential ingredient.
FreeBird03 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: tv_addict_uk

i am not TB's fan

can the impartial people answer this :

why r TB blamed for being repitive and monotonous when HT are not? arent they repeating their cover-up acts (to cover up that tina cant dance) with their drill displays?
i have not seen them dancing for a long time.i found tina's zinda hu main, the rope performance, the k sarah, and patriotic song mere skits.if these skits were done by hrithik pr prabhudeva i could understand that they r trying to be different coz they usually dance...but here HT r resorting to this strategy only to avoid dancing on a DANCE COMPETITION ! 😉

@angelsgurl:
sure the patriotic song could be done without steps...but here the IMO says they lacked expressions (correct me if i m wrong).expressions sure are an essential ingredient.

very very well said 👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".