Why Devyani did not win it!

Page

kushboo

@-Khush-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Hello all... 😛 finally got my hands on Mon epi... aah how I hate monday night class...🤢

So... I see Devyani's dessert gol gappa... and my poor memory wala brain has this brainstorm that this recipe does have an inspiration 😈😆 ... Think think think and Yahooo...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8Iq5pKkOro

Chef Sanjeev's golgappe made of boondi and coffee milkshake!

First of all... they need to show us MORE 😡 why always cut down comments and then make us look that judges are dumb and selected the bad dish? EDITORS! 🤢

I think they might not have shown but Devyani's dish is very similar to the above one! 😳 and plus, I think her water- was after all just a chocolate shake 🤓 she could have won this round had she been a little innovative than plain chocolate milk! 🤔

Also, this is the second time her dish is 'inspired' from another recipe... First that leheriya mirchi of Kandla from S1 and now this golgappa... 😆

I think Ripu's water gave him the victory... 😳 It was a different idea mixing citrus-apple-kokum 😃...his filling was not extraordinary tho... 😆 but i think he brought innovation with his water and did not exactly go too far like the other two from the 'chatpata' panipuri! 😕

Yasmeen 👏- kasoori methi and rosewater- take a bow! ⭐️

Overall, both yasmeen and ripu deserved to win... judges know best is what i have learnt the hard way and trust them ! 🤣 I think they gave it to ripu more as Yasu already has the super shakti+ 1 lakh... they would have given it to her had they have this on a weekly basis like previous seasons where radhika, shipra, maane etc. had more than one ... but beacuse it is rare this season so I feel they gave it ripu even tho his dish might not be MORE better than Yasu...😊

Feel free to share your views! 😳

Edited by -Khush- - 12 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Bansari

@Bansari7

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Yup! Even I mentioned in my other post that devyanis paani puri was similar to a one on sanjeev kapoor s website but looks like he made it too in his show

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

hiruni

@hiruni

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

i think ripu was more desrving than yasu

Quote

raj-avin

@raj-avin

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

i think judges praised Devyani's ideafrom start, like discussing between themselves and this made everyone feel she shd win. Her dish after taste test also was praised.

Yasmin's too was praised that she raisd the bars with her simple ingredients and abt her presntn.

So without pointg any flaws in their dishes whn Ripu was given the title, audiences were confused. His dish was praised but the comparisons werent made clearer either what went wrong with other dishes or what was special factor in Ripu';s panipuri.😕

Quote

kushboo

@-Khush-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

@raj exactly ! What I said in my post ! They seriously need to do something about the editing !

Quote

raj-avin

@raj-avin

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: -Khush-
@raj exactly ! What I said in my post ! They seriously need to do something about the editing !

u r right and because Kunal mentioned he made Delhi proud ,it looked like they are favouring Ripu. As u said his dish might hav been the best but from what was shown it looked easy ride for Ripu.

Quote

566912

Hibernated

Posted: 12 years ago

Honestly, I would Not like Chocolate Panipuri.

PaniPuri needs to be Chatpata, thoda Meetha, Thoda Tikha.. I for one would Never Go For Sweet Panipuri. 😕

Yasmin was innovative in her Puri & Mix.. but her Pani was more on a Meetha type. with Strawberry.

Ripu one was Perfect. It was new.. Innovative.. different from the typical Panipuri..

But still It had the Basic Panipuri Taste.. His Pani looked super yummy with all that.. Teekha.. Meetha.. & Chatpata. 😊

Ripu deserved it hands down.. 😃

Quote

Kruti

@krutiv100

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Sachi16

</div><div>
Honestly, I would Not like Chocolate Panipuri. 
PaniPuri needs to be Chatpata, thoda Meetha, Thoda Tikha.. I for one would Never Go For Sweet Panipuri. 😕
Yasmin was innovative in her Puri & Mix.. but her Pani was more on a Meetha type. with Strawberry.
Ripu one was Perfect. It was new.. Innovative.. different from the typical Panipuri.. 
But still It had the Basic Panipuri Taste.. His Pani looked super yummy with all that.. Teekha.. Meetha.. & Chatpata. 😊
Ripu deserved it hands down.. 😃

I agree totally...Ripu kept the orginal identy of gol gappas the thod theeka thoda khata ans thoda meetha but gave it aa new idently by using different and unusual ingreidents like the kokum and one the chefs also saod that hebhad got the balance right.

Quote

Apocalypse

@WhiteNights

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

I wouldn't wannna eat sweet/chocolate pani puri either!😳

But that's not the point. I am glad you made this post. It makes so much sense now. I am quite fed up of people accusing judges of partiality after each and every result, not just this one.

Anyway, in my opinion any one from Ripu and Yasmeen could have been the winner but I was not there to taste their dishes. I trust the judges. And as you said, the editing can be better.😔

Quote

Why Devyani did not win it!

Related Topics

Explore Topics