sultan's role is unnecessary now

NamuVyas thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
I like avinesh rekhi as an actor.. but somehow I find sultan's character unnecessary in the show now.. apart from covering up for VD's absence it hasn't served any purpose in the show 😲
firstly the character itself has lot of flaws.. sultan is a gangster who doesn't have a gang 😕..he is a good guy with moral values but kills ppl.. lots of confusion..
AR should have been potrayed as probably a film producer who is very big in the industry.. as the show is based on the film industry , it would have been ideal to fit into the show..👏
secondly RK's character is very strong in the show.. he has lot of shades to him.. he is good bad and ugly at the same time 😊.. an antagonist needs to be stronger than the lead to serve the purpose.. but here neither sultan is a lead not an antagonist.. 😕
thirdly the saving grace would have been sultan paired opposite trishna.. wich wouldn't have been that bad and the show would have got a parallel story as well.. since as of now trishna's role isn't serving any purpose either..😛

Edited by Aahaana - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

51

Views

5k

Users

35

Likes

286

Frequent Posters

cardio21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
I totally agree with u.. Because a majority of us hate bhai, because of the way they tried to shove this bhai Madhu track down our throats.. We were forced to see a chemistry that doesn't exist..

They should have known that RK has a great screen presence, and is liked by most people despite his grey shades.. There is no way they will accept him being sidelined, vying for his love interest.. He has a huge fan base in all age groups and not to miss that he nailed his character so well..
Even though people don't approve of his ways, they are willing to wait for him to change..

they were trying to be different, introduced the new guy as a gangster and that too with a son.. People would never accept him with Madhu as she is also loved a lot by people... And then his character underwent successive mutations over days, like never witnessed before..

This led to most of us hating him.. They tried their best by giving him all this chivalrous dialogues, showing all the golden heart.. But we are not ready to buy it.even if they show him leaving the underworld, it will not be impact full enough.. They even made RK do hideous things, but nothing is working. I feel bad for AR, because he does a good job and is trying to do justice to his role..

But RK n Madhu are the crux if this show. I dunno, what the track holds.. But from what I know that most of us will quit if its not Rishbala.. With due respect to those who want otherwise..

If they get another girl for bhai, we will start accepting him.. But we don't want any third party presence between Rishbala..

This is just my opinion...



Edited by cardio21 - 12 years ago
desait thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I think Cv fail to introduce Sultan in Show,in proper manner earlier.They rushed for forcible story line for Love triangel and force fan to accept it but fail.fan reacted strongly.
Basically Writer fail big time for writing Sultan character.




Edited by desait - 12 years ago
obstinatefemale thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
😆😆

Cvs will disagree with you😆 Did you know, Sultan being added to the Rk and Madhu angle (the gun confrontation generated the highest trp of that week, ie 3.1) so cvs hardly care what online viewers want. Think about it, we moan and complain but we still come here and watch the show and bash😆😆😆 So yeah! right time mein, saab clear hoga! kaun hero hai aur kaun heroine! dark love story this is 😆😆😆 so every role is necessary and that includes the servants in RK's mansion too😆😆



@CARDIO! LOL! If people can accept a man chaining his wife to his furniture, and abusing her mother, and asking his wife to jump off some building to show him as the hero, then accepting a woman falling for a man with a child should surely not be objected too, ESPECIALLY! Since the moral of this forum is that the show is fictional hence accept a husband abusing his wife in the name of love!😳 I dont think cvs care who is quitting or not, because online viewers dont contribute to trps😆 Waise this is not meant to be sarcastic in anyway. i just am amazed at how easily viewers forget what RK has done to MB and even without him repenting and in fact him turning worst epi by epi, viewers find it hot and call it LOVE!!(Yesh she is teaching him a lesson right now, but what she is doing is nothing compared to what RK has put her through and is continuing to put her through) You are making a great assumption based on a couple of phans' post that viewers have not accepted Sultan into the show.😆😆 especially when the guy is equally contributing to those ratings according to the makers of the show themselves. And failing to see the fall in trps with just Rishbala being shown, (well that can be blamed on RK being abusive in his own way and hence the viewers turning off their tv set) Just saying😳 (wanted to put a bit of facts out there, to enlighten your argument, totally respected your point of view.)😊

On a lighter note! Congo on becoming goldie😊😳
Edited by FragileAngel - 12 years ago
obstinatefemale thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: desait

I think Cv fail to introduce Sultan in Show in proper manner in earlier.They rushed for forcible story line for Love triangel and force fan to accept it but fail.fan reacted strongly.

Basically Writer fail big time for writing Sultan character.




agree desait! the show went nuts after revenge track, and they didnt know what to do and hence introduced this track But at the same time his character is yet to be butchered in the same manner as RK's and MB's. And latest rumour has it he is going all negative! but i fail to differentiate between good and bad in this show, so will wait and see what negative entails.😆😆
but i dont think cvs failed! they got what they wanted, we are just crazy ppl who fight over nothing😆😆😆
Edited by FragileAngel - 12 years ago
NamuVyas thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: FragileAngel

😆😆


Cvs will disagree with you😆 Did you know, Sultan being added to the Rk and Madhu angle (the gun confrontation generated the highest trp of that week, ie 3.1) so cvs hardly care what online viewers want. Think about it, we moan and complain but we still come here and watch the show and bash😆😆😆 So yeah! right time mein, saab clear hoga! kaun hero hai aur kaun heroine! dark love story this is 😆😆😆 so every role is necessary and that includes the servants in RK's mansion too😆😆



@CARDIO! LOL! If people can accept a man chaining his wife to his furniture, and abusing her mother, and asking his wife to jump off some building to show him as the hero, then accepting a woman falling for a man with a child should surely not be objected too, ESPECIALLY! Since the moral of this forum is that the show is fictional hence accept a husband abusing his wife in the name of love!😳 I dont think cvs care who is quitting or not, because online viewers dont contribute to trps😆 Waise this is not meant to be sarcastic in anyway. i just am amazed at how easily viewers forget what RK has done to MB and even without him repenting and in fact him turning worst epi by epi, viewers find it hot and call it LOVE!!(Yesh she is teaching him a lesson right now, but what she is doing is nothing compared to what RK has put her through and is continuing to put her through) You are making a great assumption based on a couple of phans' post that viewers have not accepted Sultan into the show.😆😆 especially when the guy is equally contributing to those ratings according to the makers of the show themselves. And failing to see the fall in trps with just Rishbala being shown, (well that can be blamed on RK being abusive in his own way and hence the viewers turning off their tv set) Just saying😳 (wanted to put a bit of facts out there, to enlighten your argument, totally respected your point of view.)😊

On a lighter note! Congo on becoming goldie😊😳

there is nothing wrong with AR or sultan.. I know RK is wrong totally.. but sultan's character is not making a contribution to the story line frankly.. finally its a daily soap and it requires some amount of ruthless drama.. nothing of this sort ever happens in real life.. if the character of sultan was potrayed differently it would have been worth a watch and acceptance.. even with all the goodness viewers will still accept an abnoxious and ruthless Rk THE SUPERSTAR over a very good GANGSTER..
naina2010 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
You are just too early to say it. He is very much needed. He is the main cause for what you are currently seeing.

No Sultan No Madhubala ek ishq ek Junoon.
obstinatefemale thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Well Namratevyas, i beg to differ. Just because you are a superstar, you do not treat women like garbage and claim they are your possession. In fact if you want to argue he is a better pick then i guess thats your perception of the matter. But personally, I would pick a man who has the decency to respect and worship the ground the woman he claims to love more than life itself walks on. But then again thats my perception of the matter. And i believe even the viewers are in agreement with me when i state they did not appreciate a man tying up his wife to a furniture, because if you read the breakdown of those trps, you will see the strength of my argument but of course you might not agree (and remember sultan only had like a 2 to 3 min scenes only in those episodes) CVS are not effectively using AR yet, but his character is fresh and has a lot more scope to explore, and if viewers want this show to go up to 1000 episodes, they will allow the cvs to do their job instead of bashing the actors or the makers themselves. (this is not directed at you, but generally) The reality of the disagreement over Sultan is the fear he will end up with Madhu, but people fail to see MADHU is a woman of discipline. Khair thats an argument on its own. But you hit the nail on its head when you said its a daily show where spice is required and precisely why other actors are just as important especially when leads go on leave. they have a lot on their shoulders to cater, so knowing someone else is there to control things is in itself a bonus.

Ok! i wont bore you any longer. But just wanted to say,the makers themselves said Sultan is being loved and appreciated, so i doubt they will adhere to your request.😆

Edit! I conquer Naina's argument above. He is the catalyst of what is being shown in Rishbala form RK's side, so he is moving the story forward, albeit making RK into a robotic individual who only wants to murmur that he owns Madhu which in itself is boring. We got to see a new shade of Madhubala! All thanks to Sultan indirectly pushing RK's button and RK pushing Madhu to the limit. so yeah! he has provided an interesting platform for Madhubala as a show in itself.😳
Edited by FragileAngel - 12 years ago
...shona... thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
completely agree!!!
sultan is not needed for the track at all.. he is just boring us now
cardio21 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: FragileAngel

😆😆


Cvs will disagree with you😆 Did you know, Sultan being added to the Rk and Madhu angle (the gun confrontation generated the highest trp of that week, ie 3.1) so cvs hardly care what online viewers want. Think about it, we moan and complain but we still come here and watch the show and bash😆😆😆 So yeah! right time mein, saab clear hoga! kaun hero hai aur kaun heroine! dark love story this is 😆😆😆 so every role is necessary and that includes the servants in RK's mansion too😆😆



@CARDIO! LOL! If people can accept a man chaining his wife to his furniture, and abusing her mother, and asking his wife to jump off some building to show him as the hero, then accepting a woman falling for a man with a child should surely not be objected too, ESPECIALLY! Since the moral of this forum is that the show is fictional hence accept a husband abusing his wife in the name of love!😳 I dont think cvs care who is quitting or not, because online viewers dont contribute to trps😆 Waise this is not meant to be sarcastic in anyway. i just am amazed at how easily viewers forget what RK has done to MB and even without him repenting and in fact him turning worst epi by epi, viewers find it hot and call it LOVE!!(Yesh she is teaching him a lesson right now, but what she is doing is nothing compared to what RK has put her through and is continuing to put her through) You are making a great assumption based on a couple of phans' post that viewers have not accepted Sultan into the show.😆😆 especially when the guy is equally contributing to those ratings according to the makers of the show themselves. And failing to see the fall in trps with just Rishbala being shown, (well that can be blamed on RK being abusive in his own way and hence the viewers turning off their tv set) Just saying😳 (wanted to put a bit of facts out there, to enlighten your argument, totally respected your point of view.)😊

On a lighter note! Congo on becoming goldie😊😳



Thanks!! Also thanks for enlightening me about the figures.,😊
We haven't forgotten anything,, but I am just talking about what we sensed on the basis of my discussions.. May be they are biased..
And definitely we are all waiting for a proper redemption track.. I dunno it's coming or not..??
In the meantime, I am all up for Madhu's revenge, which is justifiable
I am not a regular soap watcher.. My mom watches tons of soaps and stopped this once the shoot outs were included..
I never endorsed the abusive behavior, and actually skipped the couple of episodes myself.. Even now, we are looking for and asking some positivity if u read our episode discussions..
Then the actual face off between sultan n RK was definitely overrated, but I called it a damp squib. Not crazy about what followed either..

And I never claimed to contribute to TRPs, because most people who do are not crazy about love stories.. Be it RK madhu or bhai madhu.. And definitely not about gangster tracks,, They want regular MIL-DIL interactions.. I am here to watch a love story between the two protagonists. Nothing else..

I mentioned in an earlier post that TRPs for our show were max when there was positivity in the show between oct-jan.. And the episodes that get highest TRP are those that promise positivity, that is something I can confidently say.. Who wants to see the negativity? We have enough problems in our own lives.. Redemption track should be promising..

My mom watches a show, which didnt have any twists.. That has been running for years.. Infact I remember, it was my vacation time and the entire 3 weeks i was home, they showed one wedding. Phew..!!

And as I have always maintained, all of us are entitled to an opinion.😊


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".