Serial plot goofs that defy logic

obelix1 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Hope there is no other thread for pointing out intentional/ unintentional goofs in the serial plot.

Someone made a thread asking where is Batuk's wife and I had the exact same question. In fact, where was Batuk at Sanjay's engagement is the first question I had when Batuk was introduced as a close friend of Amit and Sanjay.

Batuk is happily dancing away with Amit and Amita's friends at the sangeet and spends so much time with those guys, so how realistic is it to not have his wife at the party ?

Not just this, there are too many things which are looking more and more unrealistic (agreed it is a serial and creative license is allowed to make up a storyline where everything is not realistic. But come on , they shouldn't disrespect the viewer's intelligence too much). Some of the other major aspects that defy logic :

(1) Amita's friend Jigna is supposed to have delivered about a month ago, and she is part of the friends' performance at the sangeet ( how did she get the time to rehearse etc with a newborn ? 😊 )

(2) Amit and Amita barely got two days to rehearse , so when did all their friends get time to rehearse their elaborate acts ?

(3) Phalguni tells Amit that Rujuta is her best friend, hence she invited her. Is it possible that when you have a best friend is living in the same city as you, your families/children have never met each other so far (until Amit saw Snehal's photo) ? Don't you attend at least some parties/functions at each others homes if not just visit each other sometimes ? 😊

(4)About the diary saga, At Amit's place , Atul almost locates the diary and picks it up from the gift basket, but puts it back immediately as Amit's father comes there. What was the need to act like he was doing something illegal or shameful ? Couldn't he just pick it up ? Would Amit's father insist on reading Amita's personal diary if he saw Atul holding it ? šŸ˜• Didn't Atul know it was a ticking time bomb that had to be removed from there at all costs ?

(5) Amita and her friends are all supposed to be around 20 years of age. How come any of them don't go to college/ do a job of any kind ? It's like they are all doing nothing waiting to get married ? šŸ˜• Who does that in this day and age ? I didn't watch the first several episodes of the serial, so I may not be aware if they showed anything to clarify this point , so correct me on this.

(6) The night before the sangeet, Amita asks her mother 'sab log aagaye' ? In a house where a wedding is taking place, do any of the guests not meet the bride after they arrive ? Wasn't Amita supposed to be rehearsing in her house itself ? Even if she was somewhere outside, is it realistic that you don't meet any of the guests when you return , no matter how late it is ?

(7)Sanjay is supposed to be working in London and is in India on a vacation to get married, but there is no signs of his and Preeti's wedding though they were engaged long before Amit and Amita who are now getting married. How many months of vacation does Sanjay have ? 😊


Edited by obelix1 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

2.2k

Users

6

Likes

64

Frequent Posters

emeraldeye thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: obelix1

Hope there is no other thread for pointing out intentional/ unintentional goofs in the serial plot.

Someone made a thread asking where is Batuk's wife and I had the exact same question. In fact, where was Batuk at Sanjay's engagement is the first question I had when Batuk was introduced as a close friend of Amit and Sanjay.

Batuk is happily dancing away with Amit and Amita's friends at the sangeet and spends so much time with those guys, so how realistic is it to not have his wife at the party ? Yes very true. I had raised the exact question in IF.šŸ˜‰

Not just this, there are too many things which are looking more and more unrealistic (agreed it is a serial and creative license is allowed to make up a storyline where everything is not realistic. But come on , they shouldn't disrespect the viewer's intelligence too much). Some of the other major aspects that defy logic :

(1) Amita's friend Jigna is supposed to have delivered about a month ago, and she is part of the friends' performance at the sangeet ( how did she get the time to rehearse etc with a newborn ? 😊 ) Agreed. Even I had the same thought and was planning to raise it in the IF. Even I had the same query and was planning to raise it in the IF. Jigna being a new mom is supposed to spend time with her baby.How is it practically possible for her to spend time with her close friends (however close they maybe šŸ˜•)

(2) Amit and Amita barely got two days to rehearse , so when did all their friends get time to rehearse their elaborate acts ? Maybe they all are superbly talented. Ek bar kiya aur sab kuch aa gaya.😊

(3) Phalguni tells Amit that Rujuta is her best friend, hence she invited her. Is it possible that when you have a best friend is living in the same city as you, your families/children have never met each other so far (until Amit saw Snehal's photo) ? Don't you attend at least some parties/functions at each others homes if not just visit each other sometimes ? 😊 Amit is a nerd. So maybe he never attends parties !!šŸ˜›

(4)About the diary saga, At Amit's place , Atul almost locates the diary and picks it up from the gift basket, but puts it back immediately as Amit's father comes there. What was the need to act like he was doing something illegal or shameful ? Couldn't he just pick it up ? Would Amit's father insist on reading Amita's personal diary if he saw Atul holding it ? šŸ˜• Didn't Atul know it was a ticking time bomb that had to be removed from there at all costs ? Arre CVs had asked him to leave it there. Nahi to Phalguni ko kaise pata chalge bhai?? šŸ˜›

(5) Amita and her friends are all supposed to be around 20 years of age. How come any of them don't go to college/ do a job of any kind ? It's like they are all doing nothing waiting to get married ? šŸ˜• Who does that in this day and age ? I didn't watch the first several episodes of the serial, so I may not be aware if they showed anything to clarify this point , so correct me on this.🤣

(6) The night before the sangeet, Amita asks her mother 'sab log aagaye' ? In a house where a wedding is taking place, do any of the guests not meet the bride after they arrive ? Wasn't Amita supposed to be rehearsing in her house itself ? Even if she was somewhere outside, is it realistic that you don't meet any of the guests when you return , no matter how late it is ? šŸ‘šŸ¼ Agreed.If they had arranged some hotel for the guests to stay then we understand but still some mami/kaki will surely visit their house first. How come no one has come?

(7)Sanjay is supposed to be working in London and is in India on a vacation to get married, but there is no signs of his and Preeti's wedding though they were engaged long before Amit and Amita who are now getting married. How many months of vacation does Sanjay have ? 😊. Actually he was in a hurry to get married and return back to London. Yaadash kho gayi shayad 🤣


obelix1 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Hilarious comments, emeraldeye. ROFL.
On the last comment about guests , it is clear they are not staying in any hotel, because during Amita's conversation with her mother, they say that all guests are sleeping on gaddis outside and no one is sharing Amita's room because her dad wanted her to be comfortable during her last 3 days at home. That's why I found it illogical as to how can they not meet her when they are all in the same house.
smritit thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Yes. I totally agree with you. They have goofed up many a times before too. I still remember, phalguni had once said that "she had a brother whose kids had made fun of amit- maybe about his nerdyness. And hence she had broke ties with his entire family." And then we are shown TiYa making fun of Amit's dancing abilities. A women who is so possesive about her son that she breaks relation with her brother, doesn't say anything to TiYa? Even when phalguni is the elder bahu and has all rights to poke them. Atleast ek argument to banta tha. If not breaking relation and all. What say friends?
mariyem thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Yeah smiriti wese Y?_?¯°?_??a??????????? falguni apne bhai se relation tod sakti hai lekin snehal aur uski mummy ko bula kar nai shruat karsakti hai and another thing want tina and riya wanted amit to marry amita S°?°o they can have tamasha everyday ?L°? ?????~°? °L? lekin yaha to ulta kardiya
badam-chi-rani thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
I wonder if people like TiYa really do exist in real world!!! Kise apne ghar me itne problems ho yeh acha lagta hai. Yeh to matlab limit ho gai...Is AKA a balaji show by any chance???šŸ¤”

Family aur acquantances ki harqat dekhkar toh yahi lagta hai by god!!!šŸ˜†
obelix1 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Adding one more to the list after yesterday's epi:

(8) The scene b/w Amita - Suraj talking about the SMS and Amit watching them : First of all , who reads out SMS's loud as if you are struggling to read it in a language you don't understand ?
Secondly, if Amit and Ria were standing close enough to Suraj-Amita to hear their conversation inspite of all the noise at the sangeet, how come Amita and Suraj neither heard them talking nor saw them ?
obelix1 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
Adding one more from yesterday's episode :

So Amita is also looking for Amit thinking he has gone somewhere . She can't find her phone because Amit took it with him. But then she managed to find some phone somewhere and managed to call Amit's home/Falguni. But why didn't she try calling Amit first from whatever phone she used to call Falguni

Complete lack of logic.
sap1310 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
guyz yeh family wala serial hai... agar logic use karna hota toh crime patrol na ban jaata... 🤣
obelix1 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sap1310

guyz yeh family wala serial hai... agar logic use karna hota toh crime patrol na ban jaata... 🤣


LOL ! But why are the CVs hell bent on showing Amita as a dumb character ? I mean, your adult husband , who owns a mobile phone disappears, wouldn't you call him on the phone first thing ? Whoever calls his home/MIL ? 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".