Kabir better than Rishi for Indira:Warning & note Pg11

samrudhi.r thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Kabir better than Rishi for Indira? Yes/NO . Please explain.

This is a question to those who support Kabir. Can any of you explain why Kabir is a better option for Indira than Rishi? Please dont forget to mention why you opt to ignore the wrongs Kabir has done to Indira and still accept him (I hope i dont have to list out that. Enough has been said abt it that u wont be ignorant about that). Also please mention why you think that, what you think the wrongs done by Rishi to Zara, are greater than what Kabir did to Indira. If you think Kabir has not done any wrong at all, please mention that also.

I hope some of you will answer this, coz i cant stop thinking so many of you guys cannot be wrong (My POV). There has to be a different side to this coin that i am not able to see and i cant wait to hear what i could not see and you guys saw.
Edited by dhanya.r - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

92

Views

7.8k

Users

26

Likes

282

Frequent Posters

EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
For me ...kabir isn't a better option for indira .He lied to her all these years...i know he gave the birth to the lie for saving her life...still he could always tell/clear things to her later ...i know he fell for her...her nature/behavior...and then he dint want to loose her but its said if you love someone...let the person go...if he/she comes back to you...then only he or she belongs to you ...i wish he would have gained the courage to tell her all . She will be so hurt when she will get to know about all of it . It's like a dhoka to her...she is living a life which is not her's...she don't recognize the ones she love...the place from where she belongs . But genuinely Rati di and Rohit sharing screen space is nice...rohit is a mature actor...he has done much in life...its always good to watch him with my angel . Now i clearly said that for me kabir is wrong...but that doesn't mean rishi is perfect for her...because after all what happened with zara...and his immediately forgetting her...all those things does make me loose the respect for the character . But anyways he is the lead of the show and he is gonna remain there . It's life...and mistakes kisse nahi hoti...i know many will not agree with me but i have actually noticed many times that illa mam does focuses on the reality . Rishi and Indira are a realistic couple . Their is no fairy tale kind of love story . The way they fight , talk , discuss ...everything is very much real...and that's refreshing . And illa mam too with it has given a new definition of a love story...dooriyan toh har show mein hoti hain par jis tarah hd mein hoti hain kisi show mein nahi hooti . Our couple just meets and is again separated . May be aise love stories bhi exist hoti ho...this all just makes it different...they are miles apart...still together...still connected . Apart from some bloopers...i know this too much separation somewhere decreases the fan following of the jodi...but when we get them after so much time...it's too a relaxation . It's kind of magical...like we got a flashback few days ago and i can actually guess with what intensity it touched the hearts of viewers . And trust me...it would not have affected that much...if we were getting that everyday .
Edited by Surbhi123 - 13 years ago
samrudhi.r thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Surbhi123

For me ...kabir isn't a better option for indira .He lied to her all these years...i know he gave the birth to the lie for saving her life...still he could always tell/clear things to her later ...i know he fell for her...her nature/behavior...and then he dint want to loose her but its said if you love someone...let the person go...if he/she comes back to you...then only he or she belongs to you ...i wish he would have gained the courage to tell her all . She will be so hurt when she will get to know about all of it . It's like a dhoka to her...she is living a life which is not her's...she don't recognize the ones she love...the place from where she belongs . But genuinely Rati di and Rohit sharing screen space is nice...rohit is a mature actor...he has done much in life...its always good to watch him with my angel . Now i clearly said that for me kabir is wrong...but that doesn't mean rishi is perfect for her...because after all what happened with zara...and his immediately forgetting her...all those things does make me loose the respect for the character . But anyways he is the lead of the show and he is gonna remain there . It's life...and mistakes kisse nahi hoti...i know many will not agree with me but i have actually noticed many times that illa mam does focuses on the reality . Rishi and Indira are a realistic couple . Their is no fairy tale kind of love story . The way they fight , talk , discuss ...everything is very much real...and that's refreshing . And illa mam too with it has given a new definition of a love story...dooriyan toh har show mein hoti hain par jis tarah hd mein hoti hain kisi show mein nahi hooti . Our couple just meets and is again separated . May be aise love stories bhi exist hoti ho...this all just makes it different...they are miles apart...still together...still connected . Apart from some bloopers...i know this too much separation somewhere decreases the fan following of the jodi...but when we get them after so much time...it's too a relaxation . It's kind of magical...like we got a flashback few days ago and i can actually guess with what intensity it touched the hearts of viewers . And trust me...it would not have affected that much...if we were getting that everyday .


@ green: thats the side of the coin i am seeing. I also understand that Kabir is not able to say the truth, since he has so much to loose. All i am saying is he is selfish to the extend that he spoiled 8yrs of Indira.

@blue: agree there with u too. RP and RR does look good together. Its also nice to work with mature actors.

@ red: i too dont think rishi is shiny white. all i am saying is that he isnt pitch black.

@parrot green: Rishi is the lead. Yes fortunately for some and unfortunately for some, tht is true.

@ pink: yes reality indeed.

Thanks Surbhi for the reply. But i guess i havent got any reply which will give me a glance of the side of the coin, i am missing to see.
Edited by dhanya.r - 13 years ago
-Paulomi- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Surbhi123

For me ...kabir isn't a better option for indira .He lied to her all these years...i know he gave the birth to the lie for saving her life...still he could always tell/clear things to her later ...i know he fell for her...her nature/behavior...and then he dint want to loose her but its said if you love someone...let the person go...if he/she comes back to you...then only he or she belongs to you ...i wish he would have gained the courage to tell her all . She will be so hurt when she will get to know about all of it . It's like a dhoka to her...she is living a life which is not her's...she don't recognize the ones she love...the place from where she belongs . But genuinely Rati di and Rohit sharing screen space is nice...rohit is a mature actor...he has done much in life...its always good to watch him with my angel . Now i clearly said that for me kabir is wrong...but that doesn't mean rishi is perfect for her...because after all what happened with zara...and his immediately forgetting her...all those things does make me loose the respect for the character . But anyways he is the lead of the show and he is gonna remain there . It's life...and mistakes kisse nahi hoti...i know many will not agree with me but i have actually noticed many times that illa mam does focuses on the reality . Rishi and Indira are a realistic couple . Their is no fairy tale kind of love story . The way they fight , talk , discuss ...everything is very much real...and that's refreshing . And illa mam too with it has given a new definition of a love story...dooriyan toh har show mein hoti hain par jis tarah hd mein hoti hain kisi show mein nahi hooti . Our couple just meets and is again separated . May be aise love stories bhi exist hoti ho...this all just makes it different...they are miles apart...still together...still connected . Apart from some bloopers...i know this too much separation somewhere decreases the fan following of the jodi...but when we get them after so much time...it's too a relaxation . It's kind of magical...like we got a flashback few days ago and i can actually guess with what intensity it touched the hearts of viewers . And trust me...it would not have affected that much...if we were getting that everyday .

\
SURBHI iam your fan from now👏👏👏
RamziMeriJaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Kabir >> A big no, first relationship is based on trust n honesty , and Kabir broke both . He took advantage of ML lady , he manipulated her so much that everything he says is true / right to her as she can't remember anything . Sadly a guy like him do exist in today world .

Rishi >> Is right for Indira because he will never do such a thing , he loved her endlessly , and will never do anything that would her hurt her , Rishi love for Indira strong even ( My Heart Beat Zara couldn't break that ,despite being Indira look alike ) . So there is no comparison here , Rishi owns Kabir in this battle .
Arreyaar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Atrangi re Season 2 Participant Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: -Paulomi-

\
SURBHI iam your fan from now👏👏👏


surbhi n paulomi agree with u both 👏
RamziMeriJaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
I am even ashamed 4 thinking good of him ,I mean 8 yrs of lie in still going are you joking .
And what me made me more anger , was Kabir asking Indira ,why she isnt except him as her husband yet , have some shame in you man ,you aren't married to her . So plz stop asking her for something that's not your .

Edited by aweil1 - 13 years ago
Afss_94 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Surbhi123

<div align="center">For me ...kabir isn't a better option for indira .He lied to her all these years...i know he gave the birth to the lie for saving her life...still he could always tell/clear things to her later ...i know he fell for her...her nature/behavior...and then he dint want to loose her but its said if you love someone...let the person go...if he/she comes back to you...then only he or she belongs to you ...i wish he would have gained the courage to tell her all . She will be so hurt when she will get to know about all of it . It's like a dhoka to her...she is living a life which is not her's...she don't recognize the ones she love...the place from where she belongs . But genuinely Rati di and Rohit sharing screen space is nice...rohit is a mature actor...he has done much in life...its always good to watch him with my angel . Now i clearly said that for me kabir is wrong...but that doesn't mean rishi is perfect for her...because after all what happened with zara...and his immediately forgetting her...all those things does make me loose the respect for the character . But anyways he is the lead of the show and he is gonna remain there . It's life...and mistakes kisse nahi hoti...i know many will not agree with me but i have actually noticed many times that illa mam does focuses on the reality . Rishi and Indira are a realistic couple . Their is no fairy tale kind of love story . The way they fight , talk , discuss ...everything is very much real...and that's refreshing . And illa mam too with it has given a new definition of a love story...dooriyan toh har show mein hoti hain par jis tarah hd mein hoti hain kisi show mein nahi hooti . Our couple just meets and is again separated . May be aise love stories bhi exist hoti ho...this all just makes it different...they are miles apart...still together...still connected . Apart from some bloopers...i know this too much separation somewhere decreases the fan following of the jodi...but when we get them after so much time...it's too a relaxation . It's kind of magical...like we got a flashback few days ago and i can actually guess with what intensity it touched the hearts of viewers . And trust me...it would not have affected that much...if we were getting that everyday .
</div>


bang on Surbhi! I second you.
-Paulomi- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: aweil1

Kabir >> A big no, first relationship is based on trust n honesty , and Kabir broke both . He took advantage of ML lady , he manipulated her so much that everything he says is true / right to her as she can't remember anything . Sadly a guy like him do exist in today world .


Rishi >> Is right for Indira because he will never do such a thing , he loved her endlessly , and will never do anything that would her hurt her , Rishi love for Indira strong even ( My Heart Beat Zara couldn't break that ,despite being Indira look alike ) . So there is no comparison here , Rishi owns Kabir in this battle .

there is nothing to win because there is no comparison
Passion_17 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
i dont support either of them...wat rishi dis 2 zara was unpardonable...it was unfair 2 both Indira n Zara...
n wat Kabir did 2 Indira is also wrong...he lied 2 her all these yrs abt her existence...
in my POV both r at fault n dnt deserve her...!!!
rest of d explanations i hv already written in ur other thread on kabir...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".