Kabir better than Rishi for Indira:Warning & note Pg11

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Dhanya

@samrudhi.r

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: shwetha297
Dhanya, This is HD Ramayan😆. Since you said abt the "Same vacancy", I remembered abt the Ram & Ravan. Without going too much deep if we look the sequences on the macro basis, it becomes easier.

@Blue: As you said ram inpsite of knowing that Sita is pure, he sent her to forest. Why? becoz he does not want his sita to be seen wrong in the society. He did it bcoz for the well being of the society & stop it from going moral degradation. An husband could ignore the silly comments but ideal king Cannot. That's why he is called "Maryada Purushotam"⭐️. Was he happy by sending his wife site alone, No. He suffered more than sita and stayed "lonely" alone in the huge palace.

@Red: Yes, Rishi was there always with Indira, when she needed. I like the forgiving nature of both "Rishi & Indira".

Sorry, if any of my comments hurted you. Looking forward for your reply.

Hey Shwetha, though i disagree on some level with ur defense of Sri Ram, i dont want to argue on that.

Why would ur comments hurt me? dont be silly

Edited by dhanya.r - 12 years ago

Quote

MONA

@Dear10

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#32

sorry dhanya if i hurt you but this post is not for shri ram i can argue with your POV about shri ram but i dont want this.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Dhanya

@samrudhi.r

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: -dear10-
sorry dhanya if i hurt you but this post is not for shri ram i can argue with your POV about shri ram but i dont want this.

😆 thanks

Quote

Shwetha

@-Shwetha-

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: dhanya.r

Hey Shwetha, though i disagree on some level with ur defense of Sri Ram, i dont want to argue on that.

Why would ur comments hurt me? dont be silly

Dhanya, Just ignore, it has not offended you. Thanks.😊

Quote

Rasha4eva

@Rasha4eva

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#35

Dhanya Nice post!👍🏼

Well For me both Kabir and Rishi are at fault!

Kabir to protect Indira lied to officers I understand..But in these 8 years ..its a long time..he should have tell her..Indira too care of his daughter..like a mom..but still Kabir should have thought that this girl must have a family..he dint care about that..he was selfish...but he took advantage of her memory loss..and this is unpardonable..for his insecurity he kept away a person detached from her family ..

Rishi on the other hand..got married to Zara ..he loved her as "zara"..n not as Indira..still..when Indira came..there were many situations were Zara felt neglected ..humiliated..when Indira entered..he forgot about her..Zara too had this accident for which she completely forgot about his past life..Rishi took care of Indira..he made that confession ki Zara is his love n indira his zimmedari...to him Indira a Zimmedari..I was really hurt by his words there..still did he support Zara as his wife??No..and this insecurity of loosing Rishi(it is a hideous way to murder a character..still have to accept it)..she turned a murderer..indirectly Rishi ruined zara's life..for which I will never forgive him..Still as we know ki Sumit and Rati are the leads..he will stay here..n Inshi gonna reunite soon..But still I have no attachment to this jodi any more..the CVS destroyed Inshi..

Its my POV..😊..I just want to see Indira recover fully !!Nothing else..😊

Quote

Paulomi Debnath

@-Paulomi-

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: Rasha4eva
Dhanya Nice post!👍🏼

Well For me both Kabir and Rishi are at fault!

Kabir to protect Indira lied to officers I understand..But in these 8 years ..its a long time..he should have tell her..Indira too care of his daughter..like a mom..but still Kabir should have thought that this girl must have a family..he dint care about that..he was selfish...but he took advantage of her memory loss..and this is unpardonable..for his insecurity he kept away a person detached from her family ..

Rishi on the other hand..got married to Zara ..he loved her as "zara"..n not as Indira..still..when Indira came..there were many situations were Zara felt neglected ..humiliated..when Indira entered..he forgot about her..Zara too had this accident for which she completely forgot about his past life..Rishi took care of Indira..he made that confession ki Zara is his love n indira his zimmedari...to him Indira a Zimmedari..I was really hurt by his words there..still did he support Zara as his wife??No..and this insecurity of loosing Rishi(it is a hideous way to murder a character..still have to accept it)..she turned a murderer..indirectly Rishi ruined zara's life..for which I will never forgive him..Still as we know ki Sumit and Rati are the leads..he will stay here..n Inshi gonna reunite soon..But still I have no attachment to this jodi any more..the CVS destroyed Inshi..
Its my POV..😊..I just want to see Indira recover fully !!Nothing else..😊

you are right,because of this mishandling of a couple,many of INSHI fans are so disheartened that they left the show as well as the forum completely and this credit simply goes to the CVS and truly speaking i still can't accept that zara is really turned negative,i mean,she tried to kill indira i can understand but the way she tried to kill INDU whom she too loved so much and suddenly she forgot is completely not digested by me

i think only shweta got the best exit

sometime i feel that zaara's track from sept to feb was totally useless and baseless

Quote

Earnshaw09

@Earnshaw09

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

#37

First of all,the title of your post put me in a confusion,because you've always been an Inshi fan.But after opening it my doubts are clear.

Well,for me,as I've always been saying,Rishi and Indira are one soul dwelling in two bodies;they're incomplete without each other.No matter what their actions have been,Indira and Rishi have been in love with each other;time,or say it destiny that has been so hard on them,but nothing could move their love.Yes,Rishi had married Zara,fallen for her,but soon he realized that he was and is,and will always be in love with his Shreematijee.And this doesn't make him a bad person;I mean who doesn't have a flaw in his/her character; Indira also have spent some moments with Kabir,who made her belief that he is her husband;she too has a part of her life,which she will regret to have lived,later.But neither Rishi,nor Indira's love has faded for each other;in fact,their love has overcome all the tests of time.And to think someone else in their lives,is foolish,because no one can touch their souls,like they have touched each others.So,to think about the question whether Kabir is better than Rishi,or not,is meaningless;because this is the story of Indira and Rishi.

Quote

TBDRESS

@TBDRESS

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

#38

" Also please mention why you think that, what you think the wrongs done by Rishi to Zara, are greater than what Kabir did to Indira."

Dhanya, I don't think one can even compare what Rishi "did" to Zara to what Kabir has done. Kabir's actions border on criminal behavior!

Rishi may not have been an ideal husband to Zara while he was trying to be an ideal ex-husband and 24x7 caregiver to the mentally challenged Indira, but how Rishi's inability to perfectly meet all the expectations placed on him in the midst of such difficult circumstances can be compared to Kabir's criminal behavior is beyond me.

Rishi did the best he could with the difficult circumstances he was in (we should also keep in mind the extraneous circumstances that affected the storyline i.e RP not wanting to continue playing the double role, the writers obsession with starting a realistic track and then trying to mold it into the sterotypical story etc.) But I am glad that the CV's did not give Rishi a free pass like they have given so far to Indira. First memory loss, then mentally impaired, memory loss again, Kabir portrayed as being a complete creep from the outset- she cannot be held culpable for any of her actions/decisions- makes things a lot simpler than having to be in your full senses and having to make some very difficult decisions while trying to do justice to yourself and others around you.

Quote

rajh

@rajh

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: Rasha4eva
Rishi on the other hand..got married to Zara ..he loved her as "zara"..n not as Indira..still..when Indira came..there were many situations were Zara felt neglected ..humiliated..when Indira entered..he forgot about her..Zara too had this accident for which she completely forgot about his past life..Rishi took care of Indira..he made that confession ki Zara is his love n indira his zimmedari...to him Indira a Zimmedari..I was really hurt by his words there..still did he support Zara as his wife??No..and this insecurity of loosing Rishi(it is a hideous way to murder a character..still have to accept it)..she turned a murderer..indirectly Rishi ruined zara's life..for which I will never forgive him..Still as we know ki Sumit and Rati are the leads..he will stay here..n Inshi gonna reunite soon..But still I have no attachment to this jodi any more..the CVS destroyed Inshi..

look from indira pov-- entire story of last one month shows rishis immense love for indira.

nothing less than that.

rishis love for indira is spotless--even though he loved zara--but that dose not bigger than indira.

it is zaras fault because she not trusted rishi like indira dose,instead she become murderer on her insecurity.

otherwise story would have different--once indira fully got recovered then zara would have also going to get justice.

but zaras senseless insecurity ruined it all for her.

Edited by 100raj - 12 years ago

Quote

Heema22

@Heema22

Sparkler

Posted: 12 years ago

#40

Dhanya . I totally understand what inspired you to make this topic. Your last thread on " Kabir" went haywire .( Even I reply x 2 ) people started to compare Rishi and Kabir . Your intention totally ignored and being a fair person , you wanted to give peole to express themselves. I Totally understand .

Now many expressed their feelings and you know who stand where? Every ones View points different so I am not an exception .To tell you the truth I do not to even write these two names in one sentence . I am sure you understand my anger towards Criminal,Who is holding emotionally dependent girl hostage , claims that she is hiso wife and sleeps in the same bed with her. What a creep !! I wrote plenty about Kabir on your last thread so I do not want to repeat myself ,

On the other hand caring husband , very committed to get India better, who is not super human, Makes lots of mistake. His morality and judgements are always on line on this forum ( not by me ) . He is very normal every day man . I am happy that he is not perfect and as wrong thing and makes mistakes ( may be that's why I like this character). I am glad they are not writing him as some kind of superman who makes every thing better without working for it . He loves indira so much that he will do any thing for her and he worships that ground she walks on. For me this is an ideal husband and every girls on Sumit AT ,dream husband .

How can I even think about comparison between north and South Pole ? One is Indira's heart beat,her Sole mate and other needs to be in jail big time criminal who's is not even tring to correct his mistake or tring to come clean with Indira .

I just cannot imagine how Indira will feel when she comes to know what Kabir did to her! And she was referring him as her Shohar? That's going to be Tiuuse grabbing episode !!!

InShi forever ! I know you are INSHI fan just like me . So lets keep Kabir out of this equation !!

Edited by Heema22 - 12 years ago