@nniks
I hope you know Prats was criticised for her acting too and she didn't evolve in a day. Avika was thought to be way more talented than her and several threads used to crop up comparing the two.
I do not think Toral's acting "sucks" completely. She was good in the women power/save Mannu episode. Only in romantic scenes she was lacking (and it was bound to happen because viewers were shown all the lovey dovey Ansh scenes recently between Prats and Sid!). Toral does need to evolve and keep working on herself.
I trust BV CVs (they never chose a wrong actor, in fact they brought out some of TV's best actors out of hibernation like Surekha Sikri and the guy who plays Mahaveer Singh, and they gave best child actor talents like Avika, Avinash and the little girl who used to play Phooli). Everyone from Prats, Shashank, Sid, Anjum was moulded by CVs who worked on them. I feel if they work on Toral, she'll fit in too.
The only case they faltered in was Gehna's. Totally wrong actress and worst handling of such a strong character (the first true rebel-crusader of BV).
The makers have been unwise in establishing Ansh jodi if they had to replace the lead. Backlash was a given then. Somewhere viewers are also to blame for we were also impatient for Anandi's personal life to move on, a new man in her life, fed up of over-focus on Jagya etc. So they brought in Sid.
Too many drags and departures of actors happened in this show...I do think its days are numbered if they don't handle it right.
As for looks, I don't want go into it much. Prats wasn't a looker either. Toral is okay except that her smile is too broad. I like her voice better, it is stronger. But her dialogue delivery needs fine-tuning. Her personality is strong (even when she doesn't speak). I kind of like these aspects. I find her sort of closer to Avika's Anandi (before DS brainwashed her). So I am willing to give her a chance.
Look, she won't be kicked out any time soon no matter what her faults are. Sooner or later people will either get used to her or look to some other show to stick to.
The only things I DO NOT want are: Anandi's character totally butchered like Gehna's and Ganga becoming some parallel lead or something. BV is about Anandi. It must remain about her MAINLY. Not some Ganga! I'd disliked over-focus on Gauri and Gehna too. I don't want Anandi sidelined in any way no matter who plays the character!