A Non Viewer's Opinion

Hi, i am although a member of India-forum since 2008 but was never active here. I am not a very ardent BV or Prats or Toral fan. I have watched this show on and off and mostly on you tube, never regularly. So after reading this Toral bashing and Prats praises i thought of checking it on my own. I started with watching shiv-anandi scenes and came across some very beautiful scenes. I actually felt that the scenes created a charm as the actors had a good chemistry, suited their respective roles and emoted the restrained love very well through their eyes. The petite personality of Anandi in contrasts with Shiv's strong built was something i liked as i always feel that husbands-wife are complimentary to each other and don't look great if are similar. Her petite frame particular to this romance part created an impact that she is soft and fragile( only physically) but is now in Shiv's secure hands. Also i feel Anandi is a young bride who has just grown up and seen miseries always...and in that young age when all she knew was that she was married since childhood to Jagiya now she is realizing what love is coz of Shiv. In contrast i also tried to watch the episodes with Toral as Anandi. First contrast was age and then built. I may have liked Toral as a lead actress of some new show as she had the qualities to play a lead but i somehow could not like her as Anandi. I understand that the actor had to be changed but by bringing a complete opposite to the earlier actor playing that role suddenly it felt as if not the actor but the entire character has changed which is very surprising. I liked Ganga and Jagiya scenes more than Toral although for a non watcher all these characters are new.

this is exactly my point is, the chemistry between sid and prat was awesome, which is not there in toral and sid. toral looks so mature and her dialogue diver y is so harsh and dominating. toral lacks tenderness and soft appeal which was amazing in prats. they should have replace prats with the the gals with same frame as prats.

Please, I am sorry to say - not interested in such post. And we here prat haters or prat lovers, have been watching the show for long and have quite substantive and strong views based on our regular study. So this posts does not add much value. Apologies may be you will not be very happy to hear this.

@TM thts the feedback I hav been getting from.most watchers and non watchers...n T fans dont butt in nobody needs ur expert openion n advise

I think non interested people can ignore the post..or do they think that the writer of this post is so very interested in their reply.

Originally posted by: reshmiroy2012

Please, I am sorry to say - not interested in such post. And we here prat haters or prat lovers, have been watching the show for long and have quite substantive and strong views based on our regular study. So this posts does not add much value. Apologies may be you will not be very happy to hear this.

Originally posted by: nobodyatnotime

What is wrong with you? Everybody has the right to express their opinions.

Exactly that is my point too...thanks for understanding.

@vinee_vinee,

Even I am not a regular viewer of BV but I try to catch up with Ansh scene. I am neither a Toral Fan not Prats. I got attracted by Avika Gor when they started this show in our regional language and started catching up with the story. I am seeing BV on internet only since last september. I like Prats acting she is the soul of Anandi depicting all emotions of a Balika vadhu, the fear, the delicay,innocence, the respect, trust , betrayel, helplessness, care, leadership. and lot more. Now that Prats is not there the CV's shd have choosen a replacement who can gel with the Anandi we have been watching. As yet I have no complaints of T's acting but still she dosen't fit in to this role just because she's just opposite of the Anandi we are used to until now. Earlier Anandi though petite had the ability to control every one with her eye'. But with T's acting we are given an entirely new Anandi with no similarities of our Anandi, soft vs loud, petitie vs loud, earlier one spoke with eyes and the new one this is completely missing. the earlier one smile had different meanings but the new one is always smiling. The cv's could have choosen a new actor with atleast few resemblences to the old Anandi.

Even I am not a regular viewer of BV but I try to catch up with Ansh scene. I am neither a Toral Fan not Prats. I got attracted by Avika Gor when they started this show in our regional language and started catching up with the story. I am seeing BV on internet only since last september. I like Prats acting she is the soul of Anandi depicting all emotions of a Balika vadhu, the fear, the delicay,innocence, the respect, trust , betrayel, helplessness, care, leadership. and lot more. Now that Prats is not there the CV's shd have choosen a replacement who can gel with the Anandi we have been watching. As yet I have no complaints of T's acting but still she dosen't fit in to this role just because she's just opposite of the Anandi we are used to until now. Earlier Anandi though petite had the ability to control every one with her eye'. But with T's acting we are given an entirely new Anandi with no similarities of our Anandi, soft vs loud, petitie vs loud, earlier one spoke with eyes and the new one this is completely missing. the earlier one smile had different meanings but the new one is always smiling. The cv's could have choosen a new actor with atleast few resemblences to the old Anandi.
[/QUOTE
Very true...one acted through eyes and other is acting through mouth. If a non regular viewer who is not attached to any character can feel this very obvious thing...then something is really fishy somewhere.