Broken Dreams, Shattered Trust

angake thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Today there was a loud noise that pierced the mind of a little boy. The clamorous noise of broken dreams and shattered trust.




Aarti had built a castle in the clouds for Ansh. She had painted a fairy tale picture of how perfect fathers are. She never once spoke ill of Prashant despite what he had done to both of them. She kept the fairy tale story alive in Ansh's mind that fathers are special, that fathers adore their children, that fathers are someone you look up to, that fathers inspire you to become a better human being. These fairy tale beliefs is what lead Ansh to readily accept Yash as his father. It was a good thing that Yash through his unconditional love and his actions re-enforced these fairy tale beliefs that Aarti had instilled in Ansh.


But finally the fairy tale castle is coming shattering down. Ansh is finally getting to see a father who can be mean and hurtful. And as the days go by he will eventually come to know that his biological father never wanted him or his mother. Amidst the divorce lie, Aarti and Yash have tried their best to keep their children's' lives as normal as they can. But now the ill-will felt by both parties ie Yash/Arti and Prashant cannot be masked. These experiences can affect the Ansh as well as Palak and Payal adversely.


What Prashant and SP did today was to rob a little child of his innocence, an innocence that may never come back, an innocence that Aarti and Yash had worked hard to protect. What they did today was break apart Ansh's and by extension Palak and Payal's little world that was filled with safety, security and comfort in their parents love.


Children are smart, intuitive and pay a lot more attention than we give them credit for. They understand tension and hatred among grown-ups. They should not be kept completely in the dark but how do you explain to a child that at one time he was unwanted? How do you explain to a child that the parents who were supposed to adore him cannot stand each other right now? How do you explain to a child that the belief he has that all fathers are wonderful is wrong? If the custody was to go in favor of Prashant, how will you explain to the child that his mother and the person he has come to love as his father has to let him go? Yet, Yash and Aarti have to do all this, to protect whatever innocence will be left in Ansh. They have to undo the damage Prashant and SP unleashed. It all looks so bleak right now.


But the one thing we know about our show is that no matter how desolate the situation is, there is always hope around the corner. Ansh, Palak and Payal may always suffer some negative results from the custody battle and the ensuing separation if there is to be one. But children do grow up. And when they do they will look back and always see that Yash and Aarti always provided them with a safe haven, a place away from all the madness that grown ups like Prashant and SP contributed to. The tag line of this show Zindagi Milegi Dobara does not lie. Only in the darkness can you see the stars.

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

2.4k

Users

16

Likes

169

Frequent Posters

InduG64 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Aha Kirthi...what a realistic picture of the children's state of affairs, especially Ansh, in the aftermath. Superb!!👏

My heart went out to the little boy today.The biological father messed up with his mind...and the father who is in his heart, whom he defends against all bad words, comes and gets him yet again. Yet the seed of doubt is sowed in his mind...What a complicated mind battle to fight for a little child: Should he listen to his heart ? And yet if he does and turns against Prashant, he will be going against all the lessons taught by his mother and father...that one should be thankful to the people who help you. He is already confused as to why his mother hates the man who helped her and who now says loves her so much and that she is his wife.

Ansh asked some valid questions to Prashant today..."Where was I when you were married? Where were you when I was born...and then later when I'd call for you?" And when Prashant tried to poison his mind against Aarti, he struck back, protesting strongly. Prashant has no idea what all Aarti has gone through with Ansh...and the strength of the bond they share. Ansh is not so gullible that he spews venom and Ansh will accept, just because he is a little boy. Ansh stands up for his parents in whatever manner he can. And this is what scares me for the later days, when Ansh will go to live with Prashant. Today, even though he knows his mother does not like Prashant, he still defends Prashant for whatever little goodness he had bestowed on them...When Prashant will speak ill of Yash and Aarti, Ansh will again defend them staunchly...that's when Prashant will turn abusive. Because Ansh will make him feel a loser then...as Yash/Aarti would have won simply by being in the little boy's heart.

Yash and Aarti will have to take some harsh decisions in the coming days, yet keep the family together...The boat will rock but they have to hold their hands, be together, and steady it...just as they reached the solution to Yash's poser...together. Even if they decide that Aarti should leave with Ansh, I have a feeling she'll take the girls with her...just as she did when Yash was in his angry mode post Mumbai. Aarti has promised the girls she would never leave them. SP has taken it for granted that Aarti will leave with only Ansh...but no one realizes that Palak/Payal can easily accompany Aarti. SP has no hold over that...Only Yash can decide for the girls. So in the end, SP will have Yash...but will actually lose him and in the bargain all the three of his blood grandkids (including Aayu).

Ansh is processing a lot of information at the moment. Whatever Prashant says, Ansh saw him manhandle Aarti...and that was a huge blunder...absolute taboo. After this Ansh will see Prashant in a new light...and try to understand why his mother was always against the man. Prashant's ego trip just got bumpier...
Edited by InduG64 - 12 years ago
MelodiousDreams thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
What is this I see?! A post from Kirthi!
First of all...You need to make more posts whenever inspiration strikes, Kirthi...This is an extremely beautiful, poignant analysis!
It is part of human nature to strive for normalcy, to cling to hopes (or illusions, perhaps) that everything will be all right in the end...What Aarti did after Ansh was born was exactly that - she created an environment where her son grew up healthy, happy, and loved...with respect for the vacant space that was to be filled by a superman Papa, only when Ansh would ask and call out for him.
Yash, in spite of all his grief, reached out for that little boy's hand and took it. Since then, he has never let go. He connected with Ansh and lived up to so many expectations without being pressured to do so. He became a father in Ansh's eyes because of all the little things he did that went beyond Ansh's innocent materialistic dreams of a "big house, big car, and lots of toys." That, by the way, was a fantastic throwback to the early episodes! (Noticed a few other throwbacks while watching the episode that made my jaw drop, but I shall keep quiet because they've probably already been talked about elsewhere.) Similarly, the care and immense love that Aarti has given to Palak and Payal far exceeds the duties that were expected of her, and that is reflected in the strong bond of love between the mother and her daughters...The love that Yash and Aarti have given Ansh transcends the tokens of love that Prashant gives Ansh - those gifts of his that seem more like bribes to me - love between a parent and a child should not be limited in such a way, and both Aarti and Yash have exemplified the sort of relationship that parents should have with their children.
"Children are smart, intuitive and pay a lot more attention than we give them credit for. They understand tension and hatred among grown-ups. They should not be kept completely in the dark but how do you explain to a child that at one time he was unwanted? How do you explain to a child that the parents who were supposed to adore him cannot stand each other right now? How do you explain to a child that the belief he has that all fathers are wonderful is wrong?"
It is interesting how all three children, Ansh, Palak, and Payal, are responding to Prashant and the aftermath of the Prashant-storm (which is going to turn into a downpour and then a hurricane, most likely). When Aarti and the girls were watching Ansh, Prashant, and Yash from the terrace (during the jalebi incident), the girls turned away from the scene unfolding below them and sought their mother's embrace for solace, which Aarti provided instinctively, protecting them as well. Ansh found his haven in Yash's embrace - the only other person besides Aarti whom he loves fiercely - and Yash has always provided that security for Ansh. In today's episode, Palak and Payal may not have known why Ansh wasn't being his energetic self, but they were concerned and wanted to cheer him up, and that was so beautiful to see. The three of them are like a unit now, and we've been seeing more and more of that in those little details...Maybe intentional, maybe not. I won't worry about that, since what matters most is what we can glean information from...
@bold: Those are such difficult questions to answer, and I honestly do not know what I would do if I were to be faced with such questions...But that reminded me of something that struck me as I watched the park scene (yes, one of those throwbacks). The way Prashant clutched Ansh and hugged him, almost smothering the little boy in his embrace, reminded me very, very much of the way Yash would hug Palak and Payal when he couldn't bring himself to express his emotions verbally...The difference between these two men, now that I try to cast my mind back to the very first days of this show, is that Yash initiated those embraces out of a feeling of grief and helplessness (and my memory is kind of fuzzy, so apologies in advance!) in addition to love...while Prashant's embraces appear to arise out of desperation and a need to conceal the dark truths of things that he does not want to talk about or even acknowledge. It might not have been his place to talk about how he figures in the Aarti-Ansh (and Prashant) relationship, and if that had been the reason behind his silence I would have been fine...But instead of being truthful about it, he twisted facts around and made up others based on his distorted assumptions...and attempted to poison Ansh's mind against Aarti (and by extension, Yash). I have no sympathy left for that wretch of a being.
There are more hurdles to cross...But like you have said, life has its ways of giving people second chances, maybe more...What remains to be seen is how those second chances are accepted and used...Until one has experienced darkness and despair, one does not fully appreciate the brightness of light and hope...But that, like all things, is a matter of perspective and outlook...
Forgive the incoherent musings...And thank you for such a lovely post!
Edited by MelodiousDreams - 12 years ago
yamunah79 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
well written...i completely agree with you... 😉
doratalk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Kirthi- I loved your post! It is so true- not only did Aarti do her best to make up for the absence of the father but she also did everything she could to protect the idea of a father being a loving and caring person. She did this for five long years. It took Prashant all of five minutes to disrupt her image as the perfect, selfless mother in Ansh's eyes. That broke my heart.

What you say is so true: children really can detect animosity amongst adults. What they cannot do is understand the complexity of adult relationships. They can understand that mom hates the very sight of P. They cannot understand how that's possible if she really dd love him once. They can feel the raw emotions yet they expect the world to be black or white. The perception of the different shades of grey in relationships is directly proportional to the loss of innocence. And Ansh is on the shades of grey fast track. That also breaks my heart.

You mention how the show is about second chances. Isn't Prashant being given a second chance as well? By life. By circumstances. He is being given a second chance to become a part of his son's life- to redeem himself in the eyes of his son. Yet, he is blowing it. He may not see it and it may seem to him like he is winning (he may even win round one of the custody battle) but Ansh is a smart little boy who is fiercely loyal to his mother. Not much escapes his notice. But my point is- I think the show also touches on how you can get second chances- but it is really up to you how well you make use of them.

Thank you Kirthi- again- for a lovely post! I thoroughly enjoyed reading it- and sharing my own related thoughts!

EDIT: I am also so excited to see Borna's response to your post! Yay!😃
Edited by doratalk - 12 years ago
angake thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: InduG64

And this is what scares me for the later days, when Ansh will go to live with Prashant. Today, even though he knows his mother does not like Prashant, he still defends Prashant for whatever little goodness he had bestowed on them...When Prashant will speak ill of Yash and Aarti, Ansh will again defend them staunchly...that's when Prashant will turn abusive. Because Ansh will make him feel a loser then...as Yash/Aarti would have won simply by being in the little boy's heart.


Thanks, Indu. This is exactly why the mother in me is scared too. It is a natural instinct wanting to protect your child at any cost isn't it. I would die before letting anyone harm my child but this is soap world and Ansh will be okay I suppose. 😆

Reading your post made me realize that yes he did defend Prashant or rather he was asking Aarti to validate his belief that Prashant is still good. It also reminded me of the fight scene between Yash and Prashant. At the end of the fight Yash tells Prashant that I considered you as my friend once so I am letting you go. He too was hanging on to that last vestige of humanity isn't it. Is it any surprise why Ansh is the way he is. ⭐️
drmhp thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Great
well written 👏
angake thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: doratalk

But my point is- I think the show also touches on how you can get second chances- but it is really up to you how well you make use of them.



Thanks Dora, wonderful thoughts. I absolutely loved this line of yours . I wish we could send it to the CVs and ask them if they could make this the tag line of the show instead. 😆


When Prashant came back, he was shown grey rather than black or white. In my books I had already written him off. I can never respect a man who has raised his hands against a woman as a way to show her who has the authority. Nor can I ever trust him not to do the same thing again. I am little weird that way. 😆 But for Ansh's sake I was willing to wait and watch if Prashant would grab hold of the second chance he has got and make use of that to build a loving, respectful relationship with his son. But I guess not.


Yup, heart breaking to see that Ansh today lost a part of his innocence and so will the girls when Ansh will be separated from them. I wonder if they will think of it as another punishment from the grown ups.

angake thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
@miti and Yamunah, Thank you. 😳
kdsubs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
Kirthi - my friend. Beautifully captured. You went straight to the point nah - the impact on the kids - not only Ansh, but also Palak and Payal. But most of all Ansh. When SP finally realizes what he has done, this is precisely what is going to cut him to the core - that he robbed Ansh (yes, even Ansh, because he does love the boy) and his precious little princesses of their childhood. Yash and Arti are adults - and by extension, able to take care of themselves. But the children - the ones who blindly depend on us, look up to us, believe us and in us - the impact to them can well be irreparable. At least in the real world - serial hai, so things will work out i expect.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".