ritzy09 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Hi Friends

Frankly speaking, I have not been watching BV for some days regularly. Tracks are clich and very stagnated. But this post is not about that frustration

Yesterday, I saw the bit where Ganag's past was being narrated to Jagya and though Jagya got Anandi's flashbacks but my only thought was why? Infact Ganga's story is very similar to Gehna's story and he should have got flashback of her DS, Tausa and Taisa.

Gehna was young girl married to a man double her age by giving money to her parents who wanted a way out of their financial mess. Her groom (Tausa) was already a widower and she was married only for kid. Tausa forced her and DS didn't care for her life in front of her grandson

During a showdown, after Gehna became a mother, she said she will leave the house. DS said she could leave but she has to leave the child behind.

To me it was same story but with a family which has not redeemed yet whereas DS / Tausa have.

I so wish CVs had shown some other circumstances because how can the family who have once done the same atrocities can become preachers. They may have reformed now but issue is too close to what has transpired in their own home.

I missed the old Gehna so much. She was a fabulous actress and could have actually carried with a track which gave prominence to her in resolving Ganga's problem.

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

3.4k

Users

12

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

tistaa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
yes you are right
Ganga's story is not only similar to Gahena's one but totally carbon copy of Phooli's story
We have seen exact same situation previously
And Anandi fought for Phooli with her single hand
So what is Jaggu's calibarity here to save Ganga?
frankly I also dont see any requirement of this repeatation
Sorry I dont mean to hurt any feeling's of Ganga's fan and I dont bash her even I like her character but I think the plot is simple repeatation
Sargesh thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
They shud have introduced some interesting story of ganga thses r nw ghisi piti
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Thanks for the post.Thought provoking it is😊

Thing is that Jagya and Anandi were very young when Gehna came into the family as a new bride of their Tausa.

They were not aware of what was going on in the house at that time they knew that situation at home was tense because thir parents were tense and their new taiji is very unhappy.

By the time they grew up Tausa did a 180 degree turn around and they are happy couple.

So J may not be able to connect with his Taiji's story.

He connected with his story because he also brought home a second wife while his legitimate wife is still at home and he paraded his brand new educated wife in front of his first wife.

So he noticed the similarities there between himself and Ratan.

The way story is going on Jagya will definitely bring her to his family home and the similarities between Ganga and Gehna Ganga and Anandi will be definitely highlighted.

I do hope Ganga becomes wife of Jagya because that will be a fitting punishment for DS too.She did not want a widow who is closer to Basant's age as a second wife she wanted a young girl as a bride for her son.So what could be more fitting punishment for her if she forced to accept Ganga with a child as Jagya's bride?
ritzy09 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: tistaa

yes you are right

Ganga's story is not only similar to Gahena's one but totally carbon copy of Phooli's story
We have seen exact same situation previously
And Anandi fought for Phooli with her single hand
So what is Jaggu's calibarity here to save Ganga?
frankly I also dont see any requirement of this repeatation
Sorry I dont mean to hurt any feeling's of Ganga's fan and I dont bash her even I like her character but I think the plot is simple repeatation

You ares o right...either they should have come up with some other issue like widowed (Prem Rog Style though that would have been DS story) or simply harassed by her family for dowry, characterless husband (more in line with Jagya's redemption).
In this track Anandi and Gehna both can do much more than Jagya and it would have been really interesting if Gehna's character could have been evolved to the one who identifies with her problem and try to help her instead of Jagya
dixie123 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Ritzy.. 🤗 Long time no see

I agree about Neha Marda. She was terrrific. I so loved her too.

Jagya cannot relate to BS-Gehna.. Wasn't he too young at that time ? He wouldn't know the details. He was getting FB of what he did to Anandi and what Ratan is doing to Ganga. Jagya's understanding is now only limited ot how Anandi might have felt when he brought Gauri as his wife into the Haveli.

Maybe when the Haveli people come to learn of Ganga's story, DS,BS-Gehna might get FBs and will be considerate to Ganga. That FB from the haveli people makes sense.

ritzy09 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Thanks for the post.Thought provoking it is😊


Thing is that Jagya and Anandi were very young when Gehna came into the family as a new bride of their Tausa.

They were not aware of what was going on in the house at that time they knew that situation at home was tense because thir parents were tense and their new taiji is very unhappy.

By the time they grew up Tausa did a 180 degree turn around and they are happy couple.

So J may not be able to connect with his Taiji's story.

He connected with his story because he also brought home a second wife while his legitimate wife is still at home and he paraded his brand new educated wife in front of his first wife.

So he noticed the similarities there between himself and Ratan.

The way story is going on Jagya will definitely bring her to his family home and the similarities between Ganga and Gehna Ganga and Anandi will be definitely highlighted.

I do hope Ganga becomes wife of Jagya because that will be a fitting punishment for DS too.She did not want a widow who is closer to Basant's age as a second wife she wanted a young girl as a bride for her son.So what could be more fitting punishment for her if she forced to accept Ganga with a child as Jagya's bride?

I agree to an extent that maybe Jagya will not be able to relate to it now but once family is introduced they can not unrelate it to what happened to Gehna. In that case, Gehna should be able to identify more and do something for her rather than Jagya.
I just feel it is too similar and repetetive. A fresh issue like harassment over dowry or character less husband who has left her for another woman would have been a better track for Jagya redemption. This in my eyes is more of Tausa and DS redemptin than Jagya
ritzy09 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: dixie123

Ritzy.. 🤗 Long time no see

I agree about Neha Marda. She was terrrific. I so loved her too.

Jagya cannot relate to BS-Gehna.. Wasn't he too young at that time ? He wouldn't know the details. He was getting FB of what he did to Anandi and what Ratan is doing to Ganga. Jagya's understanding is now only limited ot how Anandi might have felt when he brought Gauri as his wife into the Haveli.

Maybe when the Haveli people come to learn of Ganga's story, DS,BS-Gehna might get FBs and will be considerate to Ganga. That FB from the haveli people makes sense.

Haan yaar...busy wit work and two kids upar se dragging story.
Just come to peek in WU but could not stop from posting this after hearing Ganga's story. It was creepily similar to Gehna and so the post.
I just don't want to get dissapointed a)If they don't make Gehna take a lead in this especially with Neha M gone b)Becoming a repetition of Phooli's story with Jagya replacing Anandi
Already a little bored with epis nowdays...
Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Jagya was a kid at that time. He may not really know what all happened to Gehna. But yes Ganga - Gehna story is very similar too.


mahi12 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

@Ritzy Ganga 's character will show redemption of DS and Jagaya both

Yes her story is related to Gehna more than Anandi but like aparnauma has said Jagaya has been unaware of his Taijee miseries because he was too young at that time so he can only connect Ganga with Anandi where he found similarities But yes DS can connect Ganga's story with Gehna .Accepting Ganga as her DIL is one real test for DS that will show how much she has changed? ...her redemption especially when she is having her own child and DS will have to accept her child as her waaris we all know how much she is pining for her generation forwarding these days and she will defo try to hunt for a virgin bride for J and force him to re marry ..so this is going to be real test of DS😛

How it is Jagaya's redemption .?Jagaya for which flaws he left Anandi .according to him .he felt her below Gauri are present in Ganga too , a simple , less educated village girl What he should have done for Anandi related to her education etc but he didn't he will have to do it for Ganga .Ganga was a cheerful girl but due to misbehavior of her husband that made her lose her cheer in life She is currently more like a dead body who has lost all cheer of her life Jagaya will bring that cheer back in her ..that will mark his redemption and he will learn a better lesson too all glitters is not gold something which you are thinking as raw dust only hidden inside it the real gold only you need to put effort in polishing that gold

Similarity in stories well yes there are some similarities in Ganga's story and many more stories unfolded in BV but at same cvs is handling this track in different way so the difference is coming for example its highlighting child marriage which Gehna was not depicting she was not a balika vadhu Cvs brought all the dark realities of cruelty on women in this one story in aspect of child marriage and it is true it happens .Cvs didn't copy all story of Anandi for Ganga at same time they didn't copy all story of Phooli and Gehna to Ganga They brought this story in a different shade if some similarities are there many difference too isn't it ?

if singhs will be preaching morals now they have corrected their mistakes to Gehna , Anandi and they gave both good lives. Singhs will also preach same to Ganga's family but they are too inhuman to listen to them and will end up in hell Ganga will live a happy life with Singhs

Edited by mahi12 - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".