Has Jai Committed a Sin In Your Eyes??

Heya All

how are you?

A "Sin" is a term usually used in a religious context..meaning anyone straying or breaking the laws or morals that God has set..many of us take religion extremely seriously and as far as i am aware that to have an intimate relationship with anyone other than your wife/husband is a sin regardless of the circumstances..i mean in some religions to even "look" or "stare" at another man/woman outside of marriage with the wrong intentions is considered a paap...

For a minute assume its not the great Jai Walia and some stranger, i know its a serial but in reality many Divorces are linked to adultery, to have an intimate relation outside of marriage is the breaking of a vow you make in marriage as well as as committing a sin in the eyes of God.

In my eyes regardless of Jai being intoxicated he committed adultery which is a sin he not only broke a moral law set by God he also broke a vow he made to his wife by sharing himself😆😆(that sounds funny)..

My questions are that in your eyes has Jai sinned?none of us are actually aware he went all the way.. bearing in mind that Pia said i gave you my "Tan and Mann" presume they did go all the way, do you think what he did was right?and he had a valid reason to do what he did?

(This is not a Ram/Jai bashing post by the way...so please dont insult him..its just a sharing of views and opinions..thanks)

lotsa love

Becky🤗

hi becki i believe it is a sin and i do think he went all the way

i think also that it's a sin because he makes a vow regarding religions when he made the saat phere. Pia also because she stills married. A man or woman who has relationship out of mariage and that they both made a religious wedding and break the vowsit's a sin 😕. I don't blame people who aren't married and that have relationships with other because itsn't a sin. i don't know if we understand sorry 4 my english i knows isn't very good

in one simple sentence it is a sin!!!

of course its a sin - even if they didn't go all d way.. they kissed didn't they.. he was in another women's arms.. wasn't he.. that is a sin - drunk or not drunk.. when u gettin drunk.. u should be careful bout ur whereabouts and who u with. he was wit another women.. and he slept on d same bed as her.. even if they didn't do anythin.. u just go sharin a bed wit someone like that.so yep SIN.. im not even talkin bout jai - any man or women doin that.. is a sin.. cuz ur in a relationship wit someone - and ur betrayin that person's trust in d worst way possible.. that's a sin

simple- he has sinned

yes, yes, we might not know all of what occured between them, or if pia is just saying all these things to blackmail him...but whatever happened, he still sinned. because he broke bani's vishwaas, her faith, her trust... after everything he had said to her..after claiming to see past her anger and understand her helplessness...after telling her their relationship may not have been the joining of two hearts, but that of two souls...no matter what state of mind..he not only "spent time" with some woman...he "spent time" with his SAALI!!! his WIFE'S SISTER!!!!!!!.... whatever he did/didn't do still is not justified, so i'm waiting to see what crap mayii is gonna pull off to show his justification (is that a word?? 😕 😆 )...

Originally posted by: sweetsorrow18

no matter whut kind of mental state jai was in....it is a sin!

i so agree!!!

yes...he has definitely sinned!! Even he was drunk and heartbroken (and i always keep repeating this in every post 😆 ) HE made the decision to sleep with her (if they did go all the way)...like you said before..it takes two to tango 😉

yes ,tecnically he was still married to bani since the divorce hadn't come through.
but what might lessen his guilt is the fact that he was convinced that bani no longer loved him and infact wanted the divorce.
One can understand why he did what he did.spurned by two women he loved and trusted it couldn't have been easy for him to resist comfort from someone who professed to have fallen in love with him again.

jai now seems like any other man.thank god for that.
he really had all of us eating out of his hand earlier!!!!
for most of us our romance with character jai has come to an end.
amen to that