Are The Turks (Soaps) Really Coming To Kill Us? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

1.9k

Users

11

Likes

32

Frequent Posters

-Maha- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: starstruckk

Is it really that big of an invasion? 😕


It's more or less the newer channels like Express & Urdu1 that are showing these Turkish shows, and it definitely has everything to do with money for their channel because they're fairly new channels. It's another thing that these shows are being watched.

I agree with Talat Hussain though. Most Pakistanis living within Pakistan are wannabes (no offense to anyone here..keyword = most). They are delusional and can't connect with the fact that they are Pakistanis living within Pakistan. For them seeing such Turkish shows is sort of like escapism. I'm sure for people who live outside of Pakistan, find nothing special whatsoever in such foreign, dubbed shows. I'm also sure that's the case with many Pakistanis in Pakistan too..but there is a portion of those who feel otherwise which is why these dramas are the highest rated dramas right now. As Talat Hussain said it's what some people want to see.

Another thing, this is what happens when every other drama is an adaptation of a novel. Why would you want to follow a 20+ episode drama for months, when you've read the novel and already know the story? when on the other hand you could easily watch a Turkish show which offers something totally different than your own shows. Pakistani dramas need to stop using novels all the time..it gets boring. I haven't read many of these novels but it's easy to find out the entire story of a drama through the internet etc and even promos nowadays which makes you lose excitement for a drama.

And Humayun Saeed isn't really far from the truth. Bollywood actors & actresses are more popular in Pakistan than Pakistani actors & actresses. I think Fawad Khan is one of the few actors who has sort of changed that..but bollywood movies are always the center of attention in Pakistan when compared to dramas. Not everyone in Pakistan will know who the likes of Mahira Khan, Saba Qamar, Aamina Sheikh are whereas everyone will know who Deepika, Anushka, Katrina are.

@ Bold True
pk14 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
...there is nothing wrong in turkish content to run on our channel at the end of day it would b turkish culture but this should happen only in case when our dramas like humsafar should also run dubbed in turkish language in turkish channels...if this happen then its fair ..internet is now something availabel to every one we watch american shows ,indian shows etc etc but this doesnot ruin our drama industry becoz our drama industry has proved its impotance ppl are watching pakistani dramas i can feel it at my home its been 3 years now my mother again became fond of watching our shows i remember the time when we used to watch indian stuff all the day but our direcotrs ,artists worked so hard and make us all pakistani drama viewer again ..so i don't think any foriegn content runnig on our channels is threat to us or our industry coz if ppl watching ishq e manu they all too watching manjali ,kahi unkahi ,zindagi gulazar ha ,tanhaiyaaan etc etc but u know sometime thing become over rated same the case with ishqe mamnu ...its nothing but over rated drama with some vulgar story and handome guy and pretty girls its jst that ...nothing else
-SMay31- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: -Maha-

Our nation is living in some kinda complex ..
someone define the term liberal for me now..its more like kawa chala hans ki chaal apni chaal bhe bhool gaya.dont we have our own culture ? our own identity? .Complex k maary log 😵
Honestly the content of our drama is still way better than indian and turkish shows,we need some good production houses and some new faces ..but yea our people always love to run behind glamor or something that is not suitable for our culture.first it was saas bahu soaps of ekta & now its ishq-e-mamnu 😵

and that behlul.. no offense but we defo have some better looking actors in our industry, dunno why girls are going crazy behind him🤔

@bold : lmao datz so true 😆
karankittu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
do these turkish drams have kissing scenes and women with hardly any clothes on?
because if so i will have nothing left to watch.
When i was little my dad put on sky for us so i could watch asian channels rather than english soaps.
starstruckk thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: BlackStar.

Even if Bollywood dominates Pakistan it doesn't take away from the drama industry..
It takes away from the film industry.

And correct me if I'm wrong but majority of the people who read novels actually watch the drama's to see how it's dramatizedd. It's the one's who don't read novels who also don't watch the dramas.

I do find this to be an issue not because of the Turkish shows but because channels and production houses both need a desperate wake up call..
It's still not too late..
Fresh scripts.. Interesting ideas.. No more novels..
And for goodness sake if you wanna do 7 days of drama at-least make half the drama's worthy of being watchedd.


Our films don't compete with their films. Our dramas try making up for the poor films we're making at least for Pakistani audiences.yet still Indian films are more popular among Pakistani masses than Pakistani dramas and thus, so are their stars. That's exactly what Humayun Saeed was trying to say.


And yes, people who read novels do watch dramas..but my point is some people may prefer watching foreign material over a drama that's based on a novel which they've already read. I mean half the time dramas don't live up to the novels' standards and people always end up complaining that the novel was ruined, this & that. In fact, some people decide to make a judgement on a drama right from the very beginning with just the mere cast. All of this can only last so long. Pakistani production houses have to start asking writers to write drama scripts and original ones. That's probably the only way for our material to get its due when we have foreign material airing too.


Edited by starstruckk - 13 years ago
Usman. thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
Ok ishq-e-mamnoo has become the talk of the town that does not mean that others (Fatimagul & Noor) will essentially become hits.. I think its the media (newspaper) & audience who are giving it unnecessary hype. ..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".