sia1976 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Today's episode left me with a very bitter taste in my mouth. For the first time I am disappointed with what I saw and I shall pen down why.

I have time again mentioned that NBT is an unconventional story and have given my reasons for the same too.

As a woman what I admired and appreciated the most was the characterisation of the lead protagonist Megha, who despite being a widow with two kids, was portrayed in a completely different light unlike any other hindi television shows. She exhibited strength and will power to face life against all odds. She had a mind of her own. Irrespective of circumstances she always stood for what she believed in and never bowed down before anyone for wrong reasons atleast. She was never aggressive like Renu, but she was never submissive either. She always stood up for her honour and dignity come what may. She lived with her head held high and taught her kids the same. I am talking in past tense because today the creative team has marred her character which left me flabbergasted.

Kya pata kitne din rukna pad jaye? Raat ke kapde rakh liye? Kitne Jode rakhe ek ya do? Renu made these derogatory comments and posed a question on Megha's character while Megha stood there without giving any reactions or response. Why??? Even Jeeji Bua understood what Renu was hinting at but it had zero effect on Megha. I would not term it as Megha being indifferent, but it looked like as if she had given up on her self-respect.

Both Renu and Megha are daughter-in-laws of Vyas Parivar and therefore they both enjoy the same rights and status. So what gives Renu the audacity to humiliate and insult Megha in such a cheap manner? Renu as a character was always shown to have grey shades, but looks like to increase the drama quotient; the creative team have now turned her completely black and made Megha look like a dimwit in her presence.

I have no issues with the drama quotient as long as the characters act and react within their periphery and there is character consistency. Today I felt a disconnect with Megha's character and got very restless. Especially after Papaji having forgiven her, and also Megha's conscious being clear, there is absolutely no reason why she should silently listen to such derogatory comments when her honour and dignity is at stake.

I would have also appreciated if instead of Nanhi, Megha had opened her mouth and spoken the truth about the chit since she too was aware why and how Mohan got hold of that number. Making a promise to not be the cause of any trouble does not mean that one stops opening his or her mouth when needed. In this case it was all the more important for Megha to open her mouth and speak because Mohan was talking about Amar and proving him innocent matters the most to Megha.

Today I was unable to fathom her silence. It's my sincere and humble request to the Makers/Creative Team, to kindly analyse megha's character once again, since she is the lead protagonist of the show and is ideally suppose to inspire and be a role model for many in the real world.

I somehow had a strong feeling that Renu's comments would eventually prompt Papaji to accompany Megha, hence the precap did not surprise me. To be honest I am happy with Papaji's decision to tag along with them as this will help him to observe Mohan from close quarters. Its extremely important that he forms a positive opinion about Mohan inorder to support their relationship in the near future when rest of the world decides to go against them.

Finally the dialogue of the day...Unhe mein pa toh nahi sakta, lekin mein unhe khona bhi nahi chahta, uske liye toh mujhe chup hi rehna padega..."You are my life, you are the only thing it would hurt to lose." Mohan does not know if Megha will ever love him, but what he does know is that he will till his last breath.
Edited by sia1976 - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

61

Views

3.6k

Users

19

Likes

240

Frequent Posters

_SilentSoul_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Swati, I don't know what to say cause I actually fast forwarded Renu's craps. But yes, I did get that the CVs are turning her into a complete vamp. Arre yaar, this was the only show without the vamp and conspiracy stuff, lekin ab woh bhi lag raha hai ki nahi rahega. Anyways what bothered me the most after I read your post is that Megha stayed quiet. Why? Perhaps cause she always ignore Renu's taunts. But again, this made me disappointed too. Hope to watch some good and logical content in the further episodes. The SE has to be better like the previous ones. Anyways dekhte hai! Thanks for your post...It was much needed!
Dee_76 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
sia1976: Mohan does not know if Megha will ever love him, but what he does know is that he will till his last breath.
That really tells us how much he loves her with asking nothing in return, tht is why Monu sabki jaan hai 😍☺️
Hit.It.Miss thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Yet again very well written Swati 👏 and I agree with you on Renu's character turning into a vamp but she had already started in earnest when Megha returned from the farmhouse. Since then we have been just about coping and barely tolerating her hounding Megha.🤢 Renu's character started off like that of an interfering, imposing, silly gossip-indulging woman, irritating but harmless. But since the last 3 weeks, she has been increasingly getting louder and very cunning, what with always instigating Mohan and constantly calling him badmaash and lafanga etc.

Now Megha not coming forward to support the chit in front of Papa ji - I had been afraid that Megha would probably not say anything (though i had been wishing too that she should have) and later Jiji's dialogue to Megha did provide some insight as to why Megha held herself back rigidly, so Nanhi had to save the day. Jiji said
'''Tum donon ke beech jo bhi hua woh apni jagah hai, tum ne koshish tou ki thhi na uss se duur rehney ki''
While previously or given any other opportunity, presented with such a chance of finding proofs for Amar by Mohan, Megha would have jumped to grab it with both hands and would have managed to convince her family too...but today's Megha sadly didn't do it, why? I guess due to her still being raw from the aftermath of her silly mrs.bhatnagar drama, seeing how MIL grilled her as to what exactly is Mohan to her - all this accompanied by Renu's poisonous taunts. Even more so, as Megha now knows that Mohan is indeed in love with her so no matter what her heart kept screaming, she held her sentiments in check in the mandir scene and wisely didn't come forward.

Waisey I have just seen the renu scene with Megha - the last one and i don't think that it reflected in any way that Megha has given up on her self-respect. In fact she very intelligently kept quiet. You know naa what Renu is? Essentially a bigmouth/loud-mouth and a narcissistic type of person. Megha's strategy of dealing with Renu (except where it concerns her children) is always to give the silent treatment which serves her just right.
Megs knows that Renu deliberately resorts to taunts/degrading comments, not so much to make Megha look bad but to make HERSELF feel good. Such a person is stuck in a desperate circle of constantly trying to justify her worth with an inflated sense of self. This doesn't mean at all that Megha shouldn't defend herself or end up becoming a doormat but unfortunately with such incessantly stupid people like Renu, it's hardly worth the effort. If their relationship is this toxic then it's better for Megha to distance herself. Megha showing that she was unaffected by Renu's blathering and blabbering did give a sound slap as well as a powerful message to Renu's face that neither her insults nor her comments, however degrading they might be, would ever make a difference or bother Megha, one way or the other. Megha has lived with Renu for two years so she knows very well that coming across as being affected by Renu's disgusting taunts or speaking up would not shut up Renu. Instead it would have meant rising to Renu's bait and stooping to her level. I am proud that Megha acted sensibly and didn't provide Renu with the chance she was looking for, to start off her barrage of cheap insults.

Edited by Fmani - 13 years ago
_SilentSoul_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Fmani ji Megha ki defence ke liye humesha ready hai 😛 😆 Jokes apart, beautifully explained dii! I can always understand Megha better through your analysis!
Hit.It.Miss thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Lol you caught me again😆

Thanks, my name is Fariha. Hehe ajj tou Swati ne bhi saath chhor diya Megha ka tou kisi ko tou aana hee thha Megha sweety ke liye naa. Monu got busy so that's why I dropped in😆😛

P.S did you just call me dii? as in sister? if yes then aww so sweet of you, thanks 🤗
Edited by Fmani - 13 years ago
swapna82 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
I agree Megha knows Renu well, so she might think it's better to keep quiet than argue, and not replying to Renu's taunts were okay to me..
But, Megha not defending Mohan when papaji was shouting at him is NOT OK !!!
Megha seems to have forgotten everything that Mohan did for her, also how he stands for her at every possible moment !! She never gives anything back in return ! High time she starts supporting Mohan even if as a friend, as she doesn't love him yet... When Nanhi can do so much for Mohan, why can't Megha stand up for him 😡
_SilentSoul_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Fmani

Lol you caught me again😆


Thanks, my name is Fariha. Hehe ajj tou Swati ne bhi saath chhor diya Megha ka tou kisi ko tou aana hee thha Megha sweety ke liye naa. Monu got busy so that's why I dropped in😆😛

P.S did you just call me dii? as in sister? if yes then aww so sweet of you, thanks 🤗

Swati ji bhi kya kare yaar.. Megha ji hai hi itni complicated 😆 I'm glad of one thing that NBT is the only show where the female lead isn't "devi" of perfection and righteousness 🤣

Nice name! Can I ask one thing if you don't mind? Where are you from? Cuz Fariha is a commonly used name in my country Bangladesh. So just asking! Aur haan, meri aadat hai ki mujhse badi kisi ko bhi main bro ya dii bolti hoon 😳 So no thanks to ur lil sis 🤗
Hit.It.Miss thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
@ Swapna82
Yeah well, if you can manage to make Megha go back to her childhood and turn into a child of nanhi's age, then even Megha can show her ''friendship'' with Mohan and innocently stand up and speak out her mind, fearless in the face of all elders.
How can you compare nanhi and Megha? Nanhi is an innocent child, an angel and children..whatever they do or the way they go about it even if it's against family's wishes, at least it's never misconstrued and a child is never mated out judgements let alone harsh ones. The things that children doing, can get away with easily, same things done by adults are totally scrutinized and given awful connotations to. A friendship bond b/w a child-adult and b/w two mature adults is respectively different. At Nanhi's tender age, everything is simple and so is loyalty and friendship too that's why she so spontaneously came forward and explained all. Sadly Megha Mohan's friendship is not as simple as that and that you must be knowing too (afterall Mohan loves Megha as a man loves a woman ) so unfortunately adult friendships are very complicated. Megha will of course support Mohan whenever it's possible for her in future but it's not some child's play of dosti dosti that they are playing. Megha has been stretched from all directions (seeing the past few episodes) that's why, against her wishes, she held herself back forcefully from helping or supporting Mohan in front of all.
Edited by Fmani - 13 years ago
_SilentSoul_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: swapna82

I agree Megha knows Renu well, so she might think it's better to keep quiet than argue, and not replying to Renu's taunts were okay to me..
But, Megha not defending Mohan when papaji was shouting at him is NOT OK !!!
Megha seems to have forgotten everything that Mohan did for her, also how he stands for her at every possible moment !! She never gives anything back in return ! High time she starts supporting Mohan even if as a friend, as she doesn't love him yet... When Nanhi can do so much for Mohan, why can't Megha stand up for him 😡

Megha khud hi phas gayi yaar. Ek taraf accha dost hai aur dusri taraf parivaar. I know she should stand for Mohan but understand her state too. Usse phirse galat samjha jata agar woh aisa kuch karti cuz even if reality bites, she's the DIL, not the daughter. Whether in Mohan's case, things are far different cuz ultimately he's a guy who has more rights than Megha!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".