criticism punar vivah

miss_angel21 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
With all do respect, as I love the show, I would like to give feedback from an audience point of view.
Where are gurmeet/ yash's lines/movements? Honestly, everytime when something is said to him by his daughters, aarti, ansh, he doesn't reply. And his reaction is framed, he doesn't move.
He might be introvert, but still he can react in many ways, it doesn't mean that he has to stay as a statue. It's doing injustice to a talented actor like Gurmeet Chaudery. I know I shouldn't compare, but just to make my point clear, eventhough you might not have lines, you can still do something. When geet (geet hui sabse parayi) talked to maan and he had no lines, he still reacted with his movements. In punar vivah he's only standing. He could be replaced by any good looking actor. And trust me, I don't want to say that, but it's true.
Thus, I hope, he will react and really react as opposed to just standing there. Yash might be thinking, but it's not evident, it makes you do something. Otherwise you can just put a picture there, when he's supposed to be reacting.
I love the chemistry between yash and aarti! That is wonderful! Keep up the good work and I'm sure punar vivah will be at nr 1!
Lots of love!!

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2.5k

Users

14

Likes

60

Frequent Posters

priyachand thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
hi nice post!

even i felt that lack of reaction! i mean GC is a wonderful actor who could convey a lot with just his eye movements. here he is more like a statue other than occasional glimpses of emotion we cant see anything else. even his voice he has deliberately changed. why? is it just to show difference?
-ProudGCian- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
oh god...y again...šŸ˜›
Here yash is mourning man..He misses his love every passing second badly...what u people want him 2 dance'ah??šŸ˜†... Dont u see those scenes of yash and arpi...and how he used 2 enjoy like a thunder storm...I very much know tat u people are aware of GC's character in tis story so far...
But the real fact is u are not able 2 come out from his previous imagešŸ˜•...tats all...
come on yaar...šŸ¤—chill kaaro...and enjoy PV...😃
DMKJ_VB thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: priyachand

hi nice post!

even i felt that lack of reaction! i mean GC is a wonderful actor who could convey a lot with just his eye movements. here he is more like a statue other than occasional glimpses of emotion we cant see anything else. even his voice he has deliberately changed. why? is it just to show difference?



Yes, he changed his voice deliberately. He also changed his voice for GHSP. IF u listen to his interviews, u can make out that GURMEET CHOUDHARY does not talk like MSK! SO hats off to him for such wonderful modulations! Whoever has watched Ramayan knows that he spoke with a different pitch there- that one is closest to the real himself. What a gifted man, he even has the capacity to modulate his voice, by changing the pitch and tone with every different character!

Lack of reaction? šŸ˜• in some places where Yash doesn't react, he isn't supposed to react! thats his character.Its known as being in character! MSK and Yash are 2 different people! so, obviously, their action-reaction will be different!

IamaPCmaniac thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
i completely disagree. its his style... i know many people who are like satues.. i think its damn realistic
is hischaracter, and when he doesnt mve, there is a smoke, there is the tashan of his eyes
jikky_84 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AmeTz

oh god...y again...šŸ˜›
Here yash is mourning man..He misses his love every passing second badly...what u people want him 2 dance'ah??šŸ˜†... Dont u see those scenes of yash and arpi...and how he used 2 enjoy like a thunder storm...I very much know tat u people are aware of GC's character in tis story so far...
But the real fact is u are not able 2 come out from his previous imagešŸ˜•...tats all...
come on yaar...šŸ¤—chill kaaro...and enjoy PV...😃


I completely agree with you dear...big hugsšŸ¤—

Why this comparison, why can't people see Yash as Yash and no one elsešŸ˜•

Gurmeet is doing a wonderful job as Yash😃
Why can't they see emotions in Yash's face, are they really looking into TV screenšŸ˜†
Break.The.Code thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Oh brother not againšŸ˜›
Seriously I feel Yash is the role that is going to really boost up his career level.
Maan Singh Khurana was a man who hated the word 'Love' until he met Geet.Arrogance and pride were in his blood.His anger levels shoot up unnecessarily even for the menial matters but Yash Sindhiya is a man who 'has been in love' with an amazing woman called Arpita and he doesn't want anyone to disturb his imaginary relationship he still shares with her even after her death!Yash has shut himself in Arpita's memories and is scared that he may betray her by falling for Aarti.That is why he stays mum most of the time.
Gurmeet's talent is being utilized in the perfect way in the serial.I cannot imagine ANY OTHER ACTOR doing this job as perfect as Gurmeet does here.I have always loved TOM CRUISE but I think Gurmeet has greater potentials in doing this role that Tom.
Break.The.Code thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: gurunthebest

i completely disagree. its his style... i know many people who are like satues.. i think its damn realistic

is hischaracter, and when he doesnt mve, there is a smoke, there is the tashan of his eyes

@bold--Beautiful lines😳
-Serene.Rose- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: AmeTz

oh god...y again...šŸ˜›
Here yash is mourning man..He misses his love every passing second badly...what u people want him 2 dance'ah??šŸ˜†... Dont u see those scenes of yash and arpi...and how he used 2 enjoy like a thunder storm...I very much know tat u people are aware of GC's character in tis story so far...
But the real fact is u are not able 2 come out from his previous imagešŸ˜•...tats all...
come on yaar...šŸ¤—chill kaaro...and enjoy PV...😃



Exactly.. Completely agree with you:)


Its a bit sad to see him that way.. all glum & gloomy but he does smile when he's with his girlzz..

And the best part.. Somewhere, I dunno I feel Aarti will teach him how to smile again as the show progresses
šŸ˜

Till then... just chill & dream of AarYa's slight smiles that are not too far awayšŸ˜‰
-ProudGCian- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Priyamvada



Exactly.. Completely agree with you:)


Its a bit sad to see him that way.. all glum & gloomy but he does smile when he's with his girlzz..

And the best part.. Somewhere, I dunno I feel Aarti will teach him how to smile again as the show progresses
šŸ˜

Till then... just chill & dream of AarYa's slight smiles that are not too far awayšŸ˜‰


thk u for agreeing with me dear...šŸ¤—
really story got its pace and progressing very well with all dept humuor, parenting, romancešŸ˜‰
i m enjoying thoroughly...šŸ‘

Edited by AmeTz - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".