was there really a rape?

I thought Mandira consensually slept with sameer thinking it's Rishi and sameer thought it's Indira. As far as I know there was no force/rape. Did I miss anything?

I was thinking the same. I'm so confuseddd..

why confused rape happened 3 days back

looks like you people not watched serial last week .
HD airs at 8.00 pm--it is family viewing time--so ila avoided showing rape scene,but only given description.

that created confusion in the mind of viewers.

Originally posted by: 100raj

looks like you people not watched serial last week .
HD airs at 8.00 pm--it is family viewing time--so ila avoided showing rape scene,but only given description.

that created confusion in the mind of viewers.

check ur pm bro...

indira found mandira wandering on the road in a terrible state. mandira said sameer raped her. inder also remember seeing sameer coming out of one of the rooms buttoning up his shirt. plus the room is in a mess. doctor also confirmed that mandira was raped. so i guess it really did happen. sameer did that for revenge when he heard rishi marrying indira. mandira and sameer first sexual encounter was of her own free will though because she thought sameer was rishi...

Originally posted by: babu2008

I thought Mandira consensually slept with sameer thinking it's Rishi and sameer thought it's Indira. As far as I know there was no force/rape. Did I miss anything?

Both events happened. The incident that you are referring to happened during Pappu's sisters wedding time frame and the rape occurred recently. The rape occurred after Sameer thought that Inshi got married (in the mandup that he had set up to force Indira to marry him after paying goons to kidnap Indira). Rishi found out about the kidnapping and saved Indira and called Sameer and told him that he is marrying Indira in the mandup that Sameer had set up for himself. This call occurred while Sameer was at Indira's house and Mandira happened to be there and was saying to him that she will tell her didi if he doesn't marry her and then when he is about to leave she says she will claim that he raped her. This set him off even more after the phone call that he just got so yes he actually does rape Mandira. Indira takes her to a dr. after seeing her wandering the streets and nearly getting run over and the Dr. says that she believes that she has been raped (this is after she checks out Mandira). Dr. says there are signs of lots of physical force etc and that she is going to send Mandira's clothes for testing too.

Well, I just went thru all the written updates again and didn't find the rape edpisode. I didn't know about this event. It is sad that rape happened and it is very bad and horrifying for any girl. Somehow I am not sympathetic with Mandira. I always hated everybody in Indira's family except Ishan. I never saw such a bad family ever. Also, Mandira is the one who slept with Sameer in the first place and then started blackmailing him and instigating him. Sameer is BAD but Mandira is not good either.

Originally posted by: babu2008

Well, I just went thru all the written updates again and didn't find the rape edpisode. I didn't know about this event. It is sad that rape happened and it is very bad and horrifying for any girl. Somehow I am not sympathetic with Mandira. I always hated everybody in Indira's family except Ishan. I never saw such a bad family ever. Also, Mandira is the one who slept with Sameer in the first place and then started blackmailing him and instigating him. Sameer is BAD but Mandira is not good either.

Hi Babu,

Check March 22nd episode:

You will see that the Dr. says that she can say without a doubt that the patient was raped. At the beginning of the show you see Mandira wondering the streets aimlessly which is where Indira finds her and takes her to the hospital as she notices lots of cuts/bruises on her.

If you have time you should watch this episode the interaction between Indira and Mandira was amazing. Indira showing her sisterly/motherly love and support was awesome.

As for Mandira not being good, yes I agree she is not the perfect character however no one deserves rape. Consenting the first time was one thing (even if she did think it was Rishi and she tried to blackmail Sameer with it afterward) but rape is a big no no. She was physically forced this no one deserves!