SwaRon: Poignance, Hope...Stalemate? :\ - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.8k

Users

20

Likes

79

Frequent Posters

Nymeria thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#21
@Anu-- Oh heck yeah we'll still see Sharon struggling. She's definitely not going to open THEIR book until she's done flipping one page of her OWN book. She's got to accept her feelings herself before she can express any to HIM. But like you said, this time around she won't be putting up the "meanie" side to him because she just won't be able to do so anymore. She's still going to be in her "denial" mode but rather than anger, she's going to be shifting towards gradual and I mean very gradual acceptance...her unconscious progression has already begun with all that happened in Goa segments.
Sneha's doing a very good job showing this transition in Sharon...it flows nicely and it actually gives that feeling of witnessing her character's growth even if there's only so little they show of her most of the times.
SugarCubes thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#22
Amazing topic di'! :D
actually after today's scene I was very confused about what my emotion should really be like! Should it be happy or sad! Happy that finally Sharon is opening up with the feelings she contains for swayam or should be upset that he dint let Sharon speak even a word and jumped to conclusions! Nd said tht he is nt waiting for the book to open again, you should get used to these feelings, I mean wat is all this! Why is he doing this to himself, to Sharon to them!! The silence is now becoming really frustrating nd the track is moving too slow! But I STILL hope that sumthing happens between them really soon!
shaani2209 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#23
nice one nandu...i expected so much to happen 2day...but the line... itne acchese kyu jante ho tum mujhe...has just given me hopes that if not 2day...near future things are gonna be understood by sharon...hope so things turn positive...
shakti_rock thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#24
Yeah...Piognant to put it in a best way...

This can be taken as a REAL start of seeing the REAL Sharon...softened Sharon...When in the 1st scene when Sharon did't say anything to those college girls , I was irked a bit bt then i realize That this Sharon...She will take time to Open up...an dthis was proved e1 more wen she was startin the convo with Swayam...how mush hesistant she was...like chokin up after every word...
We cant expect her to open up all of a sudden...This is her Character ...

I esp liked the dialogues ...they were Strong and hard hitting...Shantannu and Sneha both actd really well...
I esp liked Shraon's reaction to all wat Swayam was sayin...she was emotions in her eyes...also wen swayam says "main us waqt ki zaroorat tha.." ooch...poor guy is really hurt with Proxy thing...also wen swayam says "main abhi bhi us book ke khulne ka intezaar kar rah ahunn..". and then wen he saya "nahin..main nahin kar raha"..aahhh Sharon reaction to this...her eyes emoted a lot..and then the bg music that followed was beautifull...

I simply loved the Last Thankyou...all this while wen Swayam was in front of her...she was not able to say that...the moment he turns she close her eyes..tears flow down and she says it...also Swayam lined how he will never be welcomed by her...fab...

Its time now Sharon move her step towards opening that BOOK...coz its only she who have to do...Swayam toh have lost all the hope...

I loved the bg music they inculcated with dialogues and expressions...Beautifull...!!!

Edited by shakti_rock - 14 years ago
The007Shivani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#25
Yeah agree and hope they start progressing real soon now
without-fathom thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#26
So Rafi made a rant post about the scene today, and Nandini, you made an ambivalent one?! 😆

I'm part of the happy gang - Nur, Ramy... anyone else? I loved the scene. Really. It just flowed for me, touched me like the classic SwaRon stuff always does, got me thinking. Everything about today's scene for me came round full circle. It's like shifting the coordinate system so that the 0,0 point becomes 0',0' - like you're at the starting coordinates again, only your entire reference plane has been shifted with respect to the original - so that, figuratively speaking, you've started fresh, in a sense, without dismissing the history you made. You've just assimilated both in the same time, with a space shift.

Damn - did that make sense? Math is not my thing, AT ALL - but tonight was like that for me. I love that in this coming round full circle scene, Swayam was the one talking. Sharon listening. Swayam guessing - Sharon surprised, and more muted than not. And the confidence Swayam had about his conjectures, was something like Sharon's conjectures from the past where she thought she knew exactly what Swayam's next reaction would be - which usually involved indulging her in some way or the other - and yet, on a certain level, just like Sharon would miss the exact depth and intention of Swayam's indulging gestures, Swayam missed Sharon's start of a change today. He did not necessarily read her actions or predict the reasons wrong - but he missed the shift in her intention. Her thank you - was not like the sorry that had been spoken in the epic scene on this same staircase weeks ago. It wasn't just Sharon's exceptional moment of actually letting on a side to herself which isn't mean. No - this thank you was an acceptance on her part at a deeper level. She has accepted not just that he helped her, and not just that she accepted his help - but is almost willing to accept such a role from him in a continued sense. No, she would never be the person who'd WANT to be in spots where she needs help - from anyone at all! But... she is starting to ease up with the idea of Swayam coming to her aid, entering that space in her life where she can show the need for help, if and when... That acceptance on her part is much deeper and greater, than her sorry had been in the previous staircase scene. This is not just an instance of the rarely civil Sharon. This is a visible unveiling of Sharon, as the person she truly is beneath all the layers she has built up and held for herself.

And that, I think, Swayam missed today. Not that one can blame him. But he did. Just like Sharon would miss the profound nature of Swayam taking her tantrums in all the past times. For a while she passed him off for a smitten fan. Then, she passed him off as someone who knew her more, and someone who certainly showed more substance and mettle beyond just a smitten fan - yet, someone, who could not really come to be at par with her. No matter what. And somewhere, the fact that she accepted he was beyond a usual fan, made her want to bait him more often than she would a regular someone - but the fact that she didn't see HOW deep he ran beneath the appeasing ways never really allowed her to accept an equal in him... upto now.

It was a scene of transition. It marked an end. And it marked a beginning. While I agree with your take on the scene and its emotions at large Nandini, I don't really see a stalemate anywhere. Yes, they probably need a catalyst kind of next kick. But somewhere, Sharon is going to become instrumental in the coming days in terms in initiation - today marked a beginning to that. It's not so simple to dis-armor her entirely, in a go, but it's started off today... And I think given the promo of the girls in guise - however they get to that situation - there will be situations between SwaRon, where Swayam will manage to see beyond what he saw today. Beyond what Sharon's spoken thank you could claim...

A good start to the week - hopefully, to be followed on in the same stride...
..SD.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#27
wen sharon msgd swayam to meet her, i was hoping some positive talk from sharon's side but wen the conversation started all my hopes turned back to me yaha toh swayam sharon ko kuch bolne hi nahi dhe raha hey, only thing i'm happy abt todays epsd was somewher the silence wit which sharon was standing ther b4 swayam n hearing all tat he said shows a positive change in sharon
LiveEatLove thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#28
edited my reply nandz...1st pg...sorry 4 da delay...

Related Topics

Channel V Dil Dosti Dance thumbnail

Posted by: SarafWasima · 5 months ago

A Love Story Sealed in Dance Dreams The sun shone brightly over the beautifully decorated outdoor venue, where fairy lights twinkled even in the...

Expand ▼
Channel V Dil Dosti Dance thumbnail

Posted by: Mystic_Muse · 10 months ago

Hello, I don't know what came into i pen it down. Hope you like it. COVER BY @EXOTICDISASTER It was supposed to be just another evening at...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".