Scene of the day 05/07/2010

Banjaaran25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hTK8_qxr1Ic&feature=related[/YOUTUBE]
na tu samkh aayi..
na samajh aaya yeh dil..
what did he mean by that.
was he confused because he failed to assess the situation.
or was that guilt because he assessed the situation wrongly..
and what did he mean by dil.
was that love, guilt, ego or something else?

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

1.2k

Users

10

Likes

58

Frequent Posters

TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
When I never understood what he was thinking...here he was said to let her go...and yet in the jungle he kept fighting with her.
Ani_La_Iam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Nimmi…I believe Dutta was confuse about what he was feeling…it was not about guilt or about how he had handle the situation...but about what he was feeling inside him…about Naku and about her leaving.😊
kabeeraspeaking thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Aahhh, I loved this scene. So beautifully written and deeply enacted. The spilled sindoor on the ground...the empty dresser...that nuance of Dutta being so in thought within himself that when Nakku calls out, he responds instinctively...'Hmm?'...shaken out of reverie. And when his eyes look up a moment after he has already 'responded' so instinctively and he sees the very object of his contemplation standing as serene and calm as ever...😊

What Dutta was going through? I think he had realized by this time in his heart of hearts, after the dhongi pandit incident, that Nakku was innocent...I think it dawned on him at some subconscious level that this girl who was so purely and devotedly sincere to him in all her actions could not have done what she was accused of and what he had punished her for. That is why he has that flashback of the shaadi...and he thinks 'kameena waqt tha, ya main andha tha?'...because he made a mistake...whether due to the situation that was created or due to his own biases, issues, and misgivings? He doesn't know. But he is reflecting on the choice he made to hold her culprit and the contrasting reality of that...'na tu samajh aayi'...he failed to understand her...and most of all even though there really was no solid or physical evidence to prove her goodness, and yet still he has come to believe it? Isliye na samajh aaya yeh dil...which knows she is innocent even without having any proof to counter the entire Supriya and Ravi debacle...which has let her off the hook even without any evidence...which wants to understand her and is let down at not being able to. And I think...na samajh aaya yeh dil isliye bhi...because it has become constricted itself in irony after having set her 'free'...all of these things that he is feeling and thinking of...the fact that they are occurring to him at a juncture when she about to leave him...it speaks for the emotion in his heart that he holds for her...the distinct presence that she has had in his life...which is at stake and loss...so he feels hollow, unsettled, fettered in these thoughts...but he doesn't know why...na samajh aaya yeh dil...

But still he decides to drive her and her family to their destination based on his gut, on what his instincts lead him on to do on a subconscious level...and it's during that journey that he is able to overcome his anger, hurt, ego, prejudices by a way of events...everything, to realize and accept truly on a concious level that she is special to him...
tamanna1391 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
i love this scene dutta confuse restless on his decision of separating nakku
Banjaaran25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

When I never understood what he was thinking...here he was said to let her go...and yet in the jungle he kept fighting with her.

in jungle he was being himself.. the adorable, stubborn, man-child😃..
me thinks dutta ke ghar ka vastu kharab hai.. dont know which stairs leads to which rooms. he is at his best when outside that house😆..
Banjaaran25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Nakusha

got me thinking 😊

me is successful in my mission😳..
confusing everyone😃
Banjaaran25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Ani_98

Nimmi'I believe Dutta was confuse about what he was feeling'it was not about guilt or about how he had handle the situation...but about what he was feeling inside him'about Naku and about her leaving.😊

🤔i think you are right ani😊..
the more i see him the more i love him and the more he ties me in knots.😆..
thanx ani😃
Banjaaran25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: kabeeraspeaking

Aahhh, I loved this scene. So beautifully written and deeply enacted. The spilled sindoor on the ground...the empty dresser...that nuance of Dutta being so in thought within himself that when Nakku calls out, he responds instinctively...'Hmm?'...shaken out of reverie. And when his eyes look up a moment after he has already 'responded' so instinctively and he sees the very object of his contemplation standing as serene and calm as ever...😊


What Dutta was going through? I think he had realized by this time in his heart of hearts, after the dhongi pandit incident, that Nakku was innocent...I think it dawned on him at some subconscious level that this girl who was so purely and devotedly sincere to him in all her actions could not have done what she was accused of and what he had punished her for. That is why he has that flashback of the shaadi...and he thinks 'kameena waqt tha, ya main andha tha?'...because he made a mistake...whether due to the situation that was created or due to his own biases, issues, and misgivings? He doesn't know. But he is reflecting on the choice he made to hold her culprit and the contrasting reality of that...'na tu samajh aayi'...he failed to understand her...and most of all even though there really was no solid or physical evidence to prove her goodness, and yet still he has come to believe it? Isliye na samajh aaya yeh dil...which knows she is innocent even without having any proof to counter the entire Supriya and Ravi debacle...which has let her off the hook even without any evidence...which wants to understand her and is let down at not being able to. And I think...na samajh aaya yeh dil isliye bhi...because it has become constricted itself in irony after having set her 'free'...all of these things that he is feeling and thinking of...the fact that they are occurring to him at a juncture when she about to leave him...it speaks for the emotion in his heart that he holds for her...the distinct presence that she has had in his life...which is at stake and loss...so he feels hollow, unsettled, fettered in these thoughts...but he doesn't know why...na samajh aaya yeh dil...

But still he decides to drive her and her family to their destination based on his gut, on what his instincts lead him on to do on a subconscious level...and it's during that journey that he is able to overcome his anger, hurt, ego, prejudices by a way of events...everything, to realize and accept truly on a concious level that she is special to him...

that was so beautifully put..
🤗..
loved each and every word of your post..
very well thought and penned down..
touching and true..
and i am in love with the last para..
and it's during that journey that he is able to overcome his anger, hurt, ego, prejudices by a way of events...everything, to realize and accept truly on a concious level that she is special to him...
thank you sooo much..
😊..
Edited by .nimmi. - 13 years ago
Banjaaran25 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: tamanna1391

i love this scene dutta confuse restless on his decision of separating nakku

me too loves this scene tamanna..
and the continuation..
the returning of magalsutra, naku's leaving, the sheen of tears in his eyes.. and the way he drops the sutra down without realizing..
beautiful!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".