Wud it b the case of Ethunasia? - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

46

Views

3k

Users

21

Frequent Posters

RiyaDutt thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: mistletoe

Anu Ben, I haven't watched KTH till date, but nowadays I see the recap on SBS...Why the hell has Kashish married that Old Fogie???

Oh yes, coming back to topic, I hate Ekta's revenge machines too......Sorry to sound so regressive, but I like the idea of Men taking revenge and Woman being all caring and sweet and nice.....something which I can never be in all my life!

Again coming back to topic, I was just putting across a point of view....I have posted elsehwere that Bani is not really capable of revenge.....and that too with Jai???? I mean, she loves him to death....It would be a total OOC thing if Bani turns into some kind of a Maha-Kaali trying to even out Bhairav Walia's head!

But at the same time, Bani won't let go of it......She will continue staying with Jai till Massi goes away and refuse to accept his love.....

Hey, you guys forgot an important thing....Remember the Astrologer's Prediction : That Jai's hands showed a major accident....Now, I am sure it was in reference to a future accident and not the one that happened! But the same astrologer also predicted a lifetime of happiness and a very fulfilling happy married life for Bani and a husband who's love will be her greatest strenght!

Could it be that, Bani goes away from Jai's life and he has a major accident and Bani comes back to him......

I remember a lovely and emotional scene from the movie Tum Bin, where the Hero Shekhar who was guilty of accidentally killing the Heroine's Fiancee, confess's his love to her on the phone and then tells that he had killed her Fiancee....and then he breaks down crying on the phone and suddenly is hit by a speeding truck......(He is drunk and is wandering in a highway)

The Herione forgets all misgivings and rushes to be at his side in the Hospital and tells him that what she has lost has been lost and she doens't want to lose him now.....

OMG, it was one of the classiest confession scene I had seen.......I wish something on these lines happen.....If Jai has an accident, then I guess it will even out things.....

Just a thought...

MT

PS: You know why I used the Gujrati word "Ben" today, my Khabari told me that Ram teases Prachi and calls her "Bani Ben" on the Sets!😆 My God, such a prankster.......😆



😆 lol MT ben...u r also sucha prankster 😆😆
RiyaDutt thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: nibbles

hmm...interesting thought hun...it could be...but again...whenever Jai used to think of Bani's mum...it was always with fondness...never with guilt!!


yup...u r rite...this is one thing that has got my head spinnnin
soap-critic thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#43

As regards mercy killing there are always two sides to this issue. While one side firmly believes it is murder the other side believes it is better for the person to be free from a fate worse than death.

Maybe in the first part they have shown one side of the issue according to Sandy's view. Then they may show the other side of the issue - if in fact something like that happened. That way Ekta can show both sides in this serial to give voice to her beliefs and in reply to people who opposed it when she showed it before.

Also Jai would not have pulled the plug on a vertilator himself - a doctor has to be involved to do something like that. Sandy's statement in the episode is just the tip of the iceberg - I am sure there is a lot more to the issue than that.

They put up the murder theory as a dhamakedaar cliffhanger for the weekend so viewers stay on edge.

Edited by pinky05 - 19 years ago
RiyaDutt thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: pinky05

As regards mercy killing there are always two sides to this issue. While one side firmly believes it is murder the other side believes it is better for the person to be free from a fate worse than death.

Maybe in the first part they have shown one side of the issue according to Sandy's view. Then they may show the other side of the issue - if in fact something like that happened. That way Ekta can show both sides in this serial to give voice to her beliefs and in reply to people who opposed it when she showed it before.

Also Jai would not have pulled the plug on a vertilator himself - a doctor has to be involved to do something like that. Sandy's statement in the episode is just the tip of the iceberg - I am sure there is a lot more to the issue than that.

They put up the murder theory as a dhamakedaar cliffhanger for the weekend so viewers stay on edge.



I quite agree with u pinky...mayb ekta really wants to show both sides of mercy killing.. ..

But hey, do u remember, sandy even mentioned that jai was with a lady that tym....so in a way this has got me confused...if the lady was not roshni...then who was she...seems lyk bani's mum to me...who knows that mayb bani's mum didnt die in any accident..mayb she too was involved with jai in this raaz thing, i mean mayb she too had killed sumone with jai's help albeit not intentionally....


Gosh...am i going nuts or wat 😆

pondy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#45
While reading abt this 'mercy killing'i was wondering that if the person in hospital(banis mom as we guess)asked to do so why wud jai do it he cud hav asked the doctors of the hospital to do.Basclly the doc consult the patients famly when there's no hope in further tretmnt(as i've seen in certain films)
Then abt our couples,as MT said jai is hiding the truth frm bani but still she knew hes hiding frm her xcpt the fact that wat it is.She has some outline of it like, jai is hiding some raaz thing,smthing happend on 29thjun 7yrs back,which is connected to jai nd roshni(to some xtent hreself),it scares jai to death when it comes out(the other day he explained to bani his scare toward the truth)and also the result which affect their relationship and what i wish is that bani shdnt give chance to roshni to take over jai,i mean y'day she told she'll make jai a lonely person,Since bani is very well aware that jai is feeling guilty and ashmed abt his past so i think that she shd stand by him nd try to know what exactly happened.If she leaves him he wud be completely shattered and still hurted for wat has happend.
ok now i'll stop as i've been blabbering too much nd by the time it is revealed i wud hav gone mad.Its really driving me crazy.Its just a thought im sharing nd jai ...a murderer 😕 but as Anu said i think they'll give expltn in defence of jai.
soap-critic thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#46
Riya - Sandy does recognize Roshni - he tells Jai 'aap aur ye madam dono the us kamre me' - something like that. So Roshni was with Jai in the hospital room.Riya

They can then show Bani debating both sides and finally siding with Jai on the issue and forgiving him. However, she can still be angry at him for hiding such an important matter from her and treating the 3 sisters badly and putting her through so much torture. Pia could be shown to take the other stand of not forgiving Jai and the sisters would be in different directions.
RiyaDutt thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: pinky05

Riya - Sandy does recognize Roshni - he tells Jai 'aap aur ye madam dono the us kamre me' - something like that. So Roshni was with Jai in the hospital room.Riya

They can then show Bani debating both sides and finally siding with Jai on the issue and forgiving him. However, she can still be angry at him for hiding such an important matter from her and treating the 3 sisters badly and putting her through so much torture. Pia could be shown to take the other stand of not forgiving Jai and the sisters would be in different directions.




Does he really? Oh..i havnt seen the video as of now and hence mayb i ended up confusing myself even more...so this means that IF jai indeed killed sumone...roshni was there and involved too....

I agree with ur thoery regarding pia n bani thinking in different directions....that really seems possible ...bani being a large hearted and sensible girl, she may forgive walia after getting angry with him for a few days...however with respect to pia..i believe that u r rite sumwhere ...lets wait n watch 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".