Are we being hypocrites?

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

urvash

@urvash

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

shows with children competing must be done away with if not properly managed. It summounts to child abuse. Suicide could be the result.

Quote

beanaq

@beanaq

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: Ramyasubbu
I guess the guest judges on the show forget that these are small children. They explain and talk to them like they are talking to adults. Which is wierd. I am sure that every child out there just wants to finish their performance, hear good things about their performance. Most children are sensitive. Slightest criticism upsets them to no end. Guest judges must def think before saying harsh words to kids. infact they should boost their confidence with kind words.

they are NOT sensible as you are who understand the children much better than these Judges.

In fact it was not Salman's mistake he sang very well in the way he was taught. This is not a recording room this is the stage where children not adults performing.

Slightest criticism upsets them to no end. Guest judges must def think before saying harsh words to kids. infact they should boost their confidence with kind words.

I agree. 👍🏼

next time please get some sensible guests.

Edited by beanaq - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Mani R.

@hothot43

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Just don't get it..Agreed it is a competition, but what kind of a person makes a child cry in a childrens contest ?? Can they really sleep peaceful at night having done it deliberately ?
Sick Dramas for sake of TRPs and all that jazz..
So ya to me that Ram guy is a loser and KK sux , period.

Quote

sohan12345

@sohan12345

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

a good singer may not be a good judge. both pyare lal and Ram had not shown capability to judge. judging by the tempo of their old singing is not fair. who says the oldies is always goldie.

Quote

sohan12345

@sohan12345

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

pyarelal lives in the past. he should not have been on the set to judge. the best would have been to give him a chair and a cup of tea to sip and enjoy the present and future.

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Zahida I totally agree with your post and share same views..

About Salman-PL ji and Niladri-RS..

Quote

433796

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

We are always hypocrites. KK made his critics himself by showing bad behavior on the set. I am fine with creative criticism, after watching so many months we should be intelligent enough to judge a singer instead of some by some comments at this stage. Payarelal ji comment was not for Salman only, it was for Kailash and his band to know at what scale that song should be sung. At this stage Salman needs good guidance and training but I think Kailash is not providing that.

Quote

musica10

@musica10

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

I think what Pyarelal ji said was ok. He was trying to give constructive feedback and he did not make Salman cry. Should judges always praise the kids? Then why get a judge who knows music? Anyone can praise a song.

When Sonu Nigam and Suresh Wadkar were the gurus for Lil Champs, they gave useful feedback. This season I only see JA giving technical comments. KK's comments are almost always tough for the kids to comprehend and Adnan is too nice to say anything negative.

Quote

Mrs. Roy

@mdroy

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

I finally found it on youtube as my DVR cut it off.

Let me start by saying Ram was harsh but was truthful about Niladri's unintelligible lyrics. The kid who sang that amazing bandish and Puchho Na Kaise could have done better and in any case chosen a better song.

We are hypocrites because Azmat is held to a completely different standard. When he was Jiya Dhadak, he could not even pronounce it correctly. Same with Madhuban Me Radhika. Every song he sings is ruined for me because either his speech impediment or frankly because sometimes he goes off tune. Yes whether it is Sniti or Azmat, as Ram said pronunciation matters.

Azmat's strengths are his natural murikyas and his concentration in trying. I think he is also 11 and because he is smaller he gets away with more. Maybe his sad story of no education or malnutrition or whatever it is makes people more forgiving. I mean Niladri is fat and privileged so he probably should be held to a higher standard. Niladri's teacher is the teacher of Aneek and Anwesha so I guess in that comparison he fell short. I don't want to pick a fight nor hurt anyone's feelings but Azmat IMO does not deserve to be in the final 3 and I will be heartbroken if either Nitin or Salman don't win.

Quote

san2471

@san2471

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: mdroy
I finally found it on youtube as my DVR cut it off.

Let me start by saying Ram was harsh but was truthful about Niladri's unintelligible lyrics. The kid who sang that amazing bandish and Puchho Na Kaise could have done better and in any case chosen a better song.

We are hypocrites because Azmat is held to a completely different standard. When he was Jiya Dhadak, he could not even pronounce it correctly. Same with Madhuban Me Radhika. Every song he sings is ruined for me because either his speech impediment or frankly because sometimes he goes off tune. Yes whether it is Sniti or Azmat, as Ram said pronunciation matters.

Azmat's strengths are his natural murikyas and his concentration in trying. I think he is also 11 and because he is smaller he gets away with more. Maybe his sad story of no education or malnutrition or whatever it is makes people more forgiving. I mean Niladri is fat and privileged so he probably should be held to a higher standard. Niladri's teacher is the teacher of Aneek and Anwesha so I guess in that comparison he fell short. I don't want to pick a fight nor hurt anyone's feelings but Azmat IMO does not deserve to be in the final 3 and I will be heartbroken if either Nitin or Salman don't win.

I could not have agreed more!! You are absolutely bang on...I dont think, Niladri has a say in choosing the song, it must be the channel and the guru. He is a kid and just got carried away by the performance. Ram was true in what he said, but his tone could have been different, the receiver was a 11 yr old boy!! He does share the same guru as Aneek and Anwesha but they came on stage when Aneek was 17 and Answesha 13 and here he is only 11. I am sure he has time to improve and my heart goes out that he travels from far suburbs of Ashoknagar (almost near (Bongaon) to Kolkata many times a week to get trained.

Frankly, without hurting anyone, while I recognize and respect Azmat's inborn talent, I cannot enjoy the song he sings, still needs time to mature. His branch of the family may be poor and he belongs to the family of famous Ghazal singers ( Ahmed Hussain and Mohammed Hussain) who are his father's elder brothers whereas all the others like Salman, Nitin and Niladri are first generation singers. This is a fact and does not or should not matter in choosing the right talent!! I have read comments that Azmat is 10 and sings 70% so he should win and Salman and Nitin are 13/14 and are at 90%+ singing capability so they dont deserve it for their age!! This is heart breaking and I just hope, everyone votes wisely!!

Quote

1 2

Are we being hypocrites? - Page 2

Related Topics

Explore Topics